1940 Play Ball — full checklist
All 241 cards with grade-by-grade values. ← Back to 1940 Play Ball overview
| Card | Ungraded | PSA 9 | PSA 10 | BGS 10 |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Joe Jackson#225 | $2,097.03 | — | — | — |
| Ted Williams#27 | $849.50 | $256,200.00 | $287,998.13 | $374,398.00 |
| Joe DiMaggio#1 | $796.50 | $33,039.80 | $221,781.17 | $288,316.00 |
| Jimmie Foxx#133 | $263.24 | $13,080.38 | $87,779.83 | $114,114.00 |
| Honus Wagner#168 | $262.50 | $10,311.38 | $69,189.79 | $89,947.00 |
| Moe Berg#30 | $231.75 | $11,710.18 | $78,580.67 | $102,155.00 |
| Christy Mathewson#175 | $191.75 | $10,703.89 | $71,824.94 | $93,372.00 |
| Hank Greenberg#40 | $180.00 | $8,506.35 | $57,071.66 | $74,193.00 |
| Walter Johnson#120 | $173.50 | $9,013.52 | $60,476.55 | $78,620.00 |
| Mel Ott#88 | $152.88 | $7,722.03 | $51,805.73 | $67,347.00 |
| Larry Lajoie#173 | $124.50 | — | — | — |
| Charley Gehringer#41 | $123.24 | $6,145.96 | $41,224.66 | $53,592.00 |
| Big Poison Waner#104 | $95.75 | $3,893.03 | $26,099.22 | $33,929.00 |
| Goose Goslin#232 | $95.19 | $4,556.21 | $30,551.72 | $39,717.00 |
| Bill Dickey#7 | $92.16 | $4,668.53 | $31,305.73 | $40,697.00 |
| Spud Chandler#181 | $89.25 | $4,517.58 | $30,292.31 | $39,380.00 |
| Wee Willie Keeler#237 | $88.49 | — | — | — |
| Mickey Cochrane#180 | $86.71 | $3,943.56 | $26,438.53 | $34,370.00 |
| OL Pete Alexander#119 | $80.86 | — | — | — |
| Lefty Gomez#6 | $78.32 | $2,969.62 | $19,899.86 | $25,870.00 |
| Frank 'Husk' Chance#234 | $78.09 | — | — | — |
| Casey Stengel#141 | $76.50 | $3,819.29 | $25,604.33 | $33,286.00 |
| Carl Hubbell#87 | $75.00 | $3,562.82 | $23,882.27 | $31,047.00 |
| Connie Mack#132 | $73.29 | $3,190.28 | $21,381.18 | $27,796.00 |
| Pie Traynor#224 | $72.00 | $3,645.12 | $24,434.85 | $31,765.00 |
| Lloyd Waner#105 | $71.88 | $3,450.08 | $23,125.53 | $30,063.00 |
| Tris Speaker#170 | $69.75 | $3,569.19 | $23,925.10 | $31,103.00 |
| Bobby Doerr#38 | $64.72 | $4,952.16 | $33,209.89 | $43,173.00 |
| George Sisler#179 | $64.12 | $3,241.38 | $21,724.33 | $28,242.00 |
| Harry Heilmann#171 | $62.75 | $3,537.26 | $23,710.78 | $30,824.00 |
| Red Faber#230 | $61.16 | $3,098.28 | $20,763.61 | $26,993.00 |
| Frank Homerun Baker#177 | $60.97 | — | — | — |
| Jim Bottomley#236 | $60.92 | $3,075.26 | $20,609.04 | $26,792.00 |
| Tony Lazzeri#238 | $59.51 | $3,015.93 | $20,210.78 | $26,274.00 |
| John J. McGraw#235 | $57.49 | — | — | — |
| Johnny Evers#174 | $54.98 | $2,636.92 | $17,666.26 | $22,966.00 |
| Joe Cronin#134 | $50.79 | $2,575.70 | $17,255.26 | $22,432.00 |
