Ripbin
Scan

Ad disclosure: As an eBay Partner Network affiliate, Ripbin earns from qualifying purchases. Learn more

🔥 Hot buys on eBay

See all →

As an eBay Partner Network affiliate, Ripbin earns from qualifying purchases.

Brandon McCarthy card values & price guide

Brandon McCarthy has 151 cards tracked; the most valuable is the 2005 Leaf Limited Brandon McCarthy #191 at $50.00 as of November 5, 2026.

151 cards · 52 sets · 2005–2024

Share

Live eBay listings

As an eBay Partner Network affiliate, Ripbin earns from qualifying purchases.
Brandon McCarthy

Brandon McCarthy career

Starting pitcher

Brandon McCarthy is a starting pitcher, born July 7, 1983.

Born
July 7, 1983
College
Lamar Community College
Nationality
United States

Teams

Arizona Diamondbacks, Athletics, Atlanta Braves, Chicago White Sox, Los Angeles Dodgers, New York Yankees, Sacramento River Cats, Texas Rangers

Facts from Wikidata

Prices last updated Nov 2026

Cards tracked
151
Highest value
$50.00
Value range
$0–$50
Median value
$1
PSA 10 avg
$16
With recorded sales
39

Most valuable Brandon McCarthy cards

Top 10 by value

Earliest cards (2005)

The earliest Brandon McCarthy cards in our catalog, ranked by value.

By price

All prices

CardYearValue
2005 Leaf Limited#1912005$50.00
2005 Leaf Limited · Gold#1912005$25.84
2018 Topps Chrome Sapphire Edition Base Set · Red#3382018$16.26
2015 Topps · Black#4312015$11.99
2005 Bowman Chrome · Refractor#2302005$10.99
2014 Topps#2912024$7.72
2015 Topps · Snow Camo#4312015$7.44
2017 Topps Heritage Base Set · Blue Border#5072017$7.20
2017 Topps Heritage Base Set · Bright Yellow Back#5072017$6.23
2005 Leaf Limited · Silver#1842005$5.40
2005 Leaf Limited · Autograph#1912005$4.50
2008 Topps#1562008$4.48
2014 Topps Chrome Update Brandon McCarthy Black Refractor #MB-55 card2014 Topps Chrome Update · Black Refractor#MB-552014$4.35
2013 Topps · Black#4062013$3.99
2005 Upper Deck Reflections · Turquoise#2062005$3.99
Show all 60 cards in this table
2005 Leaf Limited · Bronze#1912005$3.69
2013 Topps · Orange#4062013$3.42
2007 Upper Deck · Predictor Silver#9812007$3.41
2005 Bowman Chrome · Xfractor#2302005$3.39
2005 Leaf Limited · Bronze#1842005$2.99
2011 Topps Update · Cognac Diamond Anniversary#US1072011$2.91
2014 Topps Chrome Update · Gold#MB-552014$2.84
2005 Bowman's Best Brandon McCarthy Autograph #124 card2005 Bowman's Best · Autograph#1242005$2.64
2018 Topps Update Base Set Brandon McCarthy Black #US224 card2018 Topps Update Base Set · Black#US2242018$2.50
2005 Leaf Limited · Silver#1912005$2.50
2013 Topps · Silver Slate Blue Sparkle#4062013$2.50
2013 Topps · Pink#4062013$2.49
2012 Bowman Brandon McCarthy #15 card2012 Bowman#152012$1.98
2005 Bowman Sterling Brandon McCarthy Autograph Relic #BS-BM card2005 Bowman Sterling · Autograph Relic#BS-BM2005$1.87
2012 Topps#732012$1.85
2018 Topps Chrome Sapphire Edition Base Set#3382018$1.79
2005 Topps Updates & Highlights#UH2642005$1.73
2013 Topps · Blue#4062013$1.69
2008 Upper Deck Base Set#2122008$1.65
2005 Bowman#2302005$1.60
2018 Topps Update Base Set Brandon McCarthy #US224 card2018 Topps Update Base Set#US2242018$1.55
2015 Topps · Gold#4312015$1.49
2005 Bowman's Best Brandon McCarthy Autograph Green #124 card2005 Bowman's Best · Autograph Green#1242005$1.48
2005 Bowman Chrome#2302005$1.40
2014 Topps Update#US592014$1.31
2013 Topps#4062013$1.27
2015 Topps#4312015$1.25
2012 Topps Heritage#3382012$1.13
2007 Topps#5742007$1.10
2015 Topps · Pink#4312015$1.04
2013 Topps · Camo#4062013$1.00
2017 Topps Heritage Base Set#5072017$0.99
2018 Topps Heritage Base Set Brandon McCarthy #259 card2018 Topps Heritage Base Set#2592018$0.99
2014 Topps Heritage Brandon McCarthy #95 card2014 Topps Heritage#952014$0.99
2016 Topps Mini Base Set#3342016$0.99
2013 Topps Gypsy Queen · Mini Black#2862013$0.90
2013 Topps Heritage#1922013$0.90
2010 Topps#6602010$0.87
2015 Topps Heritage Base Set#1692015$0.67
2010 Upper Deck#5042010$0.25
2014 Topps Update#US-592014$0.25
2013 Topps · Gold#4062013$0.25
2005 Donruss Champions Brandon McCarthy #370 card2005 Donruss Champions#3702005$0.25
2010 Topps · Black#6602010$0.25
2013 Topps · Purple#4062013$0.25

Showing the top 60 of 151 cards. View all Brandon McCarthy card prices (151 cards) →

By year

Popular sets

Related articles

More Baseball players

Frequently asked questions

How much more is a PSA 10 Brandon McCarthy card worth?
Across Brandon McCarthy cards we track with both raw and PSA 10 prices, a PSA 10 sells for roughly 8.7× the ungraded price, averaging about $16. Grading pristine copies can pay off — check each card's grade ladder first.