Ripbin
Scan

Ad disclosure: As an eBay Partner Network affiliate, Ripbin earns from qualifying purchases. Learn more

🔥 Hot buys on eBay

See all →

As an eBay Partner Network affiliate, Ripbin earns from qualifying purchases.

1991 Pro Set Base Set

Football · 924 cards · checklist & values

Part of 1991 Pro Set Football →

All 1991 Football cards →

John Randle, 1991 Pro Set Base SetDerrick Thomas, 1991 Pro Set Base SetDarion Conner, 1991 Pro Set Base SetNeil O'Donnell, 1991 Pro Set Base Set
Cards tracked
900
With a value
761
With recorded sales
23
Value range
$0–$10
Median value
$1
PSA 10 vs raw
~45.3×

Ripbin tracks 761 priced cards from 1991 Pro Set Base Set, with values from $0 to $10 — the top 10 cards account for 4% of the set's tracked value.

Prices last updated Aug 2026

Shop 1991 Pro Set Base Set on eBay

As an eBay Partner Network affiliate, Ripbin earns from qualifying purchases.

Looking for the 1991 Pro Set Base Set checklist and card values? This set has 924 cards, featuring John Randle, Derrick Thomas, Darion Conner.

Browse the complete checklist below with current market values for every card. Click any card for its full grade ladder — PSA, BGS, CGC and SGC — and live eBay listings.

Most valuable 1991 Pro Set Base Set cards

Browse 1991 Pro Set Base Set singles on eBay ↗

Most actively traded 1991 Pro Set Base Set cards

Ranked by recorded sales volume.

Price distribution

Under $25761 (100%)
$25–$1000 (0%)
$100–$5000 (0%)
$500+0 (0%)
CardUngradedPSA 9PSA 10BGS 10
1991 Pro Set Base Set John Randle #835 cardJohn Randle#835$10.28$52.54$210.25$273.00
1991 Pro Set Base Set Derrick Thomas Error Bills Helmet on Front #19 cardDerrick Thomas#19 · Error Bills Helmet on Front$5.12$40.00$99.99$130.00
1991 Pro Set Base Set Darion Conner Drafted 1st Round '99 #92 cardDarion Conner#92 · Drafted 1st Round '99$2.26———
1991 Pro Set Base Set Neil O'Donnell #845 cardNeil O'Donnell#845$2.25$34.99$124.83$162.00
Dick Jorgensen#353$2.05———
Tom Waddle#818$2.01$37.35$129.95$169.00
1991 Pro Set Base Set Jim Kelly No NFLPA Logo #78 cardJim Kelly#78 · No NFLPA Logo$2.00———
Alfredo Roberts#720$1.99———
Jackie Slater#556$1.99———
James Campen#508$1.99———
91, 494 Jam Coliseum#814$1.99———
Lawrence Taylor / Bill Parcells#718$1.99———
Willie Green#823$1.99———
Mark Higgs#831$1.98———
Jankovich Hired to Rebuild Patriots#344$1.90———
Jarvis Williams#215$1.88———
James Williams#87$1.87———
Guy McIntyre#293$1.87———
1991 Pro Set Base Set Jerome Brown #392 cardJerome Brown#392$1.85$29.30$112.61$146.00
Tim McDonald#264$1.83———
Charles Haley#651$1.82———
Mike Croel#850 · Rookie of the Year$1.82———
Reggie Cobb#308$1.79———
1991 Pro Set Base Set Bruce Smith #417 cardBruce Smith#417$1.79$84.00$101.00$131.00
Young Named NFL's Top Executive#688$1.79$37.45——
Kenny Walker#822$1.79———
Mike Utley#849$1.78$22.48——
Tony Casillas#820$1.77———
Dwayne Woodruff#702$1.76———
1991 Pro Set Base Set Jim Kelly NFLPA Logo on Back #78 cardJim Kelly#78 · NFLPA Logo on Back$1.75$22.50$24.99$32.00
Shaun Gayle#455$1.75———
Erik Kramer#824$1.75$20.59$59.95$78.00
Michael Jackson#819$1.75———
Frank Stams#205$1.74———
Carl Hairston#695$1.72———
Hardy Nickerson#636$1.71———
Keith Van Horne#107$1.71———
Jamie Mueller#446$1.71———
Hugh Millen#836$1.70———
1991 Pro Set Base Set Warren Moon #370 cardWarren Moon#370$1.69$21.58$101.29$132.00
Jack Pardee#171$1.69———
Jim Covert#102$1.69———
Danny Lockett#706$1.69———
Dave Krieg#664$1.69———
Eric Martin#591$1.69———
Randal Hill#843$1.68$9.95——
Tom Tupa#629$1.68———
1991 Pro Set Base Set Bo Jackson #42 cardBo Jackson#42$1.67$26.00$58.50$76.00
James Washington#486$1.67—$39.95$52.00
1991 Pro Set Base Set Jackie Slater #382 cardJackie Slater#382$1.67———
Craig Heyward#236$1.67———
Sam Clancy#525$1.67———
Bruce Kozerski#463$1.66———
1991 Pro Set Base Set Derrick Thomas Chiefs Helmet on Front #19 cardDerrick Thomas#19 · Chiefs Helmet on Front$1.65$29.99——
Ken Dallafior#497$1.65$21.31$99.60$129.00
Jim Everett#200$1.65———
Kevin Walker#466$1.64———
1991 Pro Set Base Set Taylor Sacks Vikings #336 cardTaylor Sacks Vikings#336$1.64$11.00$21.71$28.00
Roger Craig#21$1.63$20.28$93.28$121.00
Dwayne Harper#662$1.62———

Showing the top 60 of 924 cards. View the full 1991 Pro Set Base Set checklist (924 cards) →

Frequently asked questions

What is the most valuable card in 1991 Pro Set Base Set?
The most valuable card in 1991 Pro Set Base Set is the John Randle #835, worth around $10.28 ungraded — graded copies sell for more.
How many cards are in 1991 Pro Set Base Set?
Ripbin tracks 900 1991 Pro Set Base Set cards, 761 of them with current values. Browse the full list above.
How much are 1991 Pro Set Base Set cards worth?
1991 Pro Set Base Set cards range from $0 to $10, with a median value of $1. The top 10 cards hold about 4% of the set's tracked value.
Is it worth grading 1991 Pro Set Base Set cards?
Across 1991 Pro Set Base Set cards we track with both raw and PSA 10 prices, a PSA 10 sells for roughly 45.3× the ungraded price. Grading pristine copies can pay off — check each card's grade ladder before submitting.

More in 1991 Pro Set — inserts & parallels

Parallels & inserts in 1991 Pro Set Base Set

All-NFC TeamChiefs Helmet on FrontDrafted 1st Round '99Error Bills Helmet on FrontGazetteLarge Type on BackNFLPA Logo on BackNo NFLPA LogoOffensive RoyRookie of the YearSmall Type on Backthink about itThink About ItTHINK ABOUT ITThink About It...Uer: Missing Copyright on Back

Notable players in 1991 Pro Set Base Set

Explore 1991 Pro Set Base Set

1991 Pro Set Base Set live on eBay

As an eBay Partner Network affiliate, Ripbin earns from qualifying purchases.