Tim Rattay card values & price guide

Tim Rattay has 286 cards tracked; the most valuable is the 2004 SP Authentic Tim Rattay Black #74 at $34.99 as of October 22, 2026.

286 cards · 109 sets · 2000–2005

Prices last updated Oct 2026

Cards tracked

286

Highest value

$34.99

Value range

$0–$35

Median value

PSA 10 avg

$31

With recorded sales

113

Most valuable Tim Rattay cards

2000 Upper Deck Graded

$8.99

2000 Playoff Contenders

$7.99

$2004 Topps Chrome Tim Rattay Black Refractor #53 card$

2000 Playoff Contenders

$4.46

$2004 Topps Pristine Tim Rattay Gold Refractor #6 card$

Top 10 by value

#	Card	Value	Shop
1	2004 SP Authentic · Black#74	$34.99	eBay ↗
2	2004 Upper Deck · UD Exclusives Vintage#165	$25.00	eBay ↗
3	2004 Fleer Authentix · Standing Room Only Purple#50	$20.00	eBay ↗
4	2004 Upper Deck Reflections · Blue#84	$17.49	eBay ↗
5	2004 Upper Deck Sweet Spot · Gold#83	$14.34	eBay ↗
6	2000 Collector's Edge Masters · HoloGold#248	$12.00	eBay ↗
7	2004 Upper Deck Ultimate Collection · Platinum#55	$9.99	eBay ↗
8	2002 Upper Deck XL · Holofoil#413	$9.00	eBay ↗
9	2000 Playoff Momentum · O's#184	$9.00	eBay ↗
10	2000 Upper Deck Graded · Autograph#145	$8.99	eBay ↗

Earliest cards (2000)

The earliest Tim Rattay cards in our catalog, ranked by value.

Card	Year	Value
2000 Collector's Edge Masters · HoloGold#248	2000	$12.00
2000 Playoff Momentum · O's#184	2000	$9.00
2000 Upper Deck Graded · Autograph#145	2000	$8.99
2000 Playoff Contenders · Championship Ticket Autograph#146	2000	$7.99
2000 Topps Chrome#231	2000	$6.66
2000 Leaf Certified · 4 Star Mirror Red#216	2000	$5.99
2000 Panini Donruss Elite · Die Cut#166	2000	$4.95
2000 Playoff Contenders · Autograph#146	2000	$4.46

By price

Affordable under $25131 cards

$25–$1002 cards

All prices

Card	Year	Value
2004 SP Authentic · Black#74	2004	$34.99
2004 Upper Deck · UD Exclusives Vintage#165	2004	$25.00
2004 Fleer Authentix · Standing Room Only Purple#50	2004	$20.00
2004 Upper Deck Reflections · Blue#84	2004	$17.49
2004 Upper Deck Sweet Spot · Gold#83	2004	$14.34
2000 Collector's Edge Masters · HoloGold#248	2000	$12.00
2004 Upper Deck Ultimate Collection · Platinum#55	2004	$9.99
2002 Upper Deck XL · Holofoil#413	2002	$9.00
2000 Playoff Momentum · O's#184	2000	$9.00
2000 Upper Deck Graded · Autograph#145	2000	$8.99
2000 Playoff Contenders · Championship Ticket Autograph#146	2000	$7.99
$2004 Topps Chrome Tim Rattay Black Refractor #53 card$ 2004 Topps Chrome · Black Refractor#53	2004	$7.75
2005 Upper Deck Reflections · Black#82	2005	$7.44
2004 Fleer Authentix · Mezzanine Bronze#50	2004	$7.20
2000 Topps Chrome#231	2000	$6.66

