Ripbin
Scan

The 8 Most Valuable Carl Mays Cards

The most valuable Carl Mays card is the 1919 W514 Carl Mays Hand Cut #103 at $266.13 as of October 15, 2026.

By Ripbin Research · Updated 2026-10-15 · prices from live market data

Shop Carl Mays cards on eBay

Affiliate — we may earn a commission

The 8 most valuable Carl Mays cards in the Ripbin catalog (1919–1928) carry a combined raw market value of $967.77, topped by a $266.13 card.

  1. 1919 W514 Carl Mays Hand Cut #103

    #11919 W514 Carl Mays Hand Cut #103

    $266.13
    Full price guide →See eBay listings ↗
  2. 🃏

    #21921 E220 National Caramel Carl Mays

    $249.25
    Full price guide →See eBay listings ↗
  3. 🃏

    #31927 E210 York Caramel Type 1 Carl Mays #17

    $107.00
    Full price guide →See eBay listings ↗
  4. 🃏

    #41923 W515 2 Carl Mays Hand Cut #20

    $95.00
    Full price guide →See eBay listings ↗
  5. 1922 E120 American Caramel Carl Mays

    #51922 E120 American Caramel Carl Mays

    $92.00
    Full price guide →See eBay listings ↗
  6. 1923 W515 1 Carl Mays Hand Cut #20

    #61923 W515 1 Carl Mays Hand Cut #20

    $59.33
    Full price guide →See eBay listings ↗
  7. 1922 Neilson's Chocolate Type II Carl Mays

    #71922 Neilson's Chocolate Type II Carl Mays

    $56.06
    Full price guide →See eBay listings ↗
  8. 🃏

    #81928 Yuengling's Ice Cream Carl Mays #17

    $43.00
    Full price guide →See eBay listings ↗

More Baseball guides

Most Valuable Shohei Ohtani CardsMost Valuable Aaron Judge CardsMost Valuable Mike Trout CardsMost Valuable Ronald Acuna Jr CardsMost Valuable Juan Soto CardsMost Valuable Bobby Witt Jr CardsMost Valuable Paul Skenes CardsMost Valuable Corbin Carroll CardsMost Valuable Fernando Tatis Jr CardsMost Valuable Mookie Betts Cards
All Carl Mays cards & values →Card investing reports →
Carl MaysBaseball cardsmost valuable cardscard valuesprice guide

More Carl Mays cards on eBay

Affiliate — we may earn a commission