The 10 Most Valuable Paul Mr. Wonderful Orndorff Cards
The most valuable Paul Mr. Wonderful Orndorff card is the 2016 Topps WWE Undisputed Paul Mr. Wonderful Orndorff Gold #77 at $10.89 as of October 23, 2026.
By Ripbin Research · Updated 2026-10-23 · prices from live market data
See all Paul Mr. Wonderful Orndorff cards & valuesShop Paul Mr. Wonderful Orndorff cards on eBay
Affiliate — we may earn a commissionThe 10 most valuable Paul Mr. Wonderful Orndorff cards in the Ripbin catalog (2010–2016) carry a combined raw market value of $40.56, topped by a $10.89 card.
Just missed the cut
- #11 2005 Topps Heritage WWE Paul Mr. Wonderful Orndorff #83$1.79
- #12 2010 Topps Platinum WWE Paul Mr. Wonderful Orndorff Xfractor #105$1.68
- #13 2016 Topps WWE Undisputed Paul Mr. Wonderful Orndorff #77$1.62
- #14 2008 Topps Heritage IV WWE Paul Mr. Wonderful Orndorff #80$1.61
- #15 2013 Topps WWE Paul Mr. Wonderful Orndorff #100$1.55
- #16 2012 Topps Heritage WWE Paul Mr. Wonderful Orndorff #93$1.23
- #17 2015 Topps Heritage WWE Paul Mr. Wonderful Orndorff #34$1.11
- #18 2016 Topps WWE Undisputed Paul Mr. Wonderful Orndorff Bronze #77$1.00
- #19 2008 Topps Heritage IV WWE Allen & Ginter Legends Paul Mr. Wonderful Orndorff #9$1.00
- #20 2013 Topps WWE Paul Mr. Wonderful Orndorff Black #100$0.25
Sets in this guide
More Wrestling guides
Most Valuable John Cena CardsMost Valuable Roman Reigns CardsMost Valuable Becky Lynch CardsMost Valuable Vladimir Kozlov CardsMost Valuable Godfather CardsMost Valuable Percy Watson CardsMost Valuable Tucker Knight CardsMost Valuable Murphy CardsMost Valuable Mr Brodie Lee CardsMost Valuable Jim Neidhart Cards