The 5 Most Valuable Fred Toney Cards

The most valuable Fred Toney card is the 1917 Collins McCarthy Fred Toney #174 at $190.00 as of October 22, 2026.

By Ripbin Research · Updated 2026-10-22 · prices from live market data

See all Fred Toney cards & values

Shop Fred Toney cards on eBay

Affiliate — we may earn a commission

The 5 most valuable Fred Toney cards in the Ripbin catalog (1916–1992) carry a combined raw market value of $261.33, topped by a $190.00 card.

#11917 Collins McCarthy Fred Toney #174
$190.00
Full price guide →See eBay listings ↗
#21916 M101 4 Sporting News Fred Toney #175
$36.20
Full price guide →See eBay listings ↗
#31922 E120 American Caramel Fred Toney
$32.13
Full price guide →See eBay listings ↗
#41961 Fleer Fred Toney #80
$1.75PSA 10 ~$297.47
Full price guide →See eBay listings ↗
#51992 Conlon Collection Fred Toney #347
$1.25
Full price guide →See eBay listings ↗

Sets in this guide

1917 Collins McCarthy 1916 M101 4 Sporting News 1922 E120 American Caramel 1961 Fleer 1992 Conlon Collection

More Baseball guides

Most Valuable Shohei Ohtani Cards Most Valuable Aaron Judge Cards Most Valuable Mike Trout Cards Most Valuable Leo De Vries Cards Most Valuable Carson Williams Cards Most Valuable Luis Garcia Cards Most Valuable Austin Meadows Cards Most Valuable Christopher Morel Cards Most Valuable Zac Veen Cards Most Valuable Lou Gehrig Cards

All Fred Toney cards & values →Card investing reports →

Fred Toney Baseball cards most valuable cards card values price guide

More Fred Toney cards on eBay

Affiliate — we may earn a commission