| Arky Vaughan#107 | $46.28 | $2,333.66 | $15,630.29 | $20,319.00 |
| Chief Bender#172 | $44.99 | $2,281.77 | $15,281.85 | $19,866.00 |
| Harry Hooper#226 | $44.50 | $2,163.50 | $14,487.81 | $18,834.00 |
| Heinie Manush#176 | $43.55 | $2,209.61 | $14,797.42 | $19,237.00 |
| Earl Averill#46 | $42.86 | $2,105.72 | $14,099.96 | $18,330.00 |
| Frankie Frisch#167 | $42.75 | $1,954.61 | $13,085.43 | $17,011.00 |
| Colonel Combs#124 | $41.81 | — | — | — |
| Chuck Klein#102 | $40.87 | $1,650.02 | $11,040.56 | $14,353.00 |
| Red Ruffing#10 | $39.37 | $2,282.92 | $15,289.61 | $19,876.00 |
| Pop Haines#227 | $38.14 | — | — | — |
| Daffy Dean#156 | $35.39 | $1,437.14 | $9,611.27 | $12,495.00 |
| Lee Gamble#208 | $34.01 | $1,677.06 | $11,222.01 | $14,589.00 |
| Hugh Jennings#223 | $33.50 | — | — | — |
| Stonewall Jackson#158 | $31.82 | $1,318.56 | $8,815.24 | $11,460.00 |
| Knick Knickerbocker#182 | $31.16 | $1,248.47 | $8,344.69 | $10,848.00 |
| Pinky Higgins#199 | $30.46 | $1,544.72 | $10,333.51 | $13,434.00 |
| Highpockets Kelly#142 | $30.00 | $1,524.73 | $10,199.33 | $13,259.00 |
| Mace Brown#220 | $29.96 | $1,535.80 | $10,273.72 | $13,356.00 |
| Schoolboy Hoyt#118 | $28.88 | $1,739.48 | $11,641.12 | $15,133.00 |
| Johnnie McCarthy#215 | $28.69 | $1,473.96 | $9,858.48 | $12,816.00 |
| Ken O'Dea#214 | $28.51 | $1,024.22 | $6,839.10 | $8,891.00 |
| Bad News Hale#203 | $28.30 | $1,438.86 | $9,622.88 | $12,510.00 |
| Bill McKechnie#153 | $27.53 | $1,339.94 | $8,958.71 | $11,646.00 |
| Max Butcher#222 | $27.11 | $1,386.44 | $9,270.93 | $12,052.00 |
| Rick Ferrell#21 | $27.00 | $1,264.84 | $8,454.56 | $10,991.00 |
| Bucky Walters#73 | $25.73 | $1,239.40 | $8,283.79 | $10,769.00 |
| Wally Millies#218 | $25.28 | $928.86 | $6,198.93 | $8,059.00 |
| Max Carey#178 | $24.99 | $1,283.35 | $8,578.84 | $11,152.00 |
| Mel Almada#71 | $24.99 | $1,271.70 | $8,500.61 | $11,051.00 |
| Walter Beck#217 | $24.68 | $870.16 | $5,804.85 | $7,546.00 |
| Lonny Frey#76 | $24.12 | $946.00 | $7,362.69 | $9,572.00 |
| John Rucker#213 | $23.89 | $1,216.09 | $8,127.21 | $10,565.00 |
| Duke Derringer#74 | $23.50 | $1,271.78 | $8,501.14 | $11,051.00 |
| Barney McCosky#201 | $23.23 | $1,156.42 | $7,726.65 | $10,045.00 |
| Bucky Harris#129 | $23.04 | $1,356.03 | $9,066.78 | $11,787.00 |
| Jimmy Dykes#187 | $23.00 | $1,171.64 | $7,828.83 | $10,177.00 |
| Twinkletoes Selkirk#8 | $22.74 | $1,158.65 | $7,741.67 | $10,064.00 |
| Dolf Luque#231 | $22.50 | $1,146.01 | $7,656.73 | $9,954.00 |
| Nonny Nonnenkamp#196 | $22.50 | $1,143.82 | $7,642.02 | $9,935.00 |
