Ripbin
Scan

Ad disclosure: As an eBay Partner Network affiliate, Ripbin earns from qualifying purchases. Learn more

🔥 Hot buys on eBay

See all →

As an eBay Partner Network affiliate, Ripbin earns from qualifying purchases.

Pat McAfee card values & price guide

Pat McAfee has 77 cards tracked; the most valuable is the 2018 National Treasures Signatures Pat McAfee at $550.00 as of November 15, 2026.

77 cards · 35 sets · 2015–2025

Share

Live eBay listings

As an eBay Partner Network affiliate, Ripbin earns from qualifying purchases.
2023 Panini Select WWE Pat McAfee Zebra #283 card
Card: 2023 Panini Select WWE #283

Pat McAfee career

Teams

Indianapolis Colts

Facts from card checklists and player reference sites

Prices last updated Nov 2026

Cards tracked
77
Highest value
$550.00
Value range
$5–$550
Median value
$60
PSA 10 avg
$270
With recorded sales
41

Most valuable Pat McAfee cards

Top 10 by value

Earliest cards (2015)

The earliest Pat McAfee cards in our catalog, ranked by value.

By price

All prices

CardYearValue
2018 National Treasures Signatures2018$550.00
2023 Panini Select WWE Pat McAfee Zebra #283 card2023 Panini Select WWE · Zebra#2832023$430.00
2023 Panini Select WWE Pat McAfee Gold #283 card2023 Panini Select WWE · Gold#2832023$385.00
2018 Panini Select · Zebra Prizm#2422018$375.00
2019 Panini Certified Mirror Signatures Pat McAfee Gold #MI-PA card2019 Panini Certified Mirror Signatures · Gold#MI-PA2019$350.00
2019 Donruss Elite Elite Signatures Pat McAfee #ES-PC card2019 Donruss Elite Elite Signatures#ES-PC2019$332.00
2019 Panini Donruss Elite Signatures Pat McAfee #ES-PC card2019 Panini Donruss Elite Signatures#ES-PC2019$332.00
2023 Panini Select WWE Pat McAfee Green #283 card2023 Panini Select WWE · Green#2832023$311.25
2019 Panini Certified Mirror Signatures Pat McAfee #MI-PA card2019 Panini Certified Mirror Signatures#MI-PA2019$297.24
2018 Panini Select Pat McAfee Gold Prizm #242 card2018 Panini Select · Gold Prizm#2422018$295.00
2019 Panini Certified Mirror Signatures Pat McAfee Red #MI-PA card2019 Panini Certified Mirror Signatures · Red#MI-PA2019$283.75
2019 Panini Certified Mirror Signatures Pat McAfee Blue #MI-PA card2019 Panini Certified Mirror Signatures · Blue#MI-PA2019$280.00
2019 Panini Absolute Iconic Ink#II-PM2019$260.00
2019 Panini Certified Mirror Signatures Pat McAfee Teal #MI-PA card2019 Panini Certified Mirror Signatures · Teal#MI-PA2019$211.00
2023 Panini Select WWE Pat McAfee Tie-Dye #283 card2023 Panini Select WWE · Tie-Dye#2832023$178.56
Show all 60 cards in this table
2023 Panini Select WWE · Gold Flash#2832023$177.50
2023 Panini Select WWE · Silver Die-Cut#2832023$164.91
2023 Panini Select WWE Pat McAfee Gold Wave #283 card2023 Panini Select WWE · Gold Wave#2832023$110.99
2018 Panini Select · Tie-Dye Prizm#2422018$109.99
2023 Panini Select WWE Pat McAfee Lucky Envelopes #283 card2023 Panini Select WWE · Lucky Envelopes#2832023$108.49
2019 Donruss Elite Dual Threats Pat McAfee Blue #DT-10 card2019 Donruss Elite Dual Threats · Blue#DT-102019$100.00
2018 Panini Select · Red Prizm#2422018$68.25
2018 Panini Select Pat McAfee Tri-Color Prizm #242 card2018 Panini Select · Tri-Color Prizm#2422018$59.80
