The 10 Most Valuable Don Mattingly Cards
The most valuable Don Mattingly card is the 1986 Donruss Highlights Don Mattingly Highlights In White #48 at $719.95 as of September 20, 2026.
By Ripbin Research · Updated 2026-09-20 · prices from live market data
Shop Don Mattingly cards on eBay
Affiliate — we may earn a commissionThe 10 most valuable Don Mattingly cards in the Ripbin catalog (1986–2026) carry a combined raw market value of $2,588.05, topped by a $719.95 card.
Just missed the cut
- #11 2025 Topps Five Star Silver Signatures Don Mattingly #FSS-DM$152.50
- #12 2026 Topps 75 Years of Topps Die-Cut Autographs Don Mattingly #75YA-DM$149.72
- #13 2025 Leaf Bronx Legacy Yankee Doodles Don Mattingly #YD-DM1$149.00
- #14 2024 Topps Luminaries Hit Kings Autographs Don Mattingly #HK-DMA$144.95
- #15 2025 Topps Archives 1964 Topps Stand-Ups Autographs Don Mattingly #64SUA-DM$142.50
- #16 2023 Topps Gilded Collection Gallery of Gold Autographs Don Mattingly #GOG-DMA$137.50
- #17 2025 Topps Sterling Swings Autographed Relics Don Mattingly #SWA-DM$136.25
- #18 2023 Topps Definitive Collection Framed Autographs Don Mattingly #DCFA-DM$135.00
- #19 2025 Topps Five Star Stars and Stitches Autographs Don Mattingly #SS-DM$132.50
- #20 2026 Topps 1991 Topps Autographs Don Mattingly #91A-DM$129.98
More Baseball guides
Most Valuable Shohei Ohtani CardsMost Valuable Mike Trout CardsMost Valuable Aaron Judge CardsMost Valuable Juan Soto CardsMost Valuable Ronald Acuna Jr CardsMost Valuable Bobby Witt Jr CardsMost Valuable Paul Skenes CardsMost Valuable Julio Rodriguez CardsMost Valuable Bryce Harper CardsMost Valuable Fernando Tatis Jr Cards