The 40 Best Sports Cards to Buy in October 2026, by Budget
By Ripbin Research · Updated 2026-10-17 · comps from live eBay market data
October stacks three catalysts at once: the NBA opens October 20 with the champion Knicks hosting LeBron James's Philadelphia debut, the World Series starts October 23 with Milwaukee in it for the first time in 44 years, and a new NHL season is already under way. This report gives ten picks in each of four budget bands — under $50, $50–$150, $150–$1,000 and $1,000+ — every price drawn from recent eBay comps, our daily rookie-card watcher and our catalog, in a month when a single Cooper Flagg 1/1 just sold for $8.04 million.
Shop these on eBay
As an eBay Partner Network affiliate, Ripbin earns from qualifying purchases.Every month we publish the cards our research flags as most likely to appreciate. This October edition keeps the four budget bands — a Starter tier under $50, a Budget tier from $50 to $150, a Core tier from $150 to $1,000, and a Conviction tier above $1,000 — with ten picks in each so there is a real buy list no matter what you have to spend.
The prices are not guesses. Core and Budget picks come from Ripbin's daily monitor of raw (ungraded) eBay listings for serial-numbered rookie patch and auto cards, with outlier-trimmed comps, plus a few graded rookies priced from recent eBay sold and Card Ladder data. Conviction picks come from fresh market research across eBay sold, Card Ladder, Fanatics Collect and Sports Card Investor. Starter picks are real market values from our catalog. Where a comp is thin or a few months old, we say so and give a range.
October: NBA tip-off, a Brewers World Series, hockey is back
The NBA's 2026-27 season opens Tuesday, October 20 with a tripleheader: Boston at Detroit, Philadelphia at New York — LeBron James's first game as a 76er, against a Knicks team that won its first title in 53 years in June with Jalen Brunson as unanimous Finals MVP — and Oklahoma City at San Antonio, a rematch of the West's two best young cores. Opening week is when basketball card demand resets from offseason lows, and it lands just weeks after a Cooper Flagg Topps Chrome Update Rookie Debut Patch Auto 1/1 sold for $8.04 million on Fanatics Collect, the most ever paid for a single-player basketball card.
Baseball's October belongs to Milwaukee. The Brewers swept the Dodgers 4-0 in the NLCS to reach their first World Series in 44 years, and the Series opens Friday, October 23 against the winner of a Guardians-Rays ALCS that Cleveland led 2-1 at publication. Postseason exposure is the classic short-term catalyst for young stars on the winning side — which is why Jackson Chourio and Jacob Misiorowski appear on this list — and the classic trap for buyers who pay the peak the morning after a big game.
Hockey's 84-game season opened September 29, and the first October Young Guns from Upper Deck Series 1 (October 7) are now in circulation, with No. 1 pick Gavin McKenna in Toronto drawing the headlines. On the football side, the NFL is at midseason and 2026 Topps Chrome Football, the second licensed Topps Chrome NFL release, opens pre-orders October 19, with Topps Heritage Football and Panini Obsidian Football following October 21. Basketball's October releases are 2025-26 Panini Select (October 23) and 2026 Panini Prizm WNBA (October 28); 2026-27 Topps flagship basketball has moved to November 5.
How to use the four tiers
Starter (under $50) is where a first-time buyer should begin — real, liquid cards of the same stars featured higher up. Budget ($50–$150) is our watcher's sweet spot: serial-numbered rookie patch autos of ascending players with a hard supply cap. Core ($150–$1,000) steps up to true RPAs of established young stars and gem-mint rookies of proven ones. Conviction ($1,000+) is the blue-chip and grail tier — buy fewer, hold longer.
Starter tier (under $50)

#31Cade Cunningham — 2021-22 Panini Obsidian Supernova #4
~$49~$49 (Oct 2026 catalog value)A rookie-year Obsidian insert of an All-NBA First Team point guard — the sub-$50 way onto the Cunningham market while his RPAs sit near $1,000.
- ▲Detroit's national-TV opening night.
- ▲A deep playoff run pulls demand down the whole Cunningham ladder.
- ▼Inserts appreciate slower than rookie autos and numbered parallels.