Show all 60 cards in this table

2001 Upper Deck Victory · Gold#312	2001	$6.29
2000 Leaf Certified · 4 Star Mirror Red#216	2000	$5.99
2004 Upper Deck Foundations · Exclusive Rainbow Silver#83	2004	$5.40
2004 Leaf Rookies & Stars Longevity · Black#77	2004	$5.14
2004 Upper Deck Ultimate Collection · HoloGold#55	2004	$5.00
2000 Panini Donruss Elite · Die Cut#166	2000	$4.95
2005 Spx · Spectrum#81	2005	$4.85
2003 Upper Deck Finite · Gold#93	2003	$4.85
2004 SP Game Used · Gold#83	2004	$4.79
2000 Playoff Contenders · Autograph#146	2000	$4.46
2005 Upper Deck Ultimate Collection · Gold Holofoil#82	2005	$4.00
2004 Fleer Authentix · General Admission Green#50	2004	$3.99
2004 Fleer Authentix · Club Box Gold#50	2004	$3.69
2004 Fleer Tradition · Crystal#219	2004	$3.41
2004 Upper Deck Ultimate Collection · Gold#55	2004	$3.41
2000 Panini Donruss Elite#166	2000	$3.16
2000 Playoff Momentum · X's#184	2000	$3.00
2005 Upper Deck Reflections · Blue#82	2005	$2.99
2004 Fleer Platinum · Finish#46	2004	$2.99
2004 Upper Deck Diamond Collection All Star Lineup · Silver#53	2004	$2.84
2004 Bazooka · Mini#103	2004	$2.84
$2004 Topps Pristine Tim Rattay Gold Refractor #6 card$ 2004 Topps Pristine · Gold Refractor#6	2004	$2.84
2000 Leaf Limited#385	2000	$2.84
2005 Upper Deck Reflections · Green#82	2005	$2.84
2005 Upper Deck Foundations · Exclusive Gold#82	2005	$2.80
2004 Topps Total · Silver#119	2004	$2.73
2000 Fleer Showcase#134	2000	$2.61
2004 Leaf Rookies & Stars Longevity · Holofoil#77	2004	$2.50
2000 Bowman's Best#142	2000	$2.50
2004 Upper Deck Reflections#84	2004	$2.38
2000 Leaf Limited · Limited Edition#385	2000	$2.34
2005 Upper Deck Reflections · Gold#82	2005	$2.27
2000 Playoff Momentum#184	2000	$2.00
2000 Leaf Certified · 4 Star Die Cut#216	2000	$2.00
2000 Fleer E X#144	2000	$1.99
2004 Topps Chrome#53	2004	$1.98
2000 Upper Deck Pros & Prospects#111	2000	$1.95
$2004 Bowman Chrome Tim Rattay Xfractor #26 card$ 2004 Bowman Chrome · Xfractor#26	2004	$1.95
2004 Bowman Chrome#26	2004	$1.89
2004 Upper Deck#165	2004	$1.85
2004 Topps · Collection#124	2004	$1.85
2004 Bowman's Best · Red#26	2004	$1.80
2004 Bowman · Gold#26	2004	$1.79
2000 Spx#128	2000	$1.70
2004 Topps Total#119	2004	$1.69

Showing the top 60 of 286 cards. View all Tim Rattay card prices (286 cards) →

By year

Year	Cards	Top card	Value
2005	41	2005 Upper Deck Reflections #82	$7.44
2004	95	2004 SP Authentic #74	$34.99
2003	8	2003 Upper Deck Finite #93	$4.85
2002	7	2002 Upper Deck XL #413	$9.00
2001	4	2001 Upper Deck Victory #312	$6.29
2000	131	2000 Collector's Edge Masters #248	$12.00

Live eBay listings

Affiliate — we may earn a commission

Most Valuable Tim Rattay Cards Most Valuable Brett Favre Cards Most Valuable Tom Brady Cards Most Valuable Peyton Manning Cards Most Valuable Latavius Murray Cards Most Valuable Tamba Hali Cards Most Valuable Courtney Hawkins Cards

More Football players

Brett Favre cards Tom Brady cards Peyton Manning cards Latavius Murray cards Tamba Hali cards Courtney Hawkins cards Bryce Paup cards Ted Hendricks cards William Green cards Ryan Finley cards Alexander Mattison cards Eric Stokes cards

Frequently asked questions

How much more is a PSA 10 Tim Rattay card worth?: Across Tim Rattay cards we track with both raw and PSA 10 prices, a PSA 10 sells for roughly 12.1× the ungraded price, averaging about $31. Grading pristine copies can pay off — check each card's grade ladder first.