| Buck Herzog#229 | $22.48 | $1,144.01 | $7,643.30 | $9,936.00 |
| Whitey Moore#150 | $22.25 | $1,133.84 | $7,575.05 | $9,848.00 |
| Dick Siebert#192 | $22.16 | $1,133.50 | $7,572.78 | $9,845.00 |
| Lee Handley#221 | $22.00 | $1,029.32 | $6,873.34 | $8,935.00 |
| Chet Laabs#206 | $21.57 | $1,102.50 | $7,364.70 | $9,574.00 |
| Mort Cooper#113 | $21.50 | $1,270.24 | $8,490.84 | $11,038.00 |
| Bill Hershberger#77 | $21.39 | $946.00 | $5,252.42 | $6,828.00 |
| Jim Bloodworth#189 | $21.29 | $1,085.33 | $7,249.37 | $9,424.00 |
| Van Mungo#64 | $21.23 | $1,082.42 | $7,229.86 | $9,399.00 |
| Charley Berry#190 | $21.16 | $1,179.78 | $7,883.48 | $10,249.00 |
| Mule Haas#184 | $21.13 | $940.86 | $6,279.50 | $8,163.00 |
| Al Schacht#116 | $20.37 | $1,054.43 | $7,041.92 | $9,155.00 |
| Charley Grimm#228 | $20.00 | — | — | — |
| Jake Solters#126 | $19.99 | $1,006.52 | $6,720.30 | $8,736.00 |
| Gus Mancuso#207 | $19.99 | $1,087.33 | $7,262.81 | $9,442.00 |
| Buck McCormick#75 | $19.94 | $1,017.25 | $6,792.35 | $8,830.00 |
| Hal Trosky#50 | $19.94 | $958.95 | $6,400.91 | $8,321.00 |
| Art Fletcher#125 | $19.88 | $1,014.19 | $6,771.81 | $8,803.00 |
| Hugh Casey#148 | $19.81 | $982.02 | $6,555.77 | $8,523.00 |
| Hank Gowdy#82 | $19.80 | $881.28 | $5,879.47 | $7,643.00 |
| Clif Melton#83 | $19.61 | — | — | — |
| Bob Klinger#165 | $19.35 | $987.30 | $6,591.23 | $8,569.00 |
| Cookie Lavagetto#69 | $19.31 | $981.59 | $6,552.91 | $8,519.00 |
| Atley Donald#121 | $19.25 | $896.03 | $5,978.48 | $7,772.00 |
| Moose Earnshaw#233 | $19.25 | — | — | — |
| Denny Galehouse#198 | $19.07 | $976.48 | $6,518.57 | $8,474.00 |
| Soupy Campbell#200 | $18.70 | $1,024.19 | $6,838.95 | $8,891.00 |
| Chuck Dressen#72 | $18.54 | $946.88 | $6,319.90 | $8,216.00 |
| Line Drive Nelson#135 | $18.51 | — | — | — |
| Dizzy Trout#44 | $18.50 | $1,136.98 | $7,596.16 | $9,875.00 |
| Tommy Henrich#4 | $18.48 | $942.95 | $6,293.47 | $8,182.00 |
| Joe Marty#216 | $18.38 | $920.77 | $6,144.63 | $7,988.00 |
| Lou Finney#197 | $18.31 | $704.02 | $4,689.42 | $6,096.00 |
| Bill Myers#80 | $18.00 | — | — | — |
| Luke Sewell#48 | $18.00 | $729.84 | $4,862.79 | $6,322.00 |
| Debs Garms#161 | $18.00 | $717.14 | $4,777.47 | $6,211.00 |
| Hot Potato Hamlin#70 | $17.69 | $903.08 | $6,025.79 | $7,834.00 |
| Mickey Owen#111 | $17.63 | $866.24 | $5,778.54 | $7,512.00 |
| Babe Young#212 | $17.56 | $868.65 | $5,794.67 | $7,533.00 |
| George Uhle#239 | $17.51 | $923.96 | $6,166.02 | $8,016.00 |
| Tot Pressnell#146 | $17.38 | $887.80 | $5,923.26 | $7,700.00 |
