Payton Tolle card values & price guide
Payton Tolle has 69 cards tracked; the most valuable is the 2026 Topps All Aces Payton Tolle #AA-19 at $461.55 as of September 1, 2026.
69 cards · 58 sets · 2024–2026
Shop Payton Tolle cards on eBay
Affiliate — we may earn a commissionRipbin tracks 24 priced Payton Tolle cards worth $1–$462 — the top 10 account for 91% of tracked value; PSA 10 copies trade ~7.7× raw.
Prices last updated Sep 2026
Cards tracked
69
Highest value
$461.55
Value range
$1–$462
Median value
$20
PSA 10 avg
$321
With recorded sales
6
Payton Tolle has 69 baseball cards in the Ripbin catalog across 58 sets, valued $0.99–$461.55, topped by the 2026 Topps All Aces Payton Tolle #AA-19 at about $461.55 ungraded.
Most valuable Payton Tolle cards
2026 Topps All Aces
$461.55
2026 Topps Real One Autographs
$110.00
2024 Bowman Draft Chrome Prospect Autograph
$90.00
2026 Topps Heritage Real One Autographs
$89.25
2024 Bowman Draft Chrome Prospect Autographs
$84.21
2026 Topps Major League Material Autographs
$79.00
2026 Topps Baseball Stars Autographs
$78.49
2026 Topps Tier One Break Out Autographs
$64.72
Top 10 most valuable Payton Tolle cards
Payton Tolle's earliest cards (2024)
The earliest Payton Tolle cards in our catalog — their rookie-year issues — ranked by value.
Payton Tolle cards by price
Affordable under $2512 cards
$25–$10010 cards
- 2024 Bowman Draft Chrome Prospect Autograph #CPA-PT$90.00
- 2026 Topps Heritage Real One Autographs #ROA-PT$89.25
- 2024 Bowman Draft Chrome Prospect Autographs #CPA-PT$84.21
- 2026 Topps Major League Material Autographs #MLM2-PT$79.00
- 2026 Topps Baseball Stars Autographs #BSA-PT$78.49
- 2026 Topps Tier One Break Out Autographs #BOA-PT$64.72
Recent Payton Tolle price movers
Biggest 90-day price changes among tracked cards.
| Card | 90-day | Value |
|---|---|---|
| 2026 Topps Chrome Black Nocturnal #NOC-14 | +151% | $150.50 |
| 2026 Topps Heritage Real One Autographs #ROA-PT | +65% | $147.50 |
| 2026 Topps Baseball Stars Autographs #BSA-PT | +21% | $95.00 |
Payton Tolle card prices
Showing the top 60 of 69 cards. View all Payton Tolle card prices (69 cards) →
Payton Tolle cards by year
| Year | Cards | Top card | Value |
|---|---|---|---|
| 2026 | 39 | 2026 Topps All Aces #AA-19 | $461.55 |
| 2025 | 8 | 2025 Panini Impeccable Indelible Ink #4 | $46.25 |
| 2024 | 22 | 2024 Bowman Draft Chrome Prospect Autograph #CPA-PT | $90.00 |
Most popular sets featuring Payton Tolle
Related articles
More Baseball players
Frequently asked questions
- How much more is a PSA 10 Payton Tolle card worth?
- Across Payton Tolle cards we track with both raw and PSA 10 prices, a PSA 10 sells for roughly 7.7× the ungraded price, averaging about $321. Grading pristine copies can pay off — check each card's grade ladder first.