#32Bijan Robinson — 2024 Panini Select Watercolors #16
~$49~$49 (Oct 2026 catalog value)A short-printed Select insert of one of the NFL's best running backs, at starter-tier pricing.
- ▲Midseason touchdown runs keep him in fantasy and highlight coverage.
- ▲Licensed Panini football is now a closed supply.
- ▼Running back careers are short, and the market discounts the position.
Learn more: Most valuable Bijan Robinson cards

#33Chet Holmgren — 2024-25 Panini Select #1
~$49~$49 (Oct 2026 catalog value)A cheap licensed Select card of a defensive anchor on the champion-caliber Thunder, under his $650 Immaculate RPA.
- ▲Opening night at San Antonio against Wembanyama.
- ▲2025-26 Panini Select arrives October 23, putting Select back in front of collectors.
- ▼Health is the whole story with Holmgren.
#34Amen Thompson — 2023-24 Hoops Hot Signatures Rookie Auto
~$48~$48 (Oct 2026 catalog value)A rookie autograph of a young two-way wing for under $50 — the lowest price on this list for a signed rookie of a starter on a contender.
- ▲A larger role in Houston beside Durant and Sengun.
- ▲Any All-Defensive or Most Improved buzz lifts his autos.
- ▼Hoops is an entry-level product; the multiple is limited.
Learn more: Most valuable Amen Thompson cards

#35Bo Nix — 2024 Panini Impeccable #76
~$48~$48 (Oct 2026 catalog value)A premium-brand base rookie of a winning quarterback, for under $50 — the cheap side of his $137 National Treasures patch.
- ▲Midseason Broncos games and a playoff push.
- ▲Licensed Panini premium football is now a closed supply.
- ▼Base cards from premium products trade thinly.
#36Caleb Williams — 2024 Panini Prizm No Huddle #301
~$48~$48 (Oct 2026 catalog value)A rookie-year Prizm No Huddle parallel of the Bears' franchise quarterback, at a starter price while the market waits on his breakout.
- ▲A midseason Bears run would re-rate his whole rookie run.
- ▲Prizm is the reference rookie brand of his class.
- ▼If Williams doesn't break out, his rookie cards keep sliding.
Learn more: Most valuable Caleb Williams cards

#37Alex Sarr — 2025-26 Topps #96
~$48~$48 (Oct 2026 catalog value)A licensed Topps card of a former No. 2 pick and rim-protecting big man, in the first Topps NBA flagship of the Fanatics era.
- ▲A third-year jump in Washington.
- ▲2026-27 Topps flagship basketball arrives November 5 and draws attention to the first edition.
- ▼A rebuilding team limits his national exposure.
Learn more: Most valuable Alex Sarr cards

#38Connor McDavid — 2024-25 SPx Holoview F/X #HV-8
~$47~$47 (Oct 2026 catalog value)A sub-$50 insert of the best player in hockey — the cheap ticket under his $2,700-plus Young Guns rookie.
- ▲A new season already under way.
- ▲Upper Deck's October releases bring new hockey buyers in.
- ▼Inserts of established stars appreciate slowly.

#39Cedric Coward — 2025-26 Topps Chrome Stratospheric Signatures Rookies
~$43~$43 (Oct 2026 catalog value)An on-card Chrome rookie autograph of an All-Rookie First Teamer for under $50 — the cheapest signed way into the class's Chrome product.
- ▲A sophomore season starting this month.
- ▲Topps Chrome is the class's flagship rookie product.
- ▼A thin trading history means choppy price moves.

#40Barry Bonds — 2026 Topps Tier One Jersey Number Relics
~$41~$41 (Oct 2026 catalog value)A jersey relic of the all-time home run leader from a premium Topps product, for under $50. Bonds's cards carry a permanent discount that keeps relics cheap.
- ▲Hall of Fame debate returns every winter.
- ▲World Series month puts baseball nostalgia at its peak.
- ▼The Hall of Fame cloud is the reason it is cheap, and it may never lift.
Learn more: Most valuable Barry Bonds cardsBarry Bonds Rookie Card: Top 10 by Value ($46K)
Budget tier ($50–$150)
#21Cedric Coward — 2025-26 Topps Midnight Rookie Jersey Auto
~$149~$149 (Oct 2026 comp; our September comp was ~$849)The cheapest All-Rookie First Team member's first-Topps-era patch auto — on the same shelf as the class's headline rookie jersey autos at a fraction of the price. The comp has reset sharply since September.
- ▲A sophomore season starting this month.
- ▲Topps Midnight is the class's first Topps-era premium product.
- ▼A falling comp can keep falling; buy a copy with a clean patch and a sharp autograph.
Learn more: Most valuable Cedric Coward cards
#22Emeka Egbuka — 2025 Topps Chrome Rookie Patch Auto /99
~$147~$147 /99 (Oct 2026 comp)A PFWA All-Rookie receiver and Offensive Rookie of the Year finalist, priced below his production tier because quarterbacks absorb the class's hype money — in the historic first Topps Chrome NFL RPA set.
- ▲A second-year breakout in Tampa Bay.
- ▲2026 Topps Chrome Football pre-orders on October 19 bring attention back to the 2025 class.
- ▼Prefer live on-card copies over redemptions; receiver cards appreciate slower than quarterback cards.
Learn more: Most valuable Emeka Egbuka cards

