Ripbin
Scan

Tyler Toffoli card values & price guide

Tyler Toffoli has 208 cards tracked; the most valuable is the 2022-23 Upper Deck Premier Premier Mega Patch Chest Logos Tyler Toffoli #PMP-LI at $82.66 as of September 26, 2026.

208 cards · 200 sets · 2018–2024

Share

Shop Tyler Toffoli cards on eBay

Affiliate — we may earn a commission

Ripbin tracks 50 priced Tyler Toffoli cards worth $0–$83 — the top 10 account for 69% of tracked value; PSA 10 copies trade ~14.6× raw.

Prices last updated Sep 2026

Cards tracked
208
Highest value
$82.66
Value range
$0–$83
Median value
$3
PSA 10 avg
$40
With recorded sales
5

Tyler Toffoli has 208 hockey cards in the Ripbin catalog across 200 sets, valued $0.25–$82.66, topped by the 2022-23 Upper Deck Premier Premier Mega Patch Chest Logos Tyler Toffoli #PMP-LI at about $82.66 ungraded.

Most valuable Tyler Toffoli cards

2022-23 Upper Deck Premier Premier Mega Patch Chest Logos Tyler Toffoli #PMP-LI card
2022-23 Upper Deck Premier Premier Mega Patch Chest Logos
$82.66
2024-25 Upper Deck Ultimate Collection Ultimate Personal Touch Signatures - Food Tyler Toffoli #PTS-TT card
2024-25 Upper Deck Ultimate Collection Ultimate Personal Touch Signatures - Food
$42.42
2023-24 Upper Deck Artifacts Storied Scripts Tyler Toffoli #SS-TT card
2023-24 Upper Deck Artifacts Storied Scripts
$40.00
2021-22 SP Authentic Limited Autograph Material Tyler Toffoli #LAM-TO card
2021-22 SP Authentic Limited Autograph Material
$28.34
2023-24 Upper Deck Artifacts Signs of Success Tyler Toffoli #SOS-TT card
2023-24 Upper Deck Artifacts Signs of Success
$23.42
2025-26 Flair Flair for the Dramatic Autographs Tyler Toffoli #FTD-16 card
2025-26 Flair Flair for the Dramatic Autographs
$17.84
2021-22 Upper Deck The Cup Scripted Swatches Tyler Toffoli #SS-TT card
2021-22 Upper Deck The Cup Scripted Swatches
$16.55
2022-23 Upper Deck Premier Premier Focus Autograph Patch Tyler Toffoli #PFAP-TO card
2022-23 Upper Deck Premier Premier Focus Autograph Patch
$16.27

Top 10 most valuable Tyler Toffoli cards

#CardValue
12022-23 Upper Deck Premier Premier Mega Patch Chest Logos#PMP-LI$82.66
22024-25 Upper Deck Ultimate Collection Ultimate Personal Touch Signatures - Food#PTS-TT$42.42
32023-24 Upper Deck Artifacts Storied Scripts#SS-TT$40.00
42021-22 SP Authentic Limited Autograph Material#LAM-TO$28.34
52023-24 Upper Deck Artifacts Signs of Success#SOS-TT$23.42
62025-26 Flair Flair for the Dramatic Autographs#FTD-16$17.84
72021-22 Upper Deck The Cup Scripted Swatches#SS-TT$16.55
82022-23 Upper Deck Premier Premier Focus Autograph Patch#PFAP-TO$16.27
92023-24 Upper Deck Engrained ElectroCast Metal#EC-49$10.39
102023-24 Upper Deck Engrained ElectroCast Metal Auto#EC-49$10.39

