1995 Stadium Club Super Skills Don Mattingly Members Only #5
1995
See all Don Mattingly cards & values1995 seasonNew York YankeesDon Mattingly career & card values
Uncommon
$5.95est. value (ungraded)
Prices updated 2026-10-22
Based on recorded sold prices how we price cards
Card number
#5
Year
1995
Parallel / variant
Members Only
Price by month
Average price of the 1995 Stadium Club Super Skills Don Mattingly Members Only #5 each month, from 1 recorded price reading. Prices are re-checked regularly; a month's average counts each day from that month's first reading at the price that held that day.
Recorded high
$5.95
Recorded low
$5.95
| Month | Source | Average | Range |
|---|---|---|---|
| Oct 2026 | Market value | $5.95 | — |
Don Mattingly prices by grade
| Grade | Value | eBay |
|---|---|---|
| Ungraded | $5.95 | Buy on eBay ↗ |
| PSA 8 | $25.46 | Buy on eBay ↗ |
| PSA 9 | $53.36 | Buy on eBay ↗ |
| Grade 9.5 | $89.89 | Buy on eBay ↗ |
| PSA 10 | $287.03 | Buy on eBay ↗ |
| BGS 10 | $373.00 | Buy on eBay ↗ |
| CGC 10 | $172.00 | Buy on eBay ↗ |
| SGC 10 | $172.00 | Buy on eBay ↗ |
Other versions of this Don Mattingly card
1 version, each priced on its own. Most valuable first.
Live on eBay
Affiliate — we may earn a commission1995 Stadium Club Super Skills Don Mattingly Members Only #5 value & prices
The 1995 Stadium Club Super Skills Don Mattingly Members Only #5 is a Baseball card (Members Only parallel) released in 1995. Ungraded copies carry a market value of about $5.95.
An ungraded copy is worth around $5.95, a PSA 9 around $53.36, a PSA 10 (Gem Mint) around $287.03 and a pristine BGS 10 around $373.00. That's roughly a 48× premium for a gem-mint copy over raw — one of the clearest signals that condition-sensitive buyers dominate this card's market.
Is it worth grading?
With raw copies near $5.95 and top grades reaching $287.03, grading a sharp copy of this card can clearly pay for itself — the spread comfortably covers a typical ~$25.00 grading fee. The catch: only submit copies with strong centering, clean corners, and unmarked surfaces, because anything below a 9 usually erases the math.
More from 1995 Stadium Club Super Skills
Jay Buhner
#3$1.75
John Wetteland
#19
Larry Walker
#15$2.38
Mark Whiten
#10
Marquis Grissom
#12
Randy Johnson
#20$2.12
Other Don Mattingly cards
Don Mattingly
#CLA-DMA$3,550.00
Don Mattingly
#64$1,300.00
Don Mattingly
#IVA-DMA$1,175.00
Don Mattingly
#89BA-DM$999.99
Don Mattingly
#479$899.99
Don Mattingly
#T88C-88$733.88
Cards worth about the same as the Don Mattingly
Explore Don Mattingly card values
Don Mattingly1995 Stadium Club Super Skills1995Baseball cardsMembers OnlyPSA 10BGS 10card valueprice guide