John Mateer card values & price guide
37 cards · 37 sets · 2025–2026
Shop John Mateer cards on eBay
Affiliate — we may earn a commissionRipbin tracks 28 priced John Mateer cards worth $1–$200 — the top 10 account for 86% of tracked value; PSA 10 copies trade ~10.9× raw.
Prices last updated Aug 2026
Cards tracked
37
Highest value
$199.99
Value range
$1–$200
Median value
$12
PSA 10 avg
$99
John Mateer has 37 football cards in the Ripbin catalog across 37 sets, valued $1.01–$199.99, topped by the 2025 Bowman University Chrome Sapphire Sapphire Selections Signatures John Mateer #SS-JM at about $199.99 ungraded.
Most valuable John Mateer cards
2025 Bowman University Chrome The Big Kahuna Autographs
$134.94
2025 Bowman University Chrome Acropolis Autographs
$95.00
2025 Bowman University Chrome 1955 Bowman Football Autographs
$71.00
2025 Bowman University Chrome Chrome Prospect Autographs
$58.16
2025 Bowman University Best Bowman Showpieces Autographs Refractor
$45.00
2025 Bowman University Chrome Campus Visit Autographs
$42.00
2025 Bowman University Chrome Campus Star Signatures
$38.00
2025 Leaf Vivid Pure Imagination Autographs
$26.71
Top 10 most valuable John Mateer cards
John Mateer's earliest cards (2025)
The earliest John Mateer cards in our catalog — their rookie-year issues — ranked by value.
John Mateer cards by price
Affordable under $2516 cards
- 2025 Leaf Vivid Bursting With Talent Autographs #TA-JM2$17.80
- 2025 Bowman University Chrome Sapphire Treasured Talent #TT-5$15.50
- 2025 Bowman University Chrome Dean's List Refractor #DL-9$8.35
- 2025 Bowman University Chrome Sapphire Sapphire Selections #SS-17$8.07
- 2025 Bowman University Chrome Sapphire Base Set #1$4.01
- 2025 Bowman University Best Field Day #FD-7$2.24
$25–$10010 cards
- 2025 Bowman University Chrome Acropolis Autographs #AA-JM$95.00
- 2025 Bowman University Chrome 1955 Bowman Football Autographs #55AV-JM$71.00
- 2025 Bowman University Chrome Sapphire Chrome Prospect Autographs #BCA-JM$66.32
- 2025 Bowman University Chrome Chrome Prospect Autographs #BCA-JM$58.16
- 2025 Bowman University Best Workhorse Signatures Refractor #WA-JM$54.00
- 2025 Bowman University Best Bowman Showpieces Autographs Refractor #BSA-JM$45.00
John Mateer card prices
John Mateer cards by year
| Year | Cards | Top card | Value |
|---|---|---|---|
| 2026 | 1 | — | — |
| 2025 | 36 | 2025 Bowman University Chrome Sapphire Sapphire Selections Signatures #SS-JM | $199.99 |
Most popular sets featuring John Mateer
2025 Bowman University Chrome Sapphire Sapphire Selections Signatures1 card$2002025 Bowman University Chrome The Big Kahuna Autographs1 card$1352025 Bowman University Chrome Acropolis Autographs1 card$952025 Bowman University Chrome 1955 Bowman Football Autographs1 card$712025 Bowman University Chrome Sapphire Chrome Prospect Autographs1 card$662025 Bowman University Chrome Chrome Prospect Autographs1 card$582025 Bowman University Best Workhorse Signatures Refractor1 card$542025 Bowman University Best Bowman Showpieces Autographs Refractor1 card$45
Related articles
More Football players
Frequently asked questions
- How much more is a PSA 10 John Mateer card worth?
- Across John Mateer cards we track with both raw and PSA 10 prices, a PSA 10 sells for roughly 10.9× the ungraded price, averaging about $99. Grading pristine copies can pay off — check each card's grade ladder first.