What is the most valuable card in 2024 Donruss Elite Pen Pals?

The most valuable card in 2024 Donruss Elite Pen Pals is the J.J. McCarthy #PAL-JMC, worth around $123.16 ungraded — graded copies sell for more.

How many cards are in 2024 Donruss Elite Pen Pals?

Ripbin tracks 39 2024 Donruss Elite Pen Pals cards, 31 of them with current values. Browse the full list above.

How much are 2024 Donruss Elite Pen Pals cards worth?

2024 Donruss Elite Pen Pals cards range from $1 to $123, with a median value of $5. The top 10 cards hold about 77% of the set's tracked value.

Is it worth grading 2024 Donruss Elite Pen Pals cards?

Across 2024 Donruss Elite Pen Pals cards we track with both raw and PSA 10 prices, a PSA 10 sells for roughly 8.2× the ungraded price. Grading pristine copies can pay off — check each card's grade ladder before submitting.

2024 Donruss Elite Pen Pals

Football · 39 cards · checklist & values

Part of 2024 Donruss Elite Football →

All 2024 Football cards →

Cards tracked

With a value

Value range

$1–$123

Median value

PSA 10 vs raw

~8.2×

Ripbin tracks 31 priced cards from 2024 Donruss Elite Pen Pals, with values from $1 to $123 — the top 10 cards account for 77% of the set's tracked value.

Prices last updated Aug 2026

Shop 2024 Donruss Elite Pen Pals on eBay

Affiliate — we may earn a commission

Looking for the 2024 Donruss Elite Pen Pals checklist and card values? This set has 39 cards, featuring J.J. McCarthy, Brian Thomas Jr., Rome Odunze.

Every card below links to a full price page: grade-by-grade values, live eBay listings, and price history. Collectors use this checklist to value collections and find deals.

Most valuable 2024 Donruss Elite Pen Pals cards

Price distribution

Under $2528 (90%)

$25–$1002 (6%)

$100–$5001 (3%)

$500+0 (0%)

Card	Ungraded	PSA 9	PSA 10	BGS 10
J.J. McCarthy#PAL-JMC	$123.16	$32.00	—	—
Brian Thomas Jr.#PAL-BTH	$40.00	$54.97	$163.22	$212.00
Rome Odunze#PAL-ROD	$33.44	$56.16	$141.63	$184.00
Joe Milton III#PAL-JMI	$23.50	—	—	—
Bucky Irving#PAL-BIR	$21.33	$28.00	$101.19	$132.00
Ricky Pearsall#PAL-RPE	$14.65	$29.20	$76.32	$99.00
Blake Corum#PAL-BCO	$11.93	$19.87	$69.63	$91.00
Xavier Legette#PAL-XLE	$9.99	$23.78	$63.27	$82.00
Keon Coleman#PAL-KCO	$9.85	—	—	—
Laiatu Latu#PAL-LLA	$8.95	$25.00	$59.79	$78.00
Luke McCaffrey#PAL-LMC	$7.99	$19.74	$56.62	$74.00
Roman Wilson#PAL-RWI	$7.50	$20.34	$65.00	$85.00
Spencer Rattler#PAL-SRA	$7.00	$18.96	$51.60	$67.00
Braelon Allen#PAL-BAL	$6.16	$18.48	$50.46	$66.00
Jalen McMillan#PAL-JMC	$5.69	—	—	—
Adonai Mitchell#PAL-AMI	$5.44	$17.54	$48.21	$63.00
Trey Benson#PAL-TBE	$5.27	—	—	—
Dallas Turner#PAL-DTU	$5.15	$10.50	$48.00	$62.00
Will Shipley#PAL-WSH	$4.38	—	—	—
Johnny Wilson#PAL-JWI	$3.99	—	—	—
Ja'Lynn Polk#PAL-JPO	$3.28	—	—	—
Audric Estime#PAL-AES	$3.26	$14.50	$40.87	$53.00
Ben Sinnott#PAL-BSI	$3.25	$14.48	$40.80	$53.00
Ja'Tavion Sanders#PAL-JSA	$3.25	—	—	—
Cade Stover#PAL-CST	$2.88	$14.02	$39.70	$52.00
Jaylen Wright#PAL-JWR	$2.87	$14.44	$40.73	$53.00
Jordan Travis#PAL-JTR	$2.62	—	—	—
Brenden Rice#PAL-BRI	$2.50	—	—	—
Anthony Gould#PAL-AGO	$1.51	$12.19	$20.50	$27.00
Jermaine Burton#PAL-JBU	$1.50	$12.07	$34.98	$45.00
Isaac Guerendo#PAL-IGU	$0.99	—	—	—
Ladd McConkey#PAL-LMC	—	—	—	—
Michael Pratt#PAL-MPR	—	—	—	—
Michael Penix Jr.#PAL-MPE	—	—	—	—
Troy Franklin#PAL-TFR	—	—	—	—
MarShawn Lloyd#PAL-MLL	—	—	—	—
Jonathon Brooks#PAL-JBR	—	—	—	—
Malachi Corley#PAL-MCO	—	—	—	—
Ray Davis#PAL-RDA	—	—	—	—

Frequently asked questions

What is the most valuable card in 2024 Donruss Elite Pen Pals?: The most valuable card in 2024 Donruss Elite Pen Pals is the J.J. McCarthy #PAL-JMC, worth around $123.16 ungraded — graded copies sell for more.
How many cards are in 2024 Donruss Elite Pen Pals?: Ripbin tracks 39 2024 Donruss Elite Pen Pals cards, 31 of them with current values. Browse the full list above.
How much are 2024 Donruss Elite Pen Pals cards worth?: 2024 Donruss Elite Pen Pals cards range from $1 to $123, with a median value of $5. The top 10 cards hold about 77% of the set's tracked value.
Is it worth grading 2024 Donruss Elite Pen Pals cards?: Across 2024 Donruss Elite Pen Pals cards we track with both raw and PSA 10 prices, a PSA 10 sells for roughly 8.2× the ungraded price. Grading pristine copies can pay off — check each card's grade ladder before submitting.

More in 2024 Donruss Elite — inserts & parallels

Base Set200 cards Turn of the Century Autographs76 cards 1992 The Elite Series50 cards 1992 The Elite Series Rookies50 cards Spellbound40 cards Numbers Game Jerseys30 cards Ath-Elite25 cards Full Throttle25 cards First Class24 cards Rookie on Deck20 cards Extra Edition20 cards Influential Jerseys20 cards Elite Deck20 cards Back to the Future Signatures19 cards MVPBound18 cards GOATBound17 cards LombardiBound16 cards Etched in Time Signatures16 cards Epic Materials15 cards High Life15 cards Rookie Elitist15 cards The Elite15 cards Elite Coverage15 cards Field Vision10 cards Throwback Threads Singles10 cards Title Waves10 cards Elitist10 cards Throwback Threads Doubles10 cards Passing the Torch Signatures Singles9 cards Pen Pals Variation Black Gold Ink8 cards Pen Pals Duals8 cards Pen Pals Triples8 cards Impact Impressions7 cards Team Lineage Signatures6 cards Mystery Rookies Redemption6 cards Pen Pals Quads5 cards Passing the Torch Signatures Doubles4 cards Spellbound Autographs0 cards

Notable players in 2024 Donruss Elite Pen Pals

Explore 2024 Donruss Elite Pen Pals

Most valuable 2024 Donruss Elite Pen Pals cards →All 2024 Donruss Elite sets & parallels →All Football cards →