The 10 Most Valuable 2025 Finest Nightmare Fuel Football Cards
The most valuable 2025 Finest Nightmare Fuel Football card is the 2025 Finest Nightmare Fuel Myles Garrett #NF-3 at $279.18 as of October 8, 2026.
By Ripbin Research · Updated 2026-10-08 · prices from live market data
Shop 2025 Finest Nightmare Fuel Football cards on eBay
Affiliate — we may earn a commissionThe 10 most valuable 2025 Finest Nightmare Fuel Football cards in the Ripbin catalog carry a combined raw market value of $1,907.61, topped by a $279.18 card.
#12025 Finest Nightmare Fuel Myles Garrett #NF-3
$279.18PSA 10 ~$1,692.81
#22025 Finest Nightmare Fuel Micah Parsons #NF-5
$252.50PSA 10 ~$1,031.53- 🃏
#32025 Finest Nightmare Fuel Maxx Crosby #NF-6
$249.97PSA 10 ~$1,138.90 
#42025 Finest Nightmare Fuel T.J. Watt #NF-7
$224.99PSA 10 ~$1,033.35
#52025 Finest Nightmare Fuel Fred Warner #NF-8
$181.48PSA 10 ~$839.27
#62025 Finest Nightmare Fuel Brian Urlacher #NF-15
$162.44PSA 10 ~$753.55- 🃏
#72025 Finest Nightmare Fuel Aidan Hutchinson #NF-4
$150.00PSA 10 ~$694.91 
#82025 Finest Nightmare Fuel Lawrence Taylor #NF-11
$140.17PSA 10 ~$648.91
#92025 Finest Nightmare Fuel Reggie White #NF-12
$136.78PSA 10 ~$603.35
#102025 Finest Nightmare Fuel Troy Polamalu #NF-14
$130.10PSA 10 ~$610.59
Just missed the cut
More Football guides
Most Valuable Patrick Mahomes Ii CardsMost Valuable Josh Allen CardsMost Valuable Justin Herbert CardsMost Valuable Joe Burrow CardsMost Valuable Justin Jefferson CardsMost Valuable Jalen Hurts CardsMost Valuable Lamar Jackson CardsMost Valuable Trevor Lawrence CardsMost Valuable Aaron Rodgers CardsMost Valuable Tom Brady Cards