1958 Topps — full checklist
All 134 cards with grade-by-grade values. ← Back to 1958 Topps overview
| Card | Ungraded | PSA 9 | PSA 10 | BGS 10 |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Jim Brown#62 | $453.00 | $40,155.00 | $101,683.20 | $132,188.00 |
| Sonny Jurgensen#90 | $42.00 | $4,342.00 | $8,491.26 | $11,039.00 |
| Bart Starr#66 | $38.56 | $21,000.00 | $25,200.00 | $32,760.00 |
| John Unitas#22 | $31.13 | $2,092.00 | $6,301.73 | $8,192.00 |
| Felt Initial Card | $15.66 | $476.00 | $3,136.37 | $4,077.00 |
| Frank Gifford#73 | $13.50 | $6,000.00 | $7,200.00 | $9,360.00 |
| Raymond Berry#120 | $11.89 | $12,000.00 | $14,400.00 | $18,720.00 |
| George Blanda#129 | $11.87 | $13,800.00 | $16,560.00 | $21,528.00 |
| Bobby Layne#2 | $9.90 | $2,562.00 | $3,074.00 | $3,996.00 |
| Cleveland Browns#9 | $8.25 | $2,128.43 | $2,554.00 | $3,320.00 |
| Y.A. Tittle#86 | $7.38 | $3,773.48 | $4,528.00 | $5,886.00 |
| Chuck Bednarik#35 | $6.84 | $191.99 | $1,243.16 | $1,616.00 |
| Lenny Moore#10 | $6.05 | $280.00 | $1,088.05 | $1,414.00 |
| Baltimore Colts#110 | $5.89 | $165.32 | $1,065.35 | $1,385.00 |
| Zeke Bratkowski#23 | $5.72 | $165.35 | $1,065.59 | $1,385.00 |
| Lou Groza#52 | $5.50 | $160.21 | $1,031.27 | $1,341.00 |
| Art Donovan#106 | $5.29 | $16,800.00 | $20,160.00 | $26,208.00 |
| Emlen Tunnell#42 | $5.26 | $168.91 | $1,089.27 | $1,416.00 |
| Jim Ringo#103 | $5.19 | $1,560.00 | $1,872.00 | $2,434.00 |
| George Tarasovic#37 | $4.84 | $59.00 | $777.70 | $1,011.00 |
| Green Bay Packers#96 | $4.80 | $256.00 | $897.83 | $1,167.00 |
| Gino Marchetti#16 | $4.64 | $186.00 | $973.02 | $1,265.00 |
| Ron Kramer#58 | $4.47 | $16,800.00 | $20,160.00 | $26,208.00 |
| Don Bosseler#132 | $4.26 | $13,800.00 | $16,560.00 | $21,528.00 |
| San Francisco 49ers#41 | $4.25 | $251.50 | $710.84 | $924.00 |
| Earl Morrall#57 | $4.25 | $127.27 | $811.74 | $1,055.00 |
| Joe Perry#93 | $4.15 | $1,260.00 | $1,512.00 | $1,966.00 |
| Tom McDonald#126 | $4.13 | $840.00 | $1,008.00 | $1,310.00 |
| Milt Plum#5 | $4.02 | $9,221.82 | $11,066.00 | $14,386.00 |
| Bill Wade#38 | $4.00 | $106.00 | $840.09 | $1,092.00 |
| Alan Ameche#12 | $4.00 | $3,240.00 | $3,888.00 | $5,054.00 |
| Don McIlhenny#71 | $3.99 | $130.63 | $834.13 | $1,084.00 |
| Eddie LeBaron#112 | $3.99 | $494.31 | $821.86 | $1,068.00 |
| Marv Matuzsak#79 | $3.99 | $144.00 | $834.10 | $1,084.00 |
| Chicago Bears#29 | $3.91 | $116.08 | $737.13 | $958.00 |
| Babe Parilli#118 | $3.86 | $159.34 | $1,025.49 | $1,333.00 |
| Ollie Matson#127 | $3.85 | $136.95 | $876.23 | $1,139.00 |
| Joe Schmidt#3 | $3.76 | $131.52 | $840.06 | $1,092.00 |
| Ed Brown#123 | $3.75 | $123.29 | $785.19 | $1,021.00 |
| Vic Zucco#36 | $3.75 | $146.02 | $936.71 | $1,218.00 |
| Hugh McElhenny#122 | $3.74 | $900.00 | $1,080.00 | $1,404.00 |