#23Zach Edey — 2024-25 Immaculate RPA /99
~$137~$137 /99 (Oct 2026 comp)An on-card RPA /99 from the final licensed Immaculate, for a 7-foot-4 All-Rookie center who posted 13.6 points and 11.1 rebounds before ankle surgery. The market prices the ankle, not the production.
- ▲A healthy return in Memphis.
- ▲The last licensed Immaculate NBA RPAs gain scarcity every year.
- ▼Ankle injuries on a 7-foot-4 frame recur; the center position has a lower hobby ceiling.
Learn more: Most valuable Zach Edey cards

#24Bo Nix — 2024 National Treasures Rookie Patch /99
~$137~$137 /99 (Oct 2026 comp)A quarterback with a 14-3 season, an AFC No. 1 seed and a playoff win — and a market that still hasn't fully bought in. Efficiency doubters keep this card cheap compared with the Maye and Caleb Williams tier.
- ▲A midseason run in Denver.
- ▲Licensed Panini NFL rookies are now a closed supply.
- ▼If the efficiency doubts prove right, the quarterback discount stays.
Learn more: Most valuable Bo Nix cards

#25Collin Murray-Boyles — 2025-26 Topps Midnight Rookie Jersey Auto
~$124~$124 patch auto (Oct 2026 comp)A first-Topps-era patch auto of an All-Rookie Second Team player, on the same shelf as the class's headliners at a fraction of the price.
- ▲A larger second-year role in Toronto.
- ▲Topps Midnight becomes the reference premium set for the class.
- ▼No scoring gravity yet — a pure flier, sized like one.
Learn more: Most valuable Collin Murray-Boyles cards

#26Alperen Sengun — 2021-22 Panini Select Rookie Jersey Auto Silver /199
~$115~$115 /199 (Oct 2026 comp)A two-time All-Star (20.8 points, 9.4 rebounds, 6.3 assists) playing beside Kevin Durant, with permanent Turkish collector demand. His top-tier National Treasures RPA trades around $2,370 — an 18x gap to this card.
- ▲A contending Houston season with Durant.
- ▲2025-26 Panini Select arrives October 23 and draws attention to earlier Select rookies.
- ▼A sticker auto caps the multiple versus on-card autos.
Learn more: Most valuable Alperen Sengun cards

#27Kel'el Ware — 2024-25 Immaculate Rookie Patch /99
~$114~$114 /99 (Oct 2026 comp)A ticket on Milwaukee's new starting center after the June blockbuster that sent Giannis Antetokounmpo out. A 7-footer averaging 10-plus rebounds and shooting 39.5% from three in 22 minutes a game.
- ▲His first full season as a starter begins October 20.
- ▲His cards have not yet repriced for the bigger role.
- ▼A patch without an autograph, and a big role does not guarantee big numbers.
Learn more: Most valuable Kel'el Ware cards

#28Ausar Thompson — 2023-24 Obsidian Rookie Jersey Auto /99
~$100~$100 /99 (Oct 2026 comp)The /99 patch auto of a realized All-Defensive First Teamer who finished third in Defensive Player of the Year voting at 23. The window may be partly closed, but the comp still sits at defensive-specialist prices.
- ▲Detroit's national-TV opening night against Boston.
- ▲Any jump in scoring would re-rate his cards past the specialist tier.
- ▼Defense-first players rarely drive card demand on their own.
Learn more: Most valuable Ausar Thompson cards

#29Trey McBride — 2022 Panini Spectra RPA /125
~$100~$100 /125 (Oct 2026 comp)An All-Pro tight end with 49 of 50 first-place votes, whose /125 RPA still trades at kicker prices. Kelce and Gronkowski showed the tight end re-rate path.
- ▲Midseason production keeps him on the All-Pro track.
- ▲Licensed Panini NFL RPAs are now a closed supply.
- ▼The tight end hobby ceiling is structurally lower than quarterback or receiver.
Learn more: Most valuable Trey McBride cards

