Ripbin
Scan

Ad disclosure: As an eBay Partner Network affiliate, Ripbin earns from qualifying purchases. Learn more

🔥 Hot buys on eBay

See all →

As an eBay Partner Network affiliate, Ripbin earns from qualifying purchases.

2025 Finest Nightmare Fuel

Football · 15 cards · checklist & values · released May 2026

Part of 2025 Finest Football →

All 2025 Football cards →

Myles Garrett, 2025 Finest Nightmare FuelMicah Parsons, 2025 Finest Nightmare FuelT.J. Watt, 2025 Finest Nightmare Fuel2025 Finest Nightmare Fuel sealed box
Box photo: eBay listing
Cards tracked
15
With a value
15
Value range
$30–$279
Median value
$143
PSA 10 vs raw
~4.5×

Ripbin tracks 15 priced cards from 2025 Finest Nightmare Fuel, with values from $30 to $279 — the top 10 cards account for 86% of the set's tracked value.

Prices last updated Oct 2026

Shop 2025 Finest Nightmare Fuel on eBay

As an eBay Partner Network affiliate, Ripbin earns from qualifying purchases.

The 2025 Finest Nightmare Fuel set includes 15 cards in the Football category. Notable cards include Myles Garrett, Micah Parsons, Maxx Crosby.

Browse the complete checklist below with current market values for every card. Click any card for its full grade ladder — PSA, BGS, CGC and SGC — and live eBay listings.

Most valuable 2025 Finest Nightmare Fuel cards

Browse 2025 Finest Nightmare Fuel singles on eBay ↗

Price distribution

Under $250 (0%)
$25–$1004 (27%)
$100–$50011 (73%)
$500+0 (0%)
CardUngradedPSA 9PSA 10BGS 10
2025 Finest Nightmare Fuel Myles Garrett #NF-3 cardMyles Garrett#NF-3$279.18$442.14$1,254.37$1,631.00
2025 Finest Nightmare Fuel Micah Parsons #NF-5 cardMicah Parsons#NF-5$252.50$400.61$1,135.90$1,477.00
Maxx Crosby#NF-6$249.97$395.86$1,119.59$1,455.00
2025 Finest Nightmare Fuel T.J. Watt #NF-7 cardT.J. Watt#NF-7$183.75$294.19$834.39$1,085.00
2025 Finest Nightmare Fuel Fred Warner #NF-8 cardFred Warner#NF-8$182.50$291.98$827.16$1,075.00
Aidan Hutchinson#NF-4$150.00$241.61$290.00$377.00
2025 Finest Nightmare Fuel Troy Polamalu #NF-14 cardTroy Polamalu#NF-14$145.89$148.00$178.00$231.00
2025 Finest Nightmare Fuel Lawrence Taylor #NF-11 cardLawrence Taylor#NF-11$142.65$230.23$652.00$848.00
2025 Finest Nightmare Fuel Ray Lewis #NF-13 cardRay Lewis#NF-13$134.99$218.38$618.43$804.00
2025 Finest Nightmare Fuel Pat Surtain II #NF-9 cardPat Surtain II#NF-9$120.00$199.06$563.76$733.00
2025 Finest Nightmare Fuel Reggie White #NF-12 cardReggie White#NF-12$106.15$174.09$228.50$297.00
2025 Finest Nightmare Fuel Brian Urlacher #NF-15 cardBrian Urlacher#NF-15$86.46$142.95$406.08$528.00
2025 Finest Nightmare Fuel Chris Jones #NF-1 cardChris Jones#NF-1$48.49$85.04$197.50$257.00
Sauce Gardner#NF-10$34.37$63.13$180.30$234.00
Trey Hendrickson#NF-2$30.00$59.33$169.52$220.00

Frequently asked questions

What is the most valuable card in 2025 Finest Nightmare Fuel?
The most valuable card in 2025 Finest Nightmare Fuel is the Myles Garrett #NF-3, worth around $279.18 ungraded — graded copies sell for more.
How many cards are in 2025 Finest Nightmare Fuel?
Ripbin tracks 15 2025 Finest Nightmare Fuel cards, 15 of them with current values. Browse the full list above.
How much are 2025 Finest Nightmare Fuel cards worth?
2025 Finest Nightmare Fuel cards range from $30 to $279, with a median value of $143. The top 10 cards hold about 86% of the set's tracked value.
Is it worth grading 2025 Finest Nightmare Fuel cards?
Across 2025 Finest Nightmare Fuel cards we track with both raw and PSA 10 prices, a PSA 10 sells for roughly 4.5× the ungraded price. Grading pristine copies can pay off — check each card's grade ladder before submitting.

More in 2025 Finest — inserts & parallels

Notable players in 2025 Finest Nightmare Fuel

Explore 2025 Finest Nightmare Fuel

2025 Finest Nightmare Fuel live on eBay

As an eBay Partner Network affiliate, Ripbin earns from qualifying purchases.