| Lamar McHan#68 | $3.69 | $3,000.00 | $3,600.00 | $4,680.00 |
| Jack McClairen#51 | $3.64 | $1,035.00 | $1,242.00 | $1,615.00 |
| Sid Youngelman#24 | $3.61 | $70.45 | $432.96 | $563.00 |
| Billy Wilson#95 | $3.50 | $115.80 | $735.25 | $956.00 |
| Yale Lary#18 | $3.44 | $4,560.00 | $5,472.00 | $7,114.00 |
| Andy Robustelli#15 | $3.43 | $114.82 | $728.72 | $947.00 |
| Bobby Dillon#32 | $3.40 | $109.69 | $694.54 | $903.00 |
| Kenny Konz#26 | $3.39 | $121.83 | $775.46 | $1,008.00 |
| Lou Creekmur#81 | $3.38 | $780.00 | $936.00 | $1,217.00 |
| Harlon Hill#80 | $3.35 | $136.00 | $626.32 | $814.00 |
| Jim Doran#43 | $3.35 | $2,520.00 | $3,024.00 | $3,931.00 |
| Pittsburgh Steelers#116 | $3.35 | $552.00 | $664.32 | $864.00 |
| Charley Conerly#84 | $3.35 | $930.00 | $1,116.00 | $1,451.00 |
| Lavern Torgeson#97 | $3.34 | $77.99 | $483.23 | $628.00 |
| Philadelphia Eagles#109 | $3.32 | $173.00 | $739.09 | $961.00 |
| New York Giants#61 | $3.32 | $660.00 | $741.30 | $964.00 |
| Dick Stanfel#39 | $3.32 | $192.00 | $817.60 | $1,063.00 |
| John Henry Johnson#75 | $3.30 | $344.00 | $686.69 | $893.00 |
| Les Richter#105 | $3.29 | $155.39 | $999.17 | $1,299.00 |
| Jack Butler#76 | $3.28 | $109.09 | $690.51 | $898.00 |
| Billy Howton#6 | $3.28 | $243.00 | $767.38 | $998.00 |
| Willie Galimore#114 | $3.26 | $515.00 | $559.82 | $728.00 |
| Dick Deschaine#48 | $3.26 | $900.00 | $1,080.00 | $1,404.00 |
| Al Carmichael#31 | $3.25 | $16,200.00 | $19,440.00 | $25,272.00 |
| Jon Arnett#20 | $3.25 | $2,340.00 | $2,808.00 | $3,650.00 |
| Bill Barnes#4 | $3.24 | $2,040.00 | $2,448.00 | $3,182.00 |
| Gern Nagler#60 | $3.23 | $97.63 | $614.13 | $798.00 |
| Leo Nomellini#89 | $3.22 | $116.97 | $743.07 | $966.00 |
| Washington Redskins#27 | $3.22 | $660.00 | $684.93 | $890.00 |
| Ted Marchibroda#44 | $3.20 | $344.00 | $734.75 | $955.00 |
| Ray Renfro#17 | $3.18 | $3,480.00 | $4,176.00 | $5,429.00 |
| Don Heinrich#83 | $3.15 | $101.82 | $642.10 | $835.00 |
| Larry Strickland#99 | $3.13 | $264.00 | $483.39 | $628.00 |
| Jack Christiansen#70 | $3.12 | $4,246.70 | $5,096.00 | $6,625.00 |
| Alex Webster#30 | $3.09 | $1,020.00 | $1,224.00 | $1,591.00 |
| Gordon Soltau#130 | $3.08 | $7,200.00 | $8,640.00 | $11,232.00 |
| Chicago Cardinals#69 | $3.03 | $363.00 | $747.36 | $972.00 |
| Bill George#119 | $3.02 | $112.79 | $715.21 | $930.00 |
| Woodley Lewis#82 | $3.01 | — | — | — |
| Joe Marconi#63 | $3.01 | $93.38 | $585.79 | $762.00 |
| Bert Rechichar#74 | $3.01 | $1,440.00 | $1,728.00 | $2,246.00 |
| Johnny Carson#47 | $3.01 | $4,680.00 | $5,616.00 | $7,301.00 |
| Rick Casares#53 | $3.00 | $184.00 | $588.24 | $765.00 |
| Frank Varrichione#77 | $3.00 | $256.00 | $771.53 | $1,003.00 |
| Matt Hazeltine#100 | $3.00 | $107.61 | $680.69 | $885.00 |
| Howard Cassady#7 | $2.99 | $230.08 | $632.56 | $822.00 |