#30Brock Bowers — 2024 National Treasures Rookie Patch /99
~$91~$91 /99 (Oct 2026 comp)A deep-value flyer: a record-pace tight end at a knee-injury discount, in the last licensed National Treasures football set.
- ▲A healthy midseason in Las Vegas.
- ▲Licensed Panini NFL rookies are now a closed supply.
- ▼The tight end hobby ceiling is the structural cap — Kyle Pitts is the cautionary tale.
Learn more: Most valuable Brock Bowers cards
Core tier ($150–$1,000)

#11Cade Cunningham — 2021-22 National Treasures RPA /99
~$999~$999 raw /99 (Oct 2026 comp)The 2021 class alpha — an All-NBA First Team point guard at 24 on a 60-win Pistons team. Graded copies ran from $18.3K to $34.2K between 2023 and 2025; you are paying post-re-rate prices, but for the flagship licensed RPA of a franchise point guard.
- ▲Detroit opens the season at home against Boston on national TV.
- ▲A deep playoff run or a title chase makes this a $25K-plus card in graded form.
- ▼The re-rate already happened, and RPA prices depend heavily on patch quality and centering.
Learn more: Most valuable Cade Cunningham cardsCade Cunningham Cards to Buy: An Investing Guide

#12Jalen Brunson — 2018-19 Panini Prizm Silver #250 (PSA 10)
~$950~$900–1,050 PSA 10 (Card Ladder last sale $900, Oct 2026; Fanatics Collect $950 Aug 2026)The Silver Prizm rookie of the Finals MVP, back to roughly half of its ~$2,100 post-title peak. Buying the champion's flagship rookie before the title defense starts is the cheaper side of that trade.
- ▲Opening night against LeBron's 76ers at Madison Square Garden.
- ▲A repeat-title run would retest the June highs.
- ▼Title spikes often fade further; the June peak may have been the top for several seasons.

#13Victor Wembanyama — 2023-24 Panini Spectra Aspiring Patches /99
~$928~$928 raw /99 (Oct 2026 comp)The cheapest credible /99 licensed Wembanyama patch — downside capped by the entry price, upside capped by a third-tier brand. The budget way to own a numbered Wemby card.
- ▲A national-TV opening night against the Thunder.
- ▲The final licensed Panini NBA products keep gaining scarcity.
- ▼Spectra trades well below Prizm and National Treasures, so it lags the Wemby market on the way up.

#14Cooper Flagg — 2025-26 Topps Chrome Patented #PD-16
~$899~$899 raw (Oct 2026 comp)A sub-$1,000 Chrome insert of the hobby's biggest name. After a Flagg 1/1 sold for $8.04 million in September, the mid-tier Flagg Chrome cards are where most collectors can actually participate.
- ▲A sophomore season that starts this month.
- ▲The record sale keeps attention on every Flagg Chrome product.
- ▼An insert, not a rookie auto — it moves with Flagg's hype but with less scarcity behind it.

#15Shohei Ohtani — 2018 Topps Chrome #150 Rookie
~$882~$882 (Oct 2026 comp)The Chrome rookie of the biggest name in baseball, after the Dodgers were swept out of the NLCS. A postseason exit is when sellers list; buying the flagship Chrome rookie then is the contrarian entry.
- ▲Offseason award voting keeps Ohtani in the headlines.
- ▲Spring 2027 resets the narrative with a full healthy season of two-way play.
- ▼High population and a mature price — this is an index-like hold, not a breakout card.
Learn more: Most valuable Shohei Ohtani cardsShohei Ohtani Rookie Card: Top 10 by Value ($50K)

#16Drake Maye — 2024 National Treasures Rookie Patch /99
~$689~$689 raw /99 (Oct 2026 comp)The scarcest licensed Panini patch card of the best young quarterback in football. No Panini auto exists because he signs exclusively with Fanatics, which makes this /99 patch his flagship Panini rookie.
- ▲A midseason playoff push after last season's Super Bowl LX run.
- ▲Licensed Panini NFL rookies are now a closed supply.
- ▼A patch without an autograph trades at a discount to RPAs; QB volatility applies.

