Pitcher's Nightmare card values & price guide
Pitcher's Nightmare has 23 cards tracked; the most valuable is the 2023 Topps Base Set Pitcher's Nightmare Golden Mirror SSP Variation #405 at $35.00 as of October 23, 2026.
23 cards · 2 sets · 2023–2023
Prices last updated Oct 2026
Cards tracked
23
Highest value
$35.00
Value range
$1–$35
Median value
$3
PSA 10 avg
$8
With recorded sales
20
Most valuable Pitcher's Nightmare cards
2023 Topps Base Set
$35.00
2023 Topps Base Set
$29.99
2023 Topps Base Set
$17.12
2023 Topps Base Set
$10.49
2023 Topps Base Set
$7.00
2023 Topps Base Set
$6.50
2023 Topps Base Set
$5.50
2023 Topps Base Set
$2.91
Top 10 by value
Earliest cards (2023)
The earliest Pitcher's Nightmare cards in our catalog, ranked by value.
| Card | Year | Value |
|---|---|---|
| 2023 Topps Base Set · Golden Mirror SSP Variation#405 | 2023 | $35.00 |
| 2023 Topps Base Set · Memorial Day Camo#405 | 2023 | $29.99 |
| 2023 Topps Base Set · Mother's Day Pink#405 | 2023 | $17.12 |
| 2023 Topps Base Set · Black#405 | 2023 | $10.49 |
| 2023 Topps Base Set · Vintage Stock#405 | 2023 | $7.00 |
| 2023 Topps Base Set · Father's Day Blue#405 | 2023 | $6.50 |
| 2023 Topps Base Set · Independence Day#405 | 2023 | $5.50 |
| 2023 Topps Chrome Sapphire · Orange#405 | 2023 | $3.72 |
By price
All prices
| Card | Year | Value |
|---|---|---|
| 2023 Topps Base Set · Golden Mirror SSP Variation#405 | 2023 | $35.00 |
| 2023 Topps Base Set · Memorial Day Camo#405 | 2023 | $29.99 |
| 2023 Topps Base Set · Mother's Day Pink#405 | 2023 | $17.12 |
| 2023 Topps Base Set · Black#405 | 2023 | $10.49 |
| 2023 Topps Base Set · Vintage Stock#405 | 2023 | $7.00 |
| 2023 Topps Base Set · Father's Day Blue#405 | 2023 | $6.50 |
| 2023 Topps Base Set · Independence Day#405 | 2023 | $5.50 |
| 2023 Topps Chrome Sapphire · Orange#405 | 2023 | $3.72 |
| 2023 Topps Base Set · Gold Foil#405 | 2023 | $2.91 |
 2023 Topps Base Set · Red Foil#405 | 2023 | $2.78 |
| 2023 Topps Base Set · Royal Blue#405 | 2023 | $2.75 |
 2023 Topps Base Set · Orange Foil#405 | 2023 | $2.66 |
 2023 Topps Base Set · Gold#405 | 2023 | $1.99 |
 2023 Topps Base Set · Blue Foil#405 | 2023 | $1.99 |
 2023 Topps Base Set · Purple Foil#405 | 2023 | $1.95 |
