Matthew Schaefer card values & price guide
26 cards · 15 sets · 2025–2026
Looking up Matthew Schaefer card values? Ripbin tracks 26 of them across 15 sets — worth from $3.34 for common issues up to $2,539.80 for the top card — each with current prices and live listings.
The most valuable Matthew Schaefer card we track is the 2026 2025 Upper Deck Series 2 Population Count Matthew Schaefer #PC-37, currently around $2,539.80 ungraded — graded copies sell for more.
Most valuable Matthew Schaefer cards
Matthew Schaefer card prices
Matthew Schaefer card market
Matthew Schaefer cards in our catalog span 2025 to 2026 — earlier issues generally carry the collector premium, while recent releases trade closer to pack-fresh prices.
The values shown are for raw (ungraded) copies. Each card's page breaks out graded values — PSA 9, PSA 10, BGS 10 and more — alongside live eBay listings.
Matthew Schaefer rookie card
Searching for the Matthew Schaefer rookie card? The earliest Matthew Schaefer cards in our catalog are from 2025, led by the 2025 Upper Deck Black Diamond Rookie Team Logo Jumbo Puzzle Patch Matthew Schaefer #RTL-MS at around $216.39 ungraded. Rookie and early-year cards are typically a player's most collected issues, and graded copies carry the largest premiums.
Matthew Schaefer cards at every budget
There's a Matthew Schaefer card for every budget: 1 cards under $10.00 — ideal entry points, 14 in the $10.00–$100.00 range and 9 premium cards above $100.00. Newer collectors typically begin with affordable base versions; the premium tier is dominated by graded early-year cards and short-printed parallels.
Matthew Schaefer cards by year
| Year | Cards | Top card | Value |
|---|---|---|---|
| 2026 | 23 | 2025 Upper Deck Series 2 Population Count #PC-37 | $2,539.80 |
| 2025 | 3 | 2025 Upper Deck Black Diamond Rookie Team Logo Jumbo Puzzle Patch #RTL-MS | $216.39 |
Sets featuring Matthew Schaefer
Frequently asked questions
- What is the most valuable Matthew Schaefer card?
- The 2026 2025 Upper Deck Series 2 Population Count Matthew Schaefer #PC-37 is the most valuable Matthew Schaefer card we track, at around $2,539.80 ungraded.
- What is the Matthew Schaefer rookie card worth?
- Matthew Schaefer's earliest cards in our catalog are from 2025; the top one — the 2025 Upper Deck Black Diamond Rookie Team Logo Jumbo Puzzle Patch Matthew Schaefer #RTL-MS — is worth around $216.39 ungraded, with graded copies selling for more. Check the price table for every early-year card.
- How many Matthew Schaefer cards are there?
- Ripbin tracks 26 Matthew Schaefer cards across 15 sets. New cards are added as sets release.
- What is the cheapest Matthew Schaefer card?
- Matthew Schaefer cards start around $3.34 for common base issues — an affordable way to start a collection before moving up to graded or early-year cards.
- How do I sell my Matthew Schaefer cards?
- Compare your card against the price table above, check its live eBay listings for the current market, and scan it with Ripbin to track it in your locker and receive bids from other collectors.
- Are Matthew Schaefer cards a good investment?
- Card values move with player performance and hobby demand, condition and grading population. Use the price table to compare values, and check each card's live listings before buying or selling.