Tyler Toffoli cards by price

Affordable under $2546 cards
$25–$1004 cards

Tyler Toffoli card prices

CardYearValue
2022-23 Upper Deck Premier Premier Mega Patch Chest Logos Tyler Toffoli #PMP-LI card2022-23 Upper Deck Premier Premier Mega Patch Chest Logos#PMP-LI—$82.66
2024-25 Upper Deck Ultimate Collection Ultimate Personal Touch Signatures - Food Tyler Toffoli #PTS-TT card2024-25 Upper Deck Ultimate Collection Ultimate Personal Touch Signatures - Food#PTS-TT—$42.42
2023-24 Upper Deck Artifacts Storied Scripts Tyler Toffoli #SS-TT card2023-24 Upper Deck Artifacts Storied Scripts#SS-TT—$40.00
2021-22 SP Authentic Limited Autograph Material Tyler Toffoli #LAM-TO card2021-22 SP Authentic Limited Autograph Material#LAM-TO—$28.34
2023-24 Upper Deck Artifacts Signs of Success Tyler Toffoli #SOS-TT card2023-24 Upper Deck Artifacts Signs of Success#SOS-TT—$23.42
2025-26 Flair Flair for the Dramatic Autographs Tyler Toffoli #FTD-16 card2025-26 Flair Flair for the Dramatic Autographs#FTD-16—$17.84
2021-22 Upper Deck The Cup Scripted Swatches Tyler Toffoli #SS-TT card2021-22 Upper Deck The Cup Scripted Swatches#SS-TT—$16.55
2022-23 Upper Deck Premier Premier Focus Autograph Patch Tyler Toffoli #PFAP-TO card2022-23 Upper Deck Premier Premier Focus Autograph Patch#PFAP-TO—$16.27
2023-24 Upper Deck Engrained ElectroCast Metal Tyler Toffoli #EC-49 card2023-24 Upper Deck Engrained ElectroCast Metal#EC-49—$10.39
2023-24 Upper Deck Engrained ElectroCast Metal Auto Tyler Toffoli #EC-49 card2023-24 Upper Deck Engrained ElectroCast Metal Auto#EC-49—$10.39
2022-23 Upper Deck Premier Acetate Autograph Patch Tyler Toffoli #AV-TO card2022-23 Upper Deck Premier Acetate Autograph Patch#AV-TO—$8.66
2021-22 Upper Deck The Cup 2020-21 The Cup Update - Stick and Move Gold Foil Autograph Parallel Tyler Toffoli #SM-TT card2021-22 Upper Deck The Cup 2020-21 The Cup Update - Stick and Move Gold Foil Autograph Parallel#SM-TT—$8.50
2022-23 SP Authentic Telemetry Autographs Tyler Toffoli #T-TT card2022-23 SP Authentic Telemetry Autographs#T-TT—$7.69
2021-22 Upper Deck The Cup Foundations Quad Jersey Tyler Toffoli #F-TT card2021-22 Upper Deck The Cup Foundations Quad Jersey#F-TT—$7.15
2021-22 SP Authentic 2001-02 Retro - Autos Tyler Toffoli #01RA-TO card2021-22 SP Authentic 2001-02 Retro - Autos#01RA-TO—$6.99
2021-22 Upper Deck Ultimate Collection 2020 Update - Ultimate Access Jersey Autograph Parallel Tyler Toffoli #UAA-TO card2021-22 Upper Deck Ultimate Collection 2020 Update - Ultimate Access Jersey Autograph Parallel#UAA-TO—$6.52
2023 SP Authentic Evolve · Blue#E-122024$4.91
2024-25 Upper Deck Premier Grand Opus Jersey Tyler Toffoli #GO-TT card2024-25 Upper Deck Premier Grand Opus Jersey#GO-TT—$4.56
2024-25 SP Game Used 2024 Stadium Series Fabrics Tyler Toffoli #GSF-14 card2024-25 SP Game Used 2024 Stadium Series Fabrics#GSF-14—$4.17
2023-24 SPx X Marks the Spot Autos Tyler Toffoli #XM-TT card2023-24 SPx X Marks the Spot Autos#XM-TT—$3.95
2023-24 O-Pee-Chee Platinum Blue Rainbow Autos Tyler Toffoli #BA-TT card2023-24 O-Pee-Chee Platinum Blue Rainbow Autos#BA-TT—$3.56
2022-23 SP Authentic SP Curated Signatures Tyler Toffoli #SPC-TT card2022-23 SP Authentic SP Curated Signatures#SPC-TT—$3.48
2023 SP Authentic Evolve · Green#E-122024$3.40
2021-22 SPx Winning Materials Tyler Toffoli #WM-TT card2021-22 SPx Winning Materials#WM-TT—$3.35
2023-24 Upper Deck Artifacts Aurum Signatures Tyler Toffoli #AS-TT card2023-24 Upper Deck Artifacts Aurum Signatures#AS-TT—$3.34
2021 SP Game Used Authentic Fabrics#AF-TT2021$3.21
2021-22 SP Game Used Authentic Fabrics Tyler Toffoli #AF-TT card2021-22 SP Game Used Authentic Fabrics#AF-TT—$3.21
2023-24 Upper Deck Artifacts Threads of Time Tyler Toffoli #TT-TO card2023-24 Upper Deck Artifacts Threads of Time#TT-TO—$3.17
