1957 Topps
Football · 48 cards · checklist & values
The 1957 Topps set includes 48 cards in the Football category. Notable cards include Bart Starr, John Unitas, Paul Hornung.
Every card below links to a full price page: grade-by-grade values, live eBay listings, and price history. Collectors use this checklist to value collections and find deals.
Most valuable 1957 Topps cards
| Card | Ungraded | PSA 9 | PSA 10 | BGS 10 |
|---|---|---|---|---|
 Bart Starr#119 | $734.53 | $22,666.29 | $151,115.04 | $196,450.00 |
 John Unitas#138 | $307.22 | $9,308.36 | $62,036.81 | $80,648.00 |
 Paul Hornung#151 | $171.96 | $25,601.00 | $38,243.74 | $49,717.00 |
 Bill Sherman#58 | $110.00 | — | — | — |
 Raymond Berry#94 | $81.53 | $3,605.00 | $15,162.64 | $19,711.00 |
 Dick Lane#85 | $31.32 | $1,634.00 | $6,511.06 | $8,464.00 |
 Lenny Moore#128 | $28.92 | $6,750.00 | $7,128.11 | $9,267.00 |
 Hugh McElhenny#95 | $16.44 | $558.78 | $3,689.58 | $4,796.00 |
| Frank Gifford#88 | $14.60 | $1,526.50 | $2,646.34 | $3,440.00 |
 Chuck Bednarik#49 | $13.00 | $1,252.34 | $2,807.36 | $3,650.00 |
 George Blanda#31 | $12.72 | $154.00 | $2,589.39 | $3,366.00 |
 Y.A. Tittle#30 | $11.38 | $359.42 | $2,360.10 | $3,068.00 |
| Bill Sherman#58 | $9.00 | $243.37 | — | — |
 Stan Jones#96 | $8.92 | $314.00 | $1,640.85 | $2,133.00 |
 Jack Butler#15 | $8.59 | $2,090.00 | $2,508.00 | $3,260.00 |
 Elroy Hirsch#46 | $8.57 | $373.67 | $2,455.17 | $3,192.00 |
 Elbie Nickel#101 | $8.09 | $1,869.00 | $2,243.00 | $2,916.00 |
 Walt Michaels#102 | $7.96 | $255.75 | $1,668.76 | $2,169.00 |
 Emlen Tunnell#35 | $7.48 | $237.97 | $1,550.25 | $2,015.00 |
 Eddie Bell#99 | $7.41 | $287.02 | $1,877.33 | $2,441.00 |
 Norm Van Brocklin#22 | $6.75 | $975.00 | $2,119.85 | $2,756.00 |
 Steve Meilinger#89 | $6.09 | $219.42 | $1,426.56 | $1,855.00 |
 Buck Lansford#90 | $5.72 | $585.00 | $1,140.77 | $1,483.00 |
| Ernie Stautner#92 | $4.99 | $439.00 | $1,058.61 | $1,376.00 |
| Bill Howton#33 | $4.85 | $560.00 | $1,027.01 | $1,335.00 |
| Dorne Dibble#97 | $4.63 | $151.85 | $975.96 | $1,269.00 |
| Rick Casares#55 | $3.94 | $93.97 | $758.34 | $986.00 |
| Bill Wade#34 | $3.82 | $127.82 | $815.68 | $1,060.00 |
| Darrel Brewster#40 | $3.64 | $122.60 | $780.86 | $1,015.00 |
| Lindon Crow#91 | $3.41 | $110.22 | $698.30 | $908.00 |
| Jim Mutscheller#103 | $3.25 | $664.00 | $698.58 | $908.00 |
| Joe Childress#100 | $3.21 | $712.00 | $854.00 | $1,110.00 |
| Leo Elter#36 | $3.20 | $281.37 | $688.09 | $895.00 |
| Alan Ameche#53 | $3.13 | $115.17 | $731.34 | $951.00 |
| Preston Carpenter#93 | $2.99 | $117.92 | $749.66 | $975.00 |
| Dave Mann#50 | $2.83 | $97.92 | $616.33 | $801.00 |
| Bill McPeak#51 | $2.75 | $79.72 | $494.96 | $643.00 |
| Gene Brito#48 | $2.60 | $221.01 | $644.98 | $838.00 |
| Kenny Konz#52 | $2.32 | $87.11 | $544.18 | $707.00 |
| Charlie Ane#56 | $2.29 | $87.12 | $544.26 | $708.00 |
| Gary Knafelc#45 | $2.29 | $82.18 | $511.35 | $665.00 |
| Al Carmichael#57 | $2.25 | $79.40 | $492.82 | $641.00 |
| Gordon Soltau#54 | $2.25 | $79.41 | $492.85 | $641.00 |
| Bert Rechichar#41 | $2.13 | $424.62 | $492.88 | $641.00 |
| Clarence Peaks#37 | $2.09 | $91.73 | $575.01 | $748.00 |
| Ed Brown#43 | $2.01 | $238.00 | $441.45 | $574.00 |
| Billy Wilson#42 | $1.91 | $299.95 | $492.72 | $641.00 |
| Bill Sherman#58 | — | — | — | — |
Frequently asked questions
- What is the most valuable card in 1957 Topps?
- The Bart Starr #119 leads the set at around $734.53 ungraded — graded copies sell for more.
- How many cards are in 1957 Topps?
- The checklist has 48 cards — every one is listed above with current values.