#17Michael Jordan — 1987-88 Fleer #59
~$684~$684 raw (Oct 2026 comp)Jordan's second-year Fleer card — the cheapest way to own a 1980s Fleer Jordan, the most recognized vintage basketball brand. The rookie trades in the thousands; this is the blue-chip vintage hold for a Core budget.
- ▲Every NBA season opening renews vintage basketball demand.
- ▲Higher grades trade at large multiples, so well-centered raw copies carry grading upside.
- ▼Condition drives everything in vintage; a raw copy with soft corners is worth far less than the comp.
Learn more: Most valuable Michael Jordan cardsMichael Jordan Rookie Card: Top 10 by Value ($97.7K)

#18Chet Holmgren — 2022-23 Immaculate RPA /99
~$650~$650 raw /99 (Oct 2026 comp)A 24-year-old unicorn on a dynasty roster, at about 35% off the title-run price. One healthy Defensive Player of the Year-type season re-rates this card sharply.
- ▲Opening night at San Antonio, matched up against Wembanyama.
- ▲A healthy full season would close the gap to the class's top RPAs.
- ▼Hip and Lisfranc injuries plus a slight frame are the risk stack.
Learn more: Most valuable Chet Holmgren cards

#19Connor Bedard — 2023-24 Upper Deck Young Guns #451 (PSA 10)
~$635~$620–650 PSA 10 (eBay sold, Oct 2026)The Young Guns rookie of a former No. 1 pick, now about a third of its peak. A big PSA 10 population keeps it from being a grail, but at this level it is a liquid, cheap way to own a franchise center.
- ▲Another season with Chicago's young core growing around him.
- ▲October Young Guns season brings new collectors into the hockey market.
- ▼More than 7,500 PSA 10 copies exist, which caps the upside.
Learn more: Most valuable Connor Bedard cards

#20Jackson Chourio — 2022 Bowman Chrome Prospect Autograph #CPA-JCO (PSA 10)
~$600~$600–675 PSA 10 (Sports Card Investor $600 Jun 2026; Card Ladder ~$675 Sep 2026)The first Bowman Chrome auto of the Brewers' young outfielder, the card that baseball collectors treat as his true rookie. Milwaukee's World Series run puts him on the biggest stage of his career.
- ▲World Series Game 1 on October 23.
- ▲A signature postseason moment would reprice his first Bowman autos.
- ▼Postseason spikes often reverse in the offseason; buying after a big game is the trap.
Learn more: Most valuable Jackson Chourio cards
Conviction tier ($1,000+)

#1Cooper Flagg — 2025-26 Topps Chrome Rookie Autograph Blue Refractor /150
~$10,600~$10,600 raw /150 (eBay sold, Sep 18 2026); earlier copies ranged ~$8,500–13,500 Jul–Sep 2026The reigning Rookie of the Year's licensed flagship rookie auto, one step below the /99 and /75 parallels in scarcity but far more liquid. The Blue /150 has climbed steadily since summer, and the $8.04 million 1/1 sale in September resets what collectors will pay across the entire Flagg rookie-auto ladder.
- ▲Year two in Dallas starts this month, and a sophomore All-Star push renews casual demand.
- ▲The $8.04 million 1/1 sale lifts the reference price for every numbered Flagg Chrome auto.
- ▼Momentum-driven rookie autos fall fast on a slump or an injury, and a /150 is the most supplied of the colored parallels.
Learn more: Most valuable Cooper Flagg cardsCooper Flagg Rookie Card: Top 9 by Value ($39K)

#2Patrick Mahomes — 2017 Panini Prizm Silver #269 (PSA 10)
~$8,700~$8,700 PSA 10 (Card Ladder last sale, Aug 30 2026); eBay sales ran ~$6,800–7,050 in Aug 2026The blue-chip index card of modern football: the Silver Prizm rookie of a three-time Super Bowl champion and the most traded high-end NFL rookie in the hobby. It is the football card you can always sell, which is exactly what a Conviction-tier hold should be.
- ▲Midseason Chiefs games put Mahomes in prime time almost every week.
- ▲Licensed Panini rookies of his class are a closed supply now that Panini has lost the NFL license.
- ▼A mature, richly priced card with a large PSA 10 population — upside is index-like, and an injury or a down year compresses it.
Learn more: Most valuable Patrick Mahomes cardsPatrick Mahomes Cards to Buy: An Investing Guide