2022-23 Upper Deck Artifacts Threads of Time Tyler Toffoli #TT-TT card2022-23 Upper Deck Artifacts Threads of Time#TT-TT—$2.99
2025-26 SkyBox Metal Universe Circle Button Tyler Toffoli #CB-18 card2025-26 SkyBox Metal Universe Circle Button#CB-18—$2.99
2023-24 Upper Deck Synergy Cranked Up Tyler Toffoli #CR-TO card2023-24 Upper Deck Synergy Cranked Up#CR-TO—$2.99
2021-22 SP Game Used 2021 NHL Stanley Cup Playoffs Banner Year Relics Tyler Toffoli #BYSC-TT card2021-22 SP Game Used 2021 NHL Stanley Cup Playoffs Banner Year Relics#BYSC-TT—$2.81
2025-26 Upper Deck Credentials Defined Success Tyler Toffoli #DS-26 card2025-26 Upper Deck Credentials Defined Success#DS-26—$2.74
2023-24 Parkhurst Champions Daddy-O Flows Tyler Toffoli #DF-19 card2023-24 Parkhurst Champions Daddy-O Flows#DF-19—$2.65
2025-26 Flair Flair for the Dramatic Tyler Toffoli #FTD-16 card2025-26 Flair Flair for the Dramatic#FTD-16—$2.62
2021 SP Game Used NHL Stanley Cup Playoffs Banner Year Relics#BYSC-TT2021$2.42
2021-22 Upper Deck Synergy Exceptional Stars Tyler Toffoli #ES-TT card2021-22 Upper Deck Synergy Exceptional Stars#ES-TT—$2.24
2021-22 Upper Deck Credentials Base Set Tyler Toffoli #22 card2021-22 Upper Deck Credentials Base Set#22—$1.96
2025-26 SkyBox Metal Universe Lunar Cycle Tyler Toffoli #LC-21 card2025-26 SkyBox Metal Universe Lunar Cycle#LC-21—$1.95
2023-24 Upper Deck Premier Premier Precipice Autograph Tyler Toffoli #PP-TT card2023-24 Upper Deck Premier Premier Precipice Autograph#PP-TT—$1.91
2025-26 SkyBox Metal Universe Championship Galaxy Tyler Toffoli #CG-14 card2025-26 SkyBox Metal Universe Championship Galaxy#CG-14—$1.59
2022-23 SkyBox Metal Universe Metal Ore Tyler Toffoli #MO-15 card2022-23 SkyBox Metal Universe Metal Ore#MO-15—$1.39
2021-22 Upper Deck Artifacts NHL Remnants Tyler Toffoli #NR-TT card2021-22 Upper Deck Artifacts NHL Remnants#NR-TT—$1.13
2023-24 Upper Deck 200' x 85' Tyler Toffoli #DM-42 card2023-24 Upper Deck 200' x 85'#DM-42—$0.99
2025-26 Upper Deck Credentials Bright Cellys Tyler Toffoli #BC-21 card2025-26 Upper Deck Credentials Bright Cellys#BC-21—$0.99
2022 O Pee Chee Tyler Toffoli #9 card2022 O Pee Chee#92022$0.99
2022-23 SP Authentic Pageantry Tyler Toffoli #P-4 card2022-23 SP Authentic Pageantry#P-4—$0.87
2021-22 SkyBox Metal Universe Championship Galaxy Tyler Toffoli #CG-19 card2021-22 SkyBox Metal Universe Championship Galaxy#CG-19—$0.25
2022-23 Upper Deck Credentials 2nd Star of the Night Tyler Toffoli #2S-8 card2022-23 Upper Deck Credentials 2nd Star of the Night#2S-8—$0.25
2018 Upper Deck Artifacts Tyler Toffoli #65 card2018 Upper Deck Artifacts#652018$0.25
2025-26 SP Base Set Tyler Toffoli #14 card2025-26 SP Base Set#14——
2025-26 SkyBox Metal Universe Base Set Tyler Toffoli #95 card2025-26 SkyBox Metal Universe Base Set#95——
2025-26 Tim Hortons Collectors Series Base Set Tyler Toffoli #54 card2025-26 Tim Hortons Collectors Series Base Set#54——
2025-26 SP Game Used Supreme Relics Tyler Toffoli #SP-TT card2025-26 SP Game Used Supreme Relics#SP-TT——
2025-26 SkyBox Metal Universe Outer Limits Tyler Toffoli #OL-34 card2025-26 SkyBox Metal Universe Outer Limits#OL-34——
2025-26 O-Pee-Chee OPC Premier Tyler Toffoli #P-15 card2025-26 O-Pee-Chee OPC Premier#P-15——
2025-26 Upper Deck Sizzle Reel Tyler Toffoli #SR-69 card2025-26 Upper Deck Sizzle Reel#SR-69——
2025-26 Upper Deck O-Pee-Chee Glossy Tyler Toffoli #OG-33 card2025-26 Upper Deck O-Pee-Chee Glossy#OG-33——
2021-22 O-Pee-Chee Base Set Tyler Toffoli #481 card2021-22 O-Pee-Chee Base Set#481——
2020-21 SP Game Used 2020 NHL Stadium Series Game Gear Tyler Toffoli #GGSS-TT card2020-21 SP Game Used 2020 NHL Stadium Series Game Gear#GGSS-TT——