| Rollie Hemsley#205 | $17.25 | $848.95 | $5,662.43 | $7,361.00 |
| Dutch Leonard#23 | $17.25 | $1,089.00 | $6,213.99 | $8,078.00 |
| Harry Danning#93 | $17.25 | $881.18 | $5,878.78 | $7,642.00 |
| Marvin Breuer#183 | $17.11 | $874.19 | $5,831.88 | $7,581.00 |
| Cecil Travis#16 | $17.00 | $694.85 | $4,627.87 | $6,016.00 |
| Lew Riggs#78 | $16.99 | $867.86 | $5,789.38 | $7,526.00 |
| Bill Atwood#240 | $16.91 | $863.81 | $5,762.16 | $7,491.00 |
| Buddy Myer#17 | $16.74 | $961.83 | $6,420.28 | $8,346.00 |
| Dolly Stark#117 | $16.72 | $854.49 | $5,699.63 | $7,410.00 |
| Sam Chapman#194 | $16.58 | $847.43 | $5,652.25 | $7,348.00 |
| Joe Vosmik#144 | $16.50 | $760.05 | $5,065.61 | $6,585.00 |
| Doc Cramer#29 | $16.50 | $881.33 | $5,879.82 | $7,644.00 |
| Jo-Jo Moore#84 | $16.35 | $931.77 | $6,218.43 | $8,084.00 |
| Don Heffner#51 | $15.98 | $816.01 | $5,441.26 | $7,074.00 |
| Babe Dahlgren#3 | $15.88 | $762.10 | $5,079.35 | $6,603.00 |
| Mike Gonzales#115 | $15.87 | — | — | — |
| Eddie Miller#56 | $15.78 | $811.25 | $5,409.32 | $7,032.00 |
| Gene Desautels#28 | $15.77 | $806.19 | $5,375.33 | $6,988.00 |
| Joe Bowman#162 | $15.75 | $792.49 | $5,283.37 | $6,868.00 |
| Tom Carey#39 | $15.56 | $635.87 | $4,231.87 | $5,501.00 |
| Fritz Ostermueller#33 | $15.50 | $698.87 | $4,654.86 | $6,051.00 |
| Beau Bell#138 | $15.50 | $767.68 | $5,116.80 | $6,652.00 |
| Don Padgett#109 | $15.46 | $791.12 | $5,274.15 | $6,856.00 |
| Morry Arnovich#97 | $15.23 | $764.68 | $5,096.62 | $6,626.00 |
| Emerson Dickman#37 | $15.18 | $765.09 | $5,099.42 | $6,629.00 |
| Rabbit McNair#14 | $15.13 | $815.12 | $5,435.30 | $7,066.00 |
| Whitey Whitehead#92 | $15.05 | $605.49 | $4,027.91 | $5,236.00 |
| Wildfire Craft#79 | $15.00 | $773.62 | $5,156.68 | $6,704.00 |
| Joe Vosmik#144 | $15.00 | — | — | — |
| Al Milnar#202 | $14.95 | $765.15 | $5,099.82 | $6,630.00 |
| Lon Warneke#114 | $14.95 | $625.19 | $4,160.16 | $5,408.00 |
| Pete Coscarart#63 | $14.91 | $764.16 | $5,093.19 | $6,621.00 |
| Hal Schumacher#85 | $14.91 | $571.71 | $3,801.16 | $4,942.00 |
| Tom Sunkel#110 | $14.88 | $755.72 | $5,036.49 | $6,547.00 |
| Joe Kuhel#185 | $14.73 | $754.04 | $5,025.21 | $6,533.00 |
| Bud Thomas#42 | $14.73 | $753.79 | $5,023.51 | $6,531.00 |
| Pinky Shoffner#149 | $14.72 | $745.06 | $4,964.90 | $6,454.00 |
| Babe Phelps#66 | $14.63 | $735.99 | $4,904.05 | $6,375.00 |
| Jimmy Brown#112 | $14.50 | $742.10 | $4,945.08 | $6,429.00 |
| Elden Auker#139 | $14.50 | $742.36 | $4,946.84 | $6,431.00 |
| John Babich#191 | $14.46 | $817.63 | $5,452.18 | $7,088.00 |
