| Joe DI Maggio, Charley Keller | $314.99 | — | — | — |
| Ted Williams, Joe Cronin | $294.00 | $14,484.89 | $97,185.08 | $126,341.00 |
| Ted Williams, Jim Tabor | $292.00 | — | — | — |
| Johnny Mize, Enos Slaughter | $189.56 | $9,078.57 | $60,898.04 | $79,167.00 |
| Harold Reese, Kirby Higbe | $182.35 | — | — | — |
| Lefty Grove, Bobby Doerr | $156.50 | — | — | — |
| Lefty Gomez, Phil Rizzuto | $138.07 | $6,811.25 | $45,680.08 | $59,384.00 |
| Hank Greenberg, Red Ruffing | $112.61 | $5,554.59 | $37,245.14 | $48,419.00 |
| Joe Cronin, Jimmy Foxx | $105.00 | $5,180.96 | $34,737.44 | $45,159.00 |
| Joe Krakauskas, Bob Feller | $90.00 | $4,442.05 | $29,777.90 | $38,711.00 |
| Johnny Mize, Dan Litwhiler | $73.00 | — | — | — |
| Morris Arnovich, Carl Hubbell | $69.69 | — | — | — |
| Buck Newsom, Hank Greenberg | $69.00 | — | — | — |
| Mel Ott, Burgess Whitehead | $69.00 | $3,407.76 | $22,835.75 | $29,686.00 |
| Mel Ott, Babe Young | $64.69 | $3,154.05 | $21,132.94 | $27,473.00 |
| Barney McCosky, Charley Gehringer | $63.00 | — | — | — |
| Red Rolfe, Bill Dickey | $51.00 | $2,521.63 | $16,888.05 | $21,954.00 |
| Joe Gordon, Red Ruffing | $47.00 | $2,230.66 | $14,935.09 | $19,416.00 |
| Tommy Henrich, Marius Russo | $46.69 | — | — | — |
| Lew Riggs, Leo Durocher | $45.00 | — | — | — |
| Dixie Walker, Ducky Medwick | $44.00 | — | — | — |
| Lee Handley, Arky Vaughan | $40.00 | $1,980.29 | $13,254.60 | $17,231.00 |
| Frank Crosetti, John Sturm | $39.50 | $521.00 | — | — |
| Joe Gordon, Charley Keller | $39.11 | $1,932.28 | $12,932.34 | $16,812.00 |
| Lloyd Waner, Henry Majeski | $36.45 | — | — | — |
| Mike Tresh, Luke Appling | $31.25 | $1,548.91 | $10,359.17 | $13,467.00 |
| Harry Lavagetto, Harold Reiser | $30.41 | — | — | — |
| Frank Pytlak, Dom DI Maggio | $30.00 | — | — | — |
| Rolly Hemsley, Mel Harder | $30.00 | — | — | — |
| Mickey Owen, Paul Waner | $26.46 | $1,313.07 | $8,776.16 | $11,409.00 |
| Billy Herman, Stanley Hack | $25.26 | — | — | — |
| Gerald Priddy, John Murphy | $23.95 | $1,249.84 | $8,351.80 | $10,857.00 |
| Harry Danning, Cliff Melton | $23.51 | $1,171.65 | $7,826.95 | $10,175.00 |
| Jimmy Ripple, Ernie Lombardi | $23.00 | $1,142.56 | $7,631.71 | $9,921.00 |
| Don Heffner, Harland Clift | $22.59 | — | — | — |
| John Cooney, Sibby Sisti | $22.50 | $1,118.14 | $7,467.86 | $9,708.00 |
| Linus Frey, John Vander Meer | $22.03 | $1,095.21 | $7,313.97 | $9,508.00 |
| John Rucker, Ace Adams | $21.95 | — | — | — |
| Paul Derringer, Bucky Walters | $21.86 | $1,090.89 | $7,284.92 | $9,470.00 |
| Fred Fitzsimmons, Joe Vosmik | $21.73 | — | — | — |
| Jimmy Wasdell, Dolph Camilli | $21.73 | $1,080.10 | $7,212.49 | $9,376.00 |
| Harry Gumbert, Burgess Whitehead | $21.33 | — | — | — |
| Max West, Carvel Rowell | $21.19 | $1,250.84 | $8,358.53 | $10,866.00 |
| Buddy Hassett, Eugene Moore | $20.74 | — | — | — |
| Frank Mccormick, Bill Werber | $20.00 | — | — | — |
| Nick Etten, John Rizzo | $19.30 | — | — | — |
| Buddy Meyer, Ben Chapman | $18.07 | $903.78 | $6,029.04 | $7,838.00 |
| Debs Garms, Elbert Fletcher | $17.97 | — | — | — |
| Bob Klinger, Stanley Brown | $17.90 | $890.32 | $5,938.67 | $7,720.00 |
| Pinky Higgins, Dick Bartell | $17.86 | $894.18 | $5,964.62 | $7,754.00 |
| Terry Moore, Gus Mancuso | $17.30 | $849.14 | $5,662.29 | $7,361.00 |
| Hal Trotsky, George Case | $16.81 | — | — | — |
| Nelson Potter, Benny McCoy | $16.80 | $837.28 | $5,582.70 | $7,258.00 |
| Larry French, Vance Page | $16.55 | $824.82 | $5,499.07 | $7,149.00 |
| Gerald Walker, Joe Heving | $16.50 | $1,023.36 | $6,831.68 | $8,881.00 |
| Alex Kampouris, John Wyatt | $16.50 | $822.61 | $5,484.26 | $7,130.00 |
| John Babich, Richard Siebert | $15.99 | — | — | — |
| Frank Hayes, Al Brancato | $15.82 | $788.94 | $5,258.23 | $6,836.00 |
| Joe Orengo, Joe Moore | $15.43 | $774.42 | $5,160.78 | $6,709.00 |
| Sam Chapman, Wally Moses | $15.27 | $762.20 | $5,078.75 | $6,602.00 |
| Jimmy Ripple, Bucky Walters | $15.14 | $749.63 | $4,994.38 | $6,493.00 |
| Moose Solters, John Rigney | $15.09 | $753.28 | $5,018.91 | $6,525.00 |
| Ival Goodman, Myron McCormick | $15.02 | — | — | — |
| Stanley Hack, Bob Klinger | $14.99 | — | — | — |
| Bob Johnson, Bill Nagel | $14.70 | $734.09 | $4,890.09 | $6,357.00 |
| Frank Crespi, Jim Brown | $14.14 | — | — | — |
| Ken Keltner, Hal Trosky | $14.01 | $675.00 | $4,493.49 | $5,842.00 |
| Harry Danning, Harry Gumbert | $12.75 | $638.04 | $4,245.38 | $5,519.00 |
| Eddie Joost, Ernest Koy | $12.52 | — | — | — |
| Cecil Travis, George Case | $11.44 | $573.52 | $3,812.32 | $4,956.00 |
| Babe Young, Cliff Melton | $9.71 | $488.27 | $3,240.17 | $4,212.00 |
| Bill Lee, Phil Cavarretta | $9.50 | — | — | — |
| Danny Litwhiler, Merrill May | $6.88 | — | — | — |
| C. Campbell, Louis Boudreau | — | — | — | — |
| Cookie Lavagetto, Harold Reiser | — | — | — | — |
| F. Fitzsimmons, Joe Vosmik | — | — | — | — |
| D. Dallessandro, Augie Galan | — | — | — | — |