The 10 Most Valuable John Mateer Cards
The most valuable John Mateer card is the 2025 Bowman University Best Making the Grade John Mateer Superfractor #MG-10 at $1,999.99 as of October 20, 2026.
By Ripbin Research · Updated 2026-10-20 · prices from live market data
See all John Mateer cards & valuesShop John Mateer cards on eBay
Affiliate — we may earn a commissionThe 10 most valuable John Mateer cards in the Ripbin catalog (2025) carry a combined raw market value of $6,575.72, topped by a $1,999.99 card.
Just missed the cut
- #11 2025 Bowman Best University Autograph John Mateer Black #BOA-JMA$199.95
- #12 2025 Bowman University Chrome Base Set John Mateer Red Shimmer Refractor #1$196.50
- #13 2025 Bowman U Now John Mateer Black #39$180.42
- #14 2025 Bowman University Chrome 1955 Bowman Football Autographs John Mateer Orange Refractor #55AV-JM$157.75
- #15 2025 Bowman University Chrome The Big Kahuna Autographs John Mateer #BK-JM$135.00
- #16 2025 Bowman University Best Workhorse Signatures Refractor John Mateer Black #WA-JM$107.50
- #17 2025 Bowman U Now John Mateer Orange #9$104.97
- #18 2025 Bowman University Chrome Base Set John Mateer White Refractor #1$100.00
- #19 2025 Bowman Best University Greatness Awaits Autograph John Mateer Orange #GA-JM$99.99
- #20 2025 Bowman Best University Greatness Awaits Autograph John Mateer Gold #GA-JM$87.50
Sets in this guide
2025 Bowman University Best Making the Grade2025 Bowman University Chrome Campus Visit Autographs2025 Bowman University Chrome College Rule Playbook2025 Bowman University Chrome Lettered Up!2025 Bowman University Chrome Base Set2025 Bowman University Chrome Campus Star Signatures2025 Bowman University Best Workhorse Signatures Refractor2025 Bowman University Chrome Sapphire Sapphire Selections Signatures2025 Bowman Best University Autograph2025 Bowman U Now2025 Bowman University Chrome 1955 Bowman Football Autographs2025 Bowman University Chrome The Big Kahuna Autographs
More Football guides
Most Valuable Patrick Mahomes Ii CardsMost Valuable Josh Allen CardsMost Valuable Tom Brady CardsMost Valuable Drew Lock CardsMost Valuable Cade Stover CardsMost Valuable Desean Jackson CardsMost Valuable Randall Cunningham CardsMost Valuable Tiki Barber CardsMost Valuable Anquan Boldin CardsMost Valuable Kordell Stewart Cards