| Wally Berger#81 | $14.44 | $739.06 | $4,924.63 | $6,402.00 |
| Harry Gumbert#86 | $14.40 | $577.92 | $3,842.81 | $4,996.00 |
| Stormy Weatherly#49 | $14.37 | $728.50 | $4,853.78 | $6,310.00 |
| Hildy Hildebrand#123 | $14.34 | $489.86 | $3,251.63 | $4,227.00 |
| Fitz Fitzsimmons#65 | $14.18 | — | — | — |
| Tony Cuccinello#61 | $14.17 | $678.78 | $4,519.99 | $5,876.00 |
| Harry Eisenstat#204 | $14.14 | $720.89 | $4,802.66 | $6,243.00 |
| Del Young#101 | $14.11 | $691.90 | $4,608.02 | $5,990.00 |
| Charley Keller#9 | $14.08 | $699.21 | $4,657.13 | $6,054.00 |
| Jim Bagby#32 | $13.77 | $705.22 | $4,697.42 | $6,107.00 |
| George Case#15 | $13.64 | $1,001.00 | $4,663.59 | $6,063.00 |
| John Peacock#34 | $13.60 | $651.03 | $4,333.66 | $5,634.00 |
| Joe Krakauskas#188 | $13.59 | $696.50 | $4,638.97 | $6,031.00 |
| HY Vandenberg#209 | $13.55 | $696.41 | $4,638.32 | $6,030.00 |
| Lou Chiozza#157 | $13.52 | $679.26 | $4,523.20 | $5,880.00 |
| Bill Lohrman#210 | $13.50 | $706.97 | $4,709.19 | $6,122.00 |
| Deerfoot Milan#130 | $13.43 | $860.59 | $5,740.60 | $7,463.00 |
| Zeke Bonura#131 | $13.35 | $678.09 | $4,515.33 | $5,870.00 |
| Gus Suhr#94 | $13.33 | $647.95 | $4,313.00 | $5,607.00 |
| Pete Fox#43 | $13.29 | $619.63 | $4,122.82 | $5,360.00 |
| Jimmy Wilson#152 | $13.27 | $680.02 | $4,528.25 | $5,887.00 |
| Gene Moore#143 | $13.25 | $664.43 | $4,423.62 | $5,751.00 |
| Elbie Fletcher#103 | $13.25 | $678.95 | $4,521.06 | $5,877.00 |
| Pete Appleton#128 | $13.21 | $749.84 | $4,997.04 | $6,496.00 |
| Edwin Joost#151 | $13.21 | $667.06 | $4,441.29 | $5,774.00 |
| Monte Pearson#5 | $13.14 | $673.39 | $4,483.75 | $5,829.00 |
| Cotton Pippen#136 | $13.13 | $671.37 | $4,470.21 | $5,811.00 |
| Buddy Lewis#20 | $13.00 | $666.43 | $4,437.04 | $5,768.00 |
| Dee Miles#195 | $13.00 | $754.00 | $4,438.28 | $5,770.00 |
| Johnny Rizzo#108 | $13.00 | $666.40 | $4,436.84 | $5,768.00 |
| Pinky May#98 | $12.99 | $697.70 | $4,646.99 | $6,041.00 |
| Bill Jurges#89 | $12.96 | $714.05 | $4,756.73 | $6,184.00 |
| Rabbit Warstler#59 | $12.88 | $822.22 | $5,483.01 | $7,128.00 |
| Ray Berres#164 | $12.87 | $655.46 | $4,363.42 | $5,672.00 |
| Bill Brubaker#166 | $12.77 | $641.41 | $4,269.08 | $5,550.00 |
| Russ Bauers#219 | $12.75 | $591.85 | $3,936.33 | $5,117.00 |
| Sammy West#22 | $12.64 | $640.07 | $4,260.07 | $5,538.00 |
| Sandy Sundra#122 | $12.55 | $643.92 | $4,285.89 | $5,572.00 |
| Johnny Hudson#147 | $12.53 | $630.09 | $4,193.04 | $5,451.00 |
| Heinie Mueller#96 | $12.51 | $641.65 | $4,270.67 | $5,552.00 |
| Whit Wyatt#67 | $12.50 | $640.90 | $4,265.63 | $5,545.00 |
