The 10 Most Valuable Jay Johnstone Cards

The most valuable Jay Johnstone card is the 1984 Topps Jay Johnstone #249 at $2.55 as of October 18, 2026.

By Ripbin Research · Updated 2026-10-18 · prices from live market data

Shop Jay Johnstone cards on eBay

Affiliate — we may earn a commission

The 10 most valuable Jay Johnstone cards in the Ripbin catalog (1970–1984) carry a combined raw market value of $16.73, topped by a $2.55 card.

🃏
#11984 Topps Jay Johnstone #249
$2.55PSA 10 ~$41.00
Full price guide →See eBay listings ↗
🃏
#21971 Topps Jay Johnstone #292
$2.01PSA 10 ~$387.93
Full price guide →See eBay listings ↗
🃏
#31976 Topps Jay Johnstone #114
$1.74PSA 10 ~$110.39
Full price guide →See eBay listings ↗
🃏
#41970 Topps Jay Johnstone #485
$1.69PSA 10 ~$289.11
Full price guide →See eBay listings ↗
🃏
#51983 Topps Jay Johnstone #152
$1.56PSA 10 ~$52.25
Full price guide →See eBay listings ↗
🃏
#61978 Topps Jay Johnstone #675
$1.50PSA 10 ~$105.00
Full price guide →See eBay listings ↗
🃏
#71981 Topps Jay Johnstone #372
$1.50PSA 10 ~$124.75
Full price guide →See eBay listings ↗
🃏
#81972 Topps Jay Johnstone #233
$1.47PSA 10 ~$215.61
Full price guide →See eBay listings ↗
🃏
#91979 Topps Jay Johnstone #558
$1.40PSA 10 ~$102.33
Full price guide →See eBay listings ↗
🃏
#101982 Topps Jay Johnstone #774
$1.31PSA 10 ~$39.09
Full price guide →See eBay listings ↗

Just missed the cut

More Baseball guides

Most Valuable Shohei Ohtani Cards Most Valuable Aaron Judge Cards Most Valuable Mike Trout Cards Most Valuable Ronald Acuna Jr Cards Most Valuable Juan Soto Cards Most Valuable Bobby Witt Jr Cards Most Valuable Paul Skenes Cards Most Valuable Corbin Carroll Cards Most Valuable Fernando Tatis Jr Cards Most Valuable Bryce Harper Cards

All Jay Johnstone cards & values →Card investing reports →

Jay Johnstone Baseball cards most valuable cards card values price guide

More Jay Johnstone cards on eBay

Affiliate — we may earn a commission