Cards tracked
15
With a value
15
Value range
$36–$375
Median value
$177
PSA 10 vs raw
~4.8×
Ripbin tracks 15 priced cards from 2025 Finest Nightmare Fuel, with values from $36 to $375 — the top 10 cards account for 83% of the set's tracked value.
Prices last updated Aug 2026
Shop 2025 Finest Nightmare Fuel on eBay
Affiliate — we may earn a commissionThe 2025 Finest Nightmare Fuel set includes 15 cards in the Football category. Notable cards include Myles Garrett, Maxx Crosby, Reggie White.
Browse the complete checklist below with current market values for every card. Click any card for its full grade ladder — PSA, BGS, CGC and SGC — and live eBay listings.
Most valuable 2025 Finest Nightmare Fuel cards
Price distribution
Under $250 (0%)
$25–$1003 (20%)
$100–$50012 (80%)
$500+0 (0%)
| Card | Ungraded | PSA 9 | PSA 10 | BGS 10 |
|---|---|---|---|---|
 Myles Garrett#NF-3 | $540.00 | $770.04 | $2,235.24 | $2,906.00 |
 Maxx Crosby#NF-6 | $325.00 | $352.83 | $1,022.63 | $1,329.00 |
 Reggie White#NF-12 | $325.00 | $404.76 | $1,175.41 | $1,528.00 |
 Micah Parsons#NF-5 | $225.00 | $365.14 | $1,059.98 | $1,378.00 |
 T.J. Watt#NF-7 | $275.00 | $364.69 | $1,057.19 | $1,374.00 |
 Fred Warner#NF-8 | $225.00 | $373.63 | $1,083.94 | $1,409.00 |
 Ray Lewis#NF-13 | $165.00 | $358.53 | $1,040.41 | $1,353.00 |
 Pat Surtain II#NF-9 | $177.38 | $309.04 | $895.66 | $1,164.00 |
 Aidan Hutchinson#NF-4 | $169.24 | $310.87 | $902.29 | $1,173.00 |
 Brian Urlacher#NF-15 | $195.06 | $266.42 | $773.73 | $1,006.00 |
 Lawrence Taylor#NF-11 | $157.50 | $258.38 | $749.61 | $974.00 |
 Troy Polamalu#NF-14 | $131.48 | $250.31 | $449.99 | $943.00 |
 Chris Jones#NF-1 | $81.79 | $175.62 | $509.94 | $663.00 |
 Trey Hendrickson#NF-2 | $50.00 | $96.68 | $280.96 | $365.00 |
 Sauce Gardner#NF-10 | $36.39 | $67.39 | $196.27 | $255.00 |
Frequently asked questions
- What is the most valuable card in 2025 Finest Nightmare Fuel?
- The most valuable card in 2025 Finest Nightmare Fuel is the Myles Garrett #NF-3, worth around $375.00 ungraded — graded copies sell for more.
- How many cards are in 2025 Finest Nightmare Fuel?
- Ripbin tracks 15 2025 Finest Nightmare Fuel cards, 15 of them with current values. Browse the full list above.
- How much are 2025 Finest Nightmare Fuel cards worth?
- 2025 Finest Nightmare Fuel cards range from $36 to $375, with a median value of $177. The top 10 cards hold about 83% of the set's tracked value.
- Is it worth grading 2025 Finest Nightmare Fuel cards?
- Across 2025 Finest Nightmare Fuel cards we track with both raw and PSA 10 prices, a PSA 10 sells for roughly 4.8× the ungraded price. Grading pristine copies can pay off — check each card's grade ladder before submitting.
More in 2025 Finest — inserts & parallels
Base Set300 cardsRookie Finest Autographs52 cards1992 Finest44 cardsFinest Autographs39 cardsFlashback Autographs38 cardsFinest Greats Autographs35 cardsCreators30 cardsTorchers30 cardsFinest Moments Autographs26 cardsFramed White25 cardsThe Man20 cardsReflash20 cardsLandmark Metal Series20 cardsHeadliners15 cardsSmashing Through15 cardsCenturions15 cardsFor the Record10 cardsPower Kings10 cardsFinest Freshman Autographs10 cardsTeam Finest10 cardsFinest Fans Autographs9 cardsFinest Fan Autographs9 cards
Notable players in 2025 Finest Nightmare Fuel
Explore 2025 Finest Nightmare Fuel
2025 Finest Nightmare Fuel live on eBay
Affiliate — we may earn a commissionOther 2025 sets
- 2025 Panini Honors Recollection Collection checklist & values652 cards
- 2024 Panini Select Base Set checklist & values500 cards
- 2025 Panini Select Base Set checklist & values500 cards
- 2025 Panini Honors Originals/Update Autographs checklist & values499 cards
- 2025 Panini Prizm Base Set checklist & values442 cards
- 2024 Score Base Set checklist & values406 cards
- 2024 Panini Prestige Base Set checklist & values401 cards
- 2024 Donruss Base Set checklist & values400 cards