| Bob Boyd#21 | $2.98 | $630.00 | $756.00 | $983.00 |
| Jimmy Carr#65 | $2.98 | $100.08 | $630.44 | $820.00 |
| Tobin Rote#94 | $2.92 | $124.00 | $626.37 | $814.00 |
| Roosevelt Brown#102 | $2.90 | $276.00 | $533.76 | $694.00 |
| Jim David#13 | $2.84 | $97.05 | $610.27 | $793.00 |
| Gene Brito#113 | $2.81 | $91.01 | $570.04 | $741.00 |
| Earl Putman#88 | $2.75 | $89.00 | $358.49 | $466.00 |
| Steve Meilinger#33 | $2.72 | $840.00 | $1,008.00 | $1,310.00 |
| Joe Krupa#104 | $2.71 | $1,125.01 | $1,350.00 | $1,755.00 |
| Los Angeles Rams#85 | $2.65 | $870.00 | $1,044.00 | $1,357.00 |
| Detroit Lions#115 | $2.65 | $11,578.38 | $13,894.00 | $18,062.00 |
| Carl Brettschnieder#28 | $2.63 | — | — | — |
| Ray Mathews#78 | $2.62 | $1,740.00 | $2,088.00 | $2,714.00 |
| Billy Wells#49 | $2.57 | $90.98 | $569.82 | $741.00 |
| Gary Glick#19 | $2.56 | $117.00 | $600.35 | $780.00 |
| Duane Putnam#55 | $2.52 | $58.97 | $356.43 | $463.00 |
| Dale Dodrill#46 | $2.50 | $1,950.00 | $2,340.00 | $3,042.00 |
| Gary Knafelc#56 | $2.44 | $4,006.18 | $4,807.00 | $6,249.00 |
| Pete Brewster#11 | $2.39 | $82.23 | $511.49 | $665.00 |
| Don Chandler#54 | $2.34 | $1,500.00 | $1,800.00 | $2,340.00 |
| Dick Bielski#111 | $2.33 | $115.20 | $491.28 | $639.00 |
| Mike McCormack#59 | $2.30 | $113.69 | $721.17 | $938.00 |
| Dick Moegle#124 | $2.28 | $900.00 | $1,080.00 | $1,404.00 |
| Tom Wilson#67 | $2.27 | $158.00 | $400.72 | $521.00 |
| Larry Morris#50 | $2.26 | $3,720.00 | $4,464.00 | $5,803.00 |
| Don Paul#91 | $2.26 | $120.00 | $549.56 | $714.00 |
| L.G. Dupre#117 | $2.25 | $1,900.07 | $2,280.00 | $2,964.00 |
| Walt Yowarsky#101 | $2.25 | $199.00 | $483.38 | $628.00 |
| Bobby Walston#87 | $2.25 | $600.00 | $720.00 | $936.00 |
| John Carson#47 | $2.20 | $1,110.00 | — | — |
| Chet Hanulak#45 | $2.19 | $102.00 | $412.89 | $537.00 |
| Sam Baker#34 | $2.16 | $810.00 | $972.00 | $1,264.00 |
| Dick Nolan#131 | $2.12 | $3,720.00 | $4,464.00 | $5,803.00 |
| Jim Podoley#121 | $2.09 | $104.00 | $451.13 | $586.00 |
| Gene Filipski#1 | $2.04 | $3,110.86 | $3,733.00 | $4,853.00 |
| Paige Cothren#92 | $2.00 | $84.00 | $467.21 | $607.00 |
| Preston Carpenter#128 | $1.97 | $4,680.00 | $5,616.00 | $7,301.00 |
| R.C. Owens#64 | $1.96 | — | — | — |
| Jim Mutscheller#14 | $1.93 | $74.99 | $463.24 | $602.00 |
| Ron Waller#72 | $1.93 | $5,040.00 | $6,048.00 | $7,862.00 |
| Tom Scott#125 | $1.86 | $345.31 | $483.27 | $628.00 |
| Ken Keller#108 | $1.79 | $65.92 | $402.78 | $524.00 |
| Leo Elter#25 | $1.71 | $416.00 | $457.02 | $594.00 |
| James Dooley#8 | $1.68 | $131.00 | $432.79 | $563.00 |
| Milt Davis#98 | $1.54 | $88.00 | $394.73 | $513.00 |
| John Olszewski#107 | $1.36 | $6,900.00 | $8,280.00 | $10,764.00 |
| Jerry Norton#40 | $1.35 | $1,020.00 | $1,224.00 | $1,591.00 |