#3Caitlin Clark — 2024 Panini Prizm WNBA Silver #22 (PSA 10)
~$3,700~$3,250–3,975 PSA 10 (Card Ladder, 27 sales, last May 2026 — dated)The Silver Prizm is the most recognized Clark rookie card, from the flagship WNBA product of her first season. It is the liquid, gradeable core of the women's-sports card market, at a fraction of her low-numbered RPAs.
- ▲2026 Panini Prizm WNBA lands October 28 and pulls collector attention back to the original Prizm rookies.
- ▲Any WNBA expansion or media-rights headline keeps Clark at the center of demand.
- ▼The most recent PSA 10 sale is from May, so the true current price may be lower; a big PSA 10 population caps the multiple.
Learn more: Most valuable Caitlin Clark cardsCaitlin Clark Cards to Buy: An Investing Guide

#4Victor Wembanyama — 2023-24 Panini Prizm Silver #136 (PSA 10)
~$2,760~$2,760–3,520 PSA 10 (Sports Card Investor sale $3,520 Jun 2026; ~$2,760 market index Jul 2026) — repriced up from our September compThe base-refractor rookie of the most valuable active name in the hobby, now priced after a run to the NBA Finals rather than before it. October 20 opens with Wembanyama hosting Oklahoma City, and a full season as the league's defensive anchor is what keeps this card bid.
- ▲A national-TV opening night against the Thunder and an MVP-ladder start.
- ▲The last licensed Panini rookies grow scarcer as Fanatics and Topps own the NBA.
- ▼Prices spiked during the Finals run and have cooled since; a slow start or injury resets the comp lower.
Learn more: Most valuable Victor Wembanyama cardsVictor Wembanyama Rookie Card: Top 10 by Value ($33K)

#5Connor McDavid — 2015-16 Upper Deck Young Guns #201 (PSA 10)
~$2,740~$2,520–3,200 PSA 10 (Card Ladder, 34 sales Apr–Jul 2026, last $3,000)The definitive rookie card of the best hockey player of his generation, in the one hockey product every collector recognizes. Hockey's blue-chip market is narrower than basketball's, but this card trades often enough to hold value through the cycle.
- ▲A new season already under way, with McDavid chasing another Art Ross.
- ▲Young Guns attention spikes each October as the new Series 1 class arrives.
- ▼A large PSA 10 population and hockey's smaller buyer pool make big gains slower than in basketball.
Learn more: Most valuable Connor McDavid cardsConnor McDavid Cards to Buy: An Investing Guide

#6Jalen Brunson — 2018-19 Panini Prizm Fast Break Rookie Autograph (PSA 10)
~$2,800~$2,600–3,000 PSA 10 (eBay sold, Jun–Jul 2026 — dated, before the summer cooldown)A Prizm rookie autograph of the reigning, unanimous Finals MVP. Brunson's cards spiked and then cooled after the Knicks title; buying his autos before the champions start their defense is the cleaner entry than buying the June peak.
- ▲Opening night at Madison Square Garden against LeBron's 76ers on national TV.
- ▲A repeat-title push keeps the Knicks the most covered team in the biggest card market.
- ▼These comps are from June and July; if the cooldown seen in his Silver Prizm carried over, the current price is lower.
Learn more: Most valuable Jalen Brunson cards

#7Shai Gilgeous-Alexander — 2018-19 Panini Prizm Silver #184 (PSA 10)
~$2,395~$2,395 PSA 10 (Card Ladder last sale, Oct 12 2026); 30 sales ranged $2,000–2,600The Silver Prizm rookie of a former MVP and champion still in his prime, with one of the most stable price histories of any modern basketball rookie. Thirty sales in a tight $2,000–2,600 band is the liquidity profile a Conviction pick needs.
- ▲Opening night in San Antonio puts the Thunder's core against Wembanyama.
- ▲Another MVP-ballot season would push the card back toward its highs.
- ▼A deep PSA 10 population and an already established star mean steady, not explosive, upside.
Learn more: Most valuable Shai Gilgeous-Alexander cardsShai Gilgeous-alexander Cards: Top 10 by Value ($20K)