Showing the top 60 of 208 cards. View all Tyler Toffoli card prices (208 cards) →

Tyler Toffoli cards by year

YearCardsTop cardValue
202422023 SP Authentic Evolve #E-12$4.91
202212022 O Pee Chee #9$0.99
202122021 SP Game Used Authentic Fabrics #AF-TT$3.21
201812018 Upper Deck Artifacts #65$0.25

Most popular sets featuring Tyler Toffoli

2023-24 Upper Deck Base Set3 cards2025-26 O-Pee-Chee Base Set3 cards2023 SP Authentic Evolve2 cards$52024-25 O-Pee-Chee Base Set2 cards2025-26 Upper Deck Base Set2 cards2025-26 O-Pee-Chee Platinum Base Set2 cards2022-23 Upper Deck Premier Premier Mega Patch Chest Logos1 card$832024-25 Upper Deck Ultimate Collection Ultimate Personal Touch Signatures - Food1 card$42

Related articles

Most Valuable Tyler Toffoli CardsMost Valuable Connor Mcdavid CardsMost Valuable Cale Makar CardsMost Valuable Auston Matthews CardsMost Valuable Alex Ovechkin CardsMost Valuable Sidney Crosby CardsMost Valuable Connor Bedard Cards

More Hockey players

Connor Mcdavid cardsCale Makar cardsAuston Matthews cardsAlex Ovechkin cardsSidney Crosby cardsConnor Bedard cardsNathan Mackinnon cardsLeon Draisaitl cardsKirill Kaprizov cardsWayne Gretzky cardsMacklin Celebrini cardsMatt Boldy cards

Frequently asked questions

How much more is a PSA 10 Tyler Toffoli card worth?
Across Tyler Toffoli cards we track with both raw and PSA 10 prices, a PSA 10 sells for roughly 14.6× the ungraded price, averaging about $40. Grading pristine copies can pay off — check each card's grade ladder first.

Tyler Toffoli cards live on eBay

Affiliate — we may earn a commission