The 10 Most Valuable Brandon McCarthy Cards
The most valuable Brandon McCarthy card is the 2005 Leaf Limited Brandon McCarthy #191 at $50.00 as of October 22, 2026.
By Ripbin Research · Updated 2026-10-22 · prices from live market data
See all Brandon McCarthy cards & valuesShop Brandon McCarthy cards on eBay
Affiliate — we may earn a commissionThe 10 most valuable Brandon McCarthy cards in the Ripbin catalog (2005–2018) carry a combined raw market value of $140.40, topped by a $50.00 card.
Just missed the cut
- #11 2005 Leaf Limited Brandon McCarthy Bronze #191$3.69
- #12 2013 Topps Brandon McCarthy Orange #406$3.42
- #13 2007 Upper Deck Brandon McCarthy Predictor Silver #981$3.41
- #14 2005 Bowman Chrome Brandon McCarthy Xfractor #230$3.39
- #15 2005 Leaf Limited Brandon McCarthy Bronze #184$2.99
- #16 2011 Topps Update Brandon McCarthy Cognac Diamond Anniversary #US107$2.91
- #17 2018 Topps Update Base Set Brandon McCarthy Black #US224$2.50
- #18 2013 Topps Brandon McCarthy Silver Slate Blue Sparkle #406$2.50
- #19 2005 Leaf Limited Brandon McCarthy Silver #191$2.50
- #20 2013 Topps Brandon McCarthy Pink #406$2.49
Sets in this guide
More Baseball guides
Most Valuable Shohei Ohtani CardsMost Valuable Aaron Judge CardsMost Valuable Ken Griffey Jr CardsMost Valuable Cy Young CardsMost Valuable Devon White CardsMost Valuable Dasan Hill CardsMost Valuable Richard Hidalgo CardsMost Valuable Glenn Otto CardsMost Valuable Jose Fermin CardsMost Valuable Mark Canha Cards