Ripbin
Scan

The 9 Most Valuable Tom McCarthy Cards

The most valuable Tom McCarthy card is the 1957 Topps Tom McCarthy #37 at $11.57 as of October 22, 2026.

By Ripbin Research · Updated 2026-10-22 · prices from live market data

See all Tom McCarthy cards & values

Shop Tom McCarthy cards on eBay

Affiliate — we may earn a commission

The 9 most valuable Tom McCarthy cards in the Ripbin catalog (1957–1995) carry a combined raw market value of $22.40, topped by a $11.57 card.

  1. #11957 Topps Tom McCarthy #37

    $11.57PSA 10 ~$1,799.08
    Full price guide →See eBay listings ↗

  2. #21982 Post Cereal Tom McCarthy

    $2.54
    Full price guide →See eBay listings ↗

  3. #31989 ProCards FutureStars AAA Base Set Tom McCarthy #593

    $1.99
    Full price guide →See eBay listings ↗
  4. 1989 Topps Traded Tiffany Tom McCarthy #75T

    #41989 Topps Traded Tiffany Tom McCarthy #75T

    $1.79
    Full price guide →See eBay listings ↗

  5. #51987 Topps Tom McCarthy #38

    $1.54PSA 10 ~$23.55
    Full price guide →See eBay listings ↗
  6. 1980 O-Pee-Chee Tom McCarthy #93

    #61980 O-Pee-Chee Tom McCarthy #93

    $1.47PSA 10 ~$143.29
    Full price guide →See eBay listings ↗

  7. #71990 Score Rising Stars Tom McCarthy #57

    $1.00
    Full price guide →See eBay listings ↗

  8. #81991 Line Drive AAA Tom McCarthy #435

    $0.25
    Full price guide →See eBay listings ↗

  9. #91981 O-Pee-Chee Sticker Tom McCarthy #95

    $0.25
    Full price guide →See eBay listings ↗

Sets in this guide

1957 Topps1982 Post Cereal1989 ProCards FutureStars AAA Base Set1989 Topps Traded Tiffany1987 Topps1980 O-Pee-Chee1990 Score Rising Stars1991 Line Drive AAA1981 O-Pee-Chee Sticker

More Baseball guides

Most Valuable Shohei Ohtani CardsMost Valuable Aaron Judge CardsMost Valuable Mike Trout CardsMost Valuable Ty France CardsMost Valuable Nomar Mazara CardsMost Valuable David Fletcher CardsMost Valuable Keegan Akin CardsMost Valuable Michael Massey CardsMost Valuable Cliff Lee CardsMost Valuable Jared Shuster Cards
All Tom McCarthy cards & values →Card investing reports →
Tom McCarthyBaseball cardsmost valuable cardscard valuesprice guide

More Tom McCarthy cards on eBay

Affiliate — we may earn a commission