The 10 Most Valuable Pitcher's Nightmare Cards
The most valuable Pitcher's Nightmare card is the 2023 Topps Base Set Pitcher's Nightmare Golden Mirror SSP Variation #405 at $35.00 as of October 14, 2026.
By Ripbin Research · Updated 2026-10-14 · prices from live market data
Shop Pitcher's Nightmare cards on eBay
Affiliate — we may earn a commissionThe 10 most valuable Pitcher's Nightmare cards in the Ripbin catalog (2023) carry a combined raw market value of $120.16, topped by a $35.00 card.
Just missed the cut
- #11 2023 Topps Base Set Pitcher's Nightmare Orange Foil #405$2.66
- #12 2023 Topps Base Set Pitcher's Nightmare Blue Foil #405$1.99
- #13 2023 Topps Base Set Pitcher's Nightmare Gold #405$1.99
- #14 2023 Topps Base Set Pitcher's Nightmare Purple Foil #405$1.95
- #15 2023 Topps Base Set Pitcher's Nightmare All Star Game #405$1.57
- #16 2023 Topps Base Set Pitcher's Nightmare Rainbow Foil #405$1.55
- #17 2023 Topps Base Set Pitcher's Nightmare Green Foil #405$1.49
- #18 2023 Topps Base Set Pitcher's Nightmare Purple #405$1.45
- #19 2023 Topps Base Set Pitcher's Nightmare #405$1.20
- #20 2023 Topps Base Set Pitcher's Nightmare Gold Star #405$0.99
More Baseball guides
Most Valuable Shohei Ohtani CardsMost Valuable Aaron Judge CardsMost Valuable Mike Trout CardsMost Valuable Ronald Acuna Jr CardsMost Valuable Juan Soto CardsMost Valuable Bobby Witt Jr CardsMost Valuable Paul Skenes CardsMost Valuable Corbin Carroll CardsMost Valuable Fernando Tatis Jr CardsMost Valuable Mookie Betts Cards