#8Macklin Celebrini — 2024-25 Upper Deck Young Guns #451 (PSA 10)
~$2,000~$1,700–2,270 PSA 10 (Fanatics Collect Feb 2026; eBay sold ~$2,040–2,270 Sep–Oct 2026)The base Young Guns of hockey's next franchise center, priced after his 1/1 Outburst Gold sold for $1.28 million in August, a record for any hockey card not featuring Wayne Gretzky. Base PSA 10s have climbed from about $1,800 to over $2,000 since February.
- ▲A full third season in San Jose with the Sharks building around him.
- ▲The August record sale keeps collectors moving up and down the Celebrini Young Guns ladder.
- ▼A high PSA 10 population and a rebuilding team; hockey prices move slowly if the Sharks stay out of contention.
Learn more: Most valuable Macklin Celebrini cardsMacklin Celebrini Rookie Card: Top 8 by Value ($3.5K)

#9Drake Maye — 2024 Panini Prizm Silver #329 (PSA 10)
~$1,300~$1,150–1,600 PSA 10 (Card Ladder last sale ~$1,158; Sports Card Investor ~$1,595 Dec 2025 — dated)The Silver Prizm rookie of the quarterback who took New England to Super Bowl LX in his second year. It traded near $2,000 at the AFC Championship peak and has come back since, which is the window to own the flagship licensed Panini rookie of an established young QB.
- ▲Midseason Patriots games and a second straight playoff push.
- ▲No new licensed Panini rookies will ever be printed now that Panini has lost the NFL license.
- ▼The most recent comps are thin and months old, so price discovery is weak; QB cards swing hard on a bad stretch.
Learn more: Most valuable Drake Maye cardsDrake Maye Rookie Card: Top 10 by Value ($4.5K)

#10Jacob Misiorowski — 2026 Bowman Crystallized #BWC-5
~$1,050~$1,050 raw (Sports Card Investor last sale, Jul 2026); 14-sale average ~$1,250A case-hit insert of the Brewers' flamethrowing rookie, the pitcher whose 2026 Bowman Anime Superfractor 1/1 sold for $45,600 in June. Short-printed case hits are where World Series attention concentrates for a rookie on the winning side.
- ▲Milwaukee's first World Series in 44 years starts October 23.
- ▲A big postseason start on national TV would reprice his whole rookie run.
- ▼Pitchers carry injury risk and a lower hobby ceiling, and World Series hype often peaks the morning after a big game.
Learn more: Most valuable Jacob Misiorowski cards
How these picks are chosen
Core and Budget picks are drawn from Ripbin's daily eBay watcher, which tracks raw serial-numbered rookie patch and auto cards and computes an outlier-trimmed median comp for each, plus a few graded rookies priced from recent eBay sold and Card Ladder data. Conviction picks come from October 2026 market research across eBay sold listings, Card Ladder, Fanatics Collect and Sports Card Investor. Starter picks are real market values from our catalog. Nothing here is a made-up number — where a comp is thin or a few months old, the price note says so and gives a range. We dropped Jaxson Dart from this month's list after his September 21 knee injury.
Frequently asked questions
- What are the best cheap sports cards to buy right now?
- For under $50, our October 2026 starter picks are real cards of ascending and established stars — Cade Cunningham 2021-22 Obsidian Supernova (~$49), Amen Thompson 2023-24 Hoops Hot Signatures rookie auto (~$48) and Cedric Coward 2025-26 Topps Chrome Stratospheric Signatures (~$43) among them. They ride the same players as the pricier serial cards without the patch-auto premium.
- Should I buy Brewers cards before the World Series?
- Postseason exposure lifts young stars on the winning side, but the biggest jumps usually come right after a big game and fade in the offseason. If you want Jackson Chourio or Jacob Misiorowski, buy before a headline performance rather than the morning after, and favor their first Bowman Chrome autos and short-printed inserts.
- Are sports cards a good investment in 2026?
- They can appreciate, but they are speculative, illiquid assets — prices can fall sharply and selling takes time and fees. Our picks are the cards our data flags as most likely to hold or grow value, but this is market analysis, not financial advice. Never buy with money you cannot afford to hold for years.
- How does Ripbin pick these cards?
- A daily monitor of raw eBay listings for serial-numbered rookie cards produces trimmed-median comps, and on top of that we layer a simple screen: an improving young player, a team being built around him, and a hard supply cap. Higher-tier and grail picks add fresh market research from eBay sold, Card Ladder, Fanatics Collect and Sports Card Investor.
This is collectibles market analysis, not financial advice. Trading cards are speculative, illiquid assets — prices can fall sharply, selling takes time and fees, and past results don't predict future returns. Never invest money you can't afford to hold for years or lose. Do your own research before buying anything.