The 10 Most Valuable Christy Mathewson Cards
The most valuable Christy Mathewson card is the 1914 Cracker Jack Christy Mathewson #88 at $51,600.00 as of October 15, 2026.
By Ripbin Research · Updated 2026-10-15 · prices from live market data
Shop Christy Mathewson cards on eBay
Affiliate — we may earn a commissionThe 10 most valuable Christy Mathewson cards in the Ripbin catalog (1909–1915) carry a combined raw market value of $72,465.05, topped by a $51,600.00 card.
Just missed the cut
- #11 1910 E98 Set of 30 Christy Mathewson Red$893.00
- #12 1909 T206 Polar Bear Christy Mathewson Dark Cap$837.00
- #13 1909 T206 Sovereign 150 Christy Mathewson Portrait$620.00
- #14 1913 National Game Christy Mathewson$382.77
- #15 1920 W516 1 Christy Mathewson Hand Cut #24$327.90
- #16 1914 Polo Grounds Game Christy Mathewson Matty$325.00
- #17 1921 W516 2 2 Christy Mathewson Hand Cut #27$243.53
- #18 1910 E98 Set of 30 Christy Mathewson Orange$227.50
- #19 1919 W514 Christy Mathewson Hand Cut #72$212.17
- #20 1940 Play Ball Christy Mathewson #175$191.75
More Baseball guides
Most Valuable Shohei Ohtani CardsMost Valuable Aaron Judge CardsMost Valuable Mike Trout CardsMost Valuable Ronald Acuna Jr CardsMost Valuable Juan Soto CardsMost Valuable Bobby Witt Jr CardsMost Valuable Paul Skenes CardsMost Valuable Corbin Carroll CardsMost Valuable Fernando Tatis Jr CardsMost Valuable Mookie Betts Cards