| Buddy Hassett#62 | $12.50 | $619.55 | $4,122.33 | $5,359.00 |
| Pop Joiner#211 | $12.50 | $641.40 | $4,268.98 | $5,550.00 |
| Pep Young#106 | $12.47 | $639.67 | $4,257.37 | $5,535.00 |
| Art Jorgens#2 | $12.44 | $638.24 | $4,247.80 | $5,522.00 |
| John Cooney#60 | $12.32 | $681.24 | $4,536.50 | $5,897.00 |
| Myril Hoag#52 | $12.23 | $684.08 | $4,555.55 | $5,922.00 |
| Frank Demaree#90 | $12.10 | $642.83 | $4,278.59 | $5,562.00 |
| Muddy Ruel#127 | $12.09 | $620.68 | $4,129.87 | $5,369.00 |
| Bill Trotter#54 | $12.05 | $530.66 | $3,525.52 | $4,583.00 |
| Chubby Dean#193 | $12.01 | $613.34 | $4,080.57 | $5,305.00 |
| Hersh Martin#100 | $11.95 | $576.90 | $3,835.93 | $4,987.00 |
| Frank Blimp Hayes#24 | $11.91 | — | — | — |
| Bill Posedel#58 | $11.90 | $610.76 | $4,063.29 | $5,282.00 |
| Spud Davis#163 | $11.85 | $679.19 | $4,522.73 | $5,880.00 |
| Gabby Street#169 | $11.84 | $601.81 | $4,003.21 | $5,204.00 |
| Slick Coffman#55 | $11.84 | $1,228.00 | $4,087.35 | $5,314.00 |
| Ken Chase#19 | $11.58 | $592.87 | $3,943.17 | $5,126.00 |
| Bing Miller#137 | $11.50 | $397.91 | $2,634.28 | $3,425.00 |
| Dick Coffman#140 | $11.43 | $583.07 | $3,877.40 | $5,041.00 |
| Ray Hayworth#155 | $11.26 | $539.57 | $3,585.34 | $4,661.00 |
| Johnny Schulte#12 | $11.25 | $578.05 | $3,843.71 | $4,997.00 |
| Jake Powell#11 | $11.22 | $691.40 | $4,604.72 | $5,986.00 |
| Jack Knott#13 | $11.20 | $952.00 | $3,749.95 | $4,875.00 |
| Charley Gelbert#18 | $11.18 | $350.25 | $2,314.29 | $3,009.00 |
| Max West#57 | $11.14 | $572.47 | $3,806.23 | $4,948.00 |
| Mac McQuinn#53 | $11.05 | — | — | — |
| Taft Wright#186 | $11.00 | $634.00 | $3,591.96 | $4,670.00 |
| Jim Tabor#36 | $11.00 | $565.44 | $3,759.00 | $4,887.00 |
| Hans Lobert#160 | $11.00 | $487.84 | $3,238.06 | $4,209.00 |
| Vito Tamulis#145 | $10.93 | $560.30 | $3,724.48 | $4,842.00 |
| Wally Moses#26 | $10.92 | $561.38 | $3,731.78 | $4,851.00 |
| Cherokee B. Johnson#25 | $10.50 | — | — | — |
| Joe Heving#35 | $10.50 | $558.55 | $3,712.80 | $4,827.00 |
| Red Kress#45 | $10.20 | $654.53 | $4,357.14 | $5,664.00 |
| Jack Wilson#31 | $10.00 | $628.69 | $4,183.64 | $5,439.00 |
| Dolph Camilli#68 | $9.99 | $629.78 | $4,190.96 | $5,448.00 |
| Jumbo Brown#154 | $9.99 | $512.36 | $3,402.66 | $4,423.00 |
| Syl Johnson#99 | $9.90 | $498.96 | $3,312.73 | $4,307.00 |
| Mul Mulcahy#95 | $9.75 | $502.53 | $3,336.69 | $4,338.00 |
| Old OS Vitt#47 | $9.63 | — | — | — |
| Pancho Snyder#159 | $9.25 | $476.95 | $3,164.91 | $4,114.00 |
| Bob Suitcase Seeds#91 | $8.93 | — | — | — |