Cards tracked
189
With a value
129
With recorded sales
130
Value range
$1–$85
Median value
$6
PSA 10 vs raw
~255.7×
Ripbin tracks 129 priced cards from 1951 Topps Magic, with values from $1 to $85 — the top 10 cards account for 36% of the set's tracked value.
Shop 1951 Topps Magic on eBay
Affiliate — we may earn a commission1951 Topps Magic checklist, prices and values — all 189 cards in one place, led by Bill Burkhalter, William Reichardt, John Coatta.
Browse the complete checklist below with current market values for every card. Click any card for its full grade ladder — PSA, BGS, CGC and SGC — and live eBay listings.
Most valuable 1951 Topps Magic cards
Most actively traded 1951 Topps Magic cards
Ranked by recorded sales volume.
| # | Card | Sales | Value |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | John Dottley#62 | 22 | $5.71 |
| 2 | Gil Bartosh#27 | 21 | $7.79 |
| 3 | Bill Vesprini#40 | 21 | $5.50 |
| 4 | George Young#48 | 19 | $13.96 |
| 5 | Dave Waters#58 | 19 | $5.62 |
| 6 | Babe Parilli#4 | 18 | $24.61 |
| 7 | Tom Rushing#29 | 18 | $6.50 |
| 8 | Bill Putich#47 | 18 | $5.40 |
| 9 | Clyde Pickard#52 | 17 | $9.34 |
| 10 | Jim Weatherall#12 | 17 | $8.54 |
Price distribution
Under $25124 (96%)
$25–$1005 (4%)
$100–$5000 (0%)
$500+0 (0%)
| Card | Ungraded | PSA 9 | PSA 10 | BGS 10 |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Bill Burkhalter#5 | $85.00 | — | — | — |
| William Reichardt#3 | $80.00 | — | — | — |
| John Coatta#17 | $80.00 | — | — | — |
| Vic Janowicz#10 | $41.75 | $1,843.44 | $12,295.50 | $15,984.00 |
 Babe Parilli#4 | $25.82 | — | — | — |
 Babe Parilli#4 | $24.61 | $926.98 | $6,164.48 | $8,014.00 |
 Bob Reynolds#53 | $17.38 | $661.67 | $4,389.62 | $5,707.00 |
 Bill Wade#2 | $16.24 | $1,437.00 | $3,696.35 | $4,805.00 |
 Bert Rechichar#30 | $15.00 | — | — | — |
 George Young#48 | $13.96 | $662.00 | $3,530.88 | $4,590.00 |
 John Bright#72 | $13.57 | $518.63 | $3,432.69 | $4,463.00 |
 George Young#48 | $12.97 | — | — | — |
 Steve Wadiak#36 | $11.50 | — | — | — |
 John Coatta#17 | $11.00 | $376.31 | $2,480.56 | $3,225.00 |
 Dale Samuels#55 | $10.20 | $392.33 | $2,587.72 | $3,364.00 |
 Dick Gregory#54 | $9.99 | $370.67 | $2,442.84 | $3,176.00 |
 Jim Weatherall#12 | $9.95 | — | — | — |
 Joe Johnson#68 | $9.95 | $438.05 | $2,893.59 | $3,762.00 |
 Frank Smith#50 | $9.90 | $374.65 | $2,469.46 | $3,210.00 |
 Bruce Patton#18 | $9.89 | $370.08 | $2,438.88 | $3,171.00 |
 Capt. Don McRae#49 | $9.75 | — | — | — |
| Carroll McDonald#66 | $9.50 | — | — | — |
 Clyde Pickard#52 | $9.34 | $360.18 | $2,372.70 | $3,085.00 |
 Jimmy Monahan#1 | $8.75 | $321.11 | $2,111.31 | $2,745.00 |
 John Karras#9 | $8.59 | — | — | — |
 Jim Weatherall#12 | $8.54 | $321.55 | $2,114.23 | $2,749.00 |
 Armand Kitto#45 | $8.41 | $268.33 | $1,758.23 | $2,286.00 |
 Dick Hightower#51 | $8.19 | $310.17 | $2,038.07 | $2,649.00 |
 Bill Fuchs#38 | $8.16 | — | — | — |
 Byron Townsend#34 | $8.07 | $312.58 | $2,054.22 | $2,670.00 |
 Hi Faubion#63 | $8.06 | $312.02 | $2,050.49 | $2,666.00 |
 John Petitbon#33 | $8.02 | $252.11 | $1,649.66 | $2,145.00 |
 Bob Steele#24 | $8.00 | $309.85 | $2,035.95 | $2,647.00 |
 Gil Bartosh#27 | $7.79 | $303.21 | $1,991.57 | $2,589.00 |