2023 Panini Select WWE Pat McAfee Silver #283 card2023 Panini Select WWE · Silver#2832023$58.09
2015 Topps · Pink#2822015$50.00
2019 Panini Donruss Elite Dual Threats Pat McAfee Orange #DT-10 card2019 Panini Donruss Elite Dual Threats · Orange#DT-102019$44.67
2023 Panini Select WWE Pat McAfee Orange Flash #283 card2023 Panini Select WWE · Orange Flash#2832023$39.99
2019 Panini Gold Standard Base Set · Rose Gold#1202019$35.00
2015 Topps · Gold Border#2822015$29.99
2019 Panini Gold Standard Base Set#1202019$28.75
2018 Panini Select · Silver Prizm#2422018$28.00
2019 Donruss Elite Dual Threats Pat McAfee Purple #DT-10 card2019 Donruss Elite Dual Threats · Purple#DT-102019$27.97
2018 Panini Select · Copper Prizm#2422018$27.86
2019 Panini Gold Standard Base Set · Platinum#1202019$25.99
2019 Donruss Elite Dual Threats Pat McAfee Red #DT-10 card2019 Donruss Elite Dual Threats · Red#DT-102019$24.99
2023 Panini Select WWE Pat McAfee Red Wave #283 card2023 Panini Select WWE · Red Wave#2832023$18.59
2022 Panini Instant WWE#602022$15.00
2018 Panini Select Pat McAfee #242 card2018 Panini Select#2422018$12.55
2019 Donruss Elite Dual Threats Pat McAfee #DT-10 card2019 Donruss Elite Dual Threats#DT-102019$8.90
2023 Panini Select WWE Pat McAfee #283 card2023 Panini Select WWE#2832023$8.80
2019 Donruss Elite Dual Threats Pat McAfee Green #DT-10 card2019 Donruss Elite Dual Threats · Green#DT-102019$8.50
2015 Topps Pat McAfee #282 card2015 Topps#2822015$7.50
2019 Donruss Elite Dual Threats Pat McAfee Pink #DT-10 card2019 Donruss Elite Dual Threats · Pink#DT-102019$7.25
2025 Topps Now WWE Pat McAfee #51 card2025 Topps Now WWE#512025$4.99
2023 Panini Select WWE Pat McAfee Red Blue #283 card2023 Panini Select WWE · Red Blue#2832023$4.98
2023 Panini Select WWE · Mojo#2832023—
2019 Panini Immaculate Collection Nameplate Nobility#NN-PM2019—
2019 Score Signatures#SI-PM2019—
2019 Panini Plates & Patches 2018 Panini Select Printing Plates#2422019—
2019 Panini Plates & Patches 2019 Panini Gold Standard Printing Plates#1202019—
2019 Panini Plates & Patches Base Set#1192019—
2019 Panini Immaculate Collection Immaculate Numbers Memorabilia#IN-672019—
2019 Donruss Signature Marks#SM-252019—
2019 Panini Majestic Upper Tier Signatures#UT-PM2019—
2019 Donruss Legends of the Fall#LF-42019—
2019 Panini Gold Standard Bullion Brand Tags Signatures#BBTS-172019—
2019 Panini Luminance Spotlight Signatures#SS-PMA2019—
2018 Panini Select Base Set#2422018—
2018 Panini National Treasures Signatures#S-PM2018—
2018 Panini Obsidian Aurora Autographs#AA-PM2018—

Showing the top 60 of 77 cards. View all Pat McAfee card prices (77 cards) →

By year

YearCardsTop cardValue
202512025 Topps Now WWE #51$4.99
2023162023 Panini Select WWE #283$430.00
202272022 Panini Instant WWE #60$15.00
2019312019 Panini Certified Mirror Signatures #MI-PA$350.00
2018142018 National Treasures Signatures$550.00
20173——
20162——
201532015 Topps #282$50.00

Popular sets

Related articles

More Football players

Frequently asked questions

How much more is a PSA 10 Pat McAfee card worth?
Across Pat McAfee cards we track with both raw and PSA 10 prices, a PSA 10 sells for roughly 5.5× the ungraded price, averaging about $270. Grading pristine copies can pay off — check each card's grade ladder first.