| Nick Liotta#61 | $7.75 | — | — | — |
 Bill Putich#47 | $7.75 | — | — | — |
| Arnold Burwitz#69 | $7.75 | — | — | — |
 Bob Bestwick#28 | $7.05 | $319.94 | $2,103.44 | $2,734.00 |
| Joe Dudeck#71 | $7.00 | — | — | — |
 Bruce Patton#18 | $7.00 | — | — | — |
 Ed Dobrowolski#70 | $7.00 | $272.09 | $1,783.34 | $2,318.00 |
 Walt Trillhaase#26 | $6.97 | $276.76 | $1,814.59 | $2,359.00 |
 Zack Jordan#41 | $6.88 | — | — | — |
 John Karras#9 | $6.83 | $270.42 | $1,772.18 | $2,304.00 |
 Glenn Smith#44 | $6.76 | $297.38 | $1,952.50 | $2,538.00 |
 Armand Kitto#45 | $6.69 | — | — | — |
 Dick Dewing#67 | $6.61 | $289.71 | $1,901.22 | $2,472.00 |
 Vinnie Drake#46 | $6.53 | $225.43 | $1,471.17 | $1,913.00 |
 Bill Fuchs#38 | $6.50 | $250.60 | $1,639.56 | $2,131.00 |
 Tom Rushing#29 | $6.50 | $254.37 | $1,664.81 | $2,164.00 |
 Marion Campbell#19 | $6.44 | $252.49 | $1,652.23 | $2,148.00 |
 Lawrence Hairston#74 | $6.38 | $261.54 | $1,712.80 | $2,227.00 |
 Joe Dudeck#71 | $6.38 | $274.22 | $1,797.58 | $2,337.00 |
 Frank Guthridge#8 | $6.31 | $207.98 | $1,354.46 | $1,761.00 |
 Charles Hanson#43 | $6.28 | $245.45 | $1,605.16 | $2,087.00 |
 Zack Jordan#41 | $6.27 | $244.93 | $1,601.62 | $2,082.00 |
 Clyde Pickard#52 | $6.25 | — | — | — |
| Hi Faubion#63 | $6.25 | — | — | — |
| Dick Dewing#67 | $6.25 | — | — | — |
 Bill Owens#31 | $6.24 | $206.71 | $1,345.95 | $1,750.00 |
Showing the top 60 of 189 cards. View the full 1951 Topps Magic checklist (189 cards) →
Frequently asked questions
- What is the most valuable card in 1951 Topps Magic?
- The most valuable card in 1951 Topps Magic is the Bill Burkhalter #5, worth around $85.00 ungraded — graded copies sell for more.
- How many cards are in 1951 Topps Magic?
- Ripbin tracks 189 1951 Topps Magic cards, 129 of them with current values. Browse the full list above.
- How much are 1951 Topps Magic cards worth?
- 1951 Topps Magic cards range from $1 to $85, with a median value of $6. The top 10 cards hold about 36% of the set's tracked value.
- Is it worth grading 1951 Topps Magic cards?
- Across 1951 Topps Magic cards we track with both raw and PSA 10 prices, a PSA 10 sells for roughly 255.7× the ungraded price. Grading pristine copies can pay off — check each card's grade ladder before submitting.
Parallels & inserts in 1951 Topps Magic
PanelUN Rubbed
Notable players in 1951 Topps Magic
Bill BurkhalterWilliam ReichardtJohn CoattaVic JanowiczBabe ParilliBob ReynoldsBill WadeBert RechicharGeorge YoungJohn BrightSteve WadiakDale SamuelsDick GregoryJim WeatherallJoe JohnsonFrank SmithBruce PattonCapt. Don McRaeCarroll McDonaldClyde PickardJimmy MonahanJohn KarrasArmand KittoDick Hightower
Explore 1951 Topps Magic
1951 Topps Magic live on eBay
Affiliate — we may earn a commissionRelated sets
- 1991 Pro Set Base Set checklist & values850 cards
- 1990 Pro Set Base Set checklist & values801 cards
- 1992 Topps Base Set checklist & values759 cards
- 1992 Pro Set Base Set checklist & values701 cards
- 1992 Stadium Club Base Set checklist & values700 cards
- 1991 Upper Deck Base Set checklist & values692 cards
- 1991 Score Base Set checklist & values686 cards
- 1992 Pacific Base Set checklist & values660 cards