Ripbin
Scan

Ad disclosure: As an eBay Partner Network affiliate, Ripbin earns from qualifying purchases. Learn more

🔥 Hot buys on eBay

See all →

As an eBay Partner Network affiliate, Ripbin earns from qualifying purchases.

Matthew Schaefer card values & price guide

Matthew Schaefer has 300 cards tracked; the most valuable is the 2025 Upper Deck Extended Series Acetate Young Guns Matthew Schaefer Outburst Red #451 at $7,800.00 as of November 15, 2026.

300 cards · 125 sets · 2024–2026

Share

Live eBay listings

As an eBay Partner Network affiliate, Ripbin earns from qualifying purchases.
2025 Upper Deck Extended Series Acetate Young Guns Matthew Schaefer Outburst Red #451 card
Card: 2025 Upper Deck Extended Series Acetate Young Guns #451

Matthew Schaefer career

Teams

New York Islanders

Facts from card checklists and player reference sites

Prices last updated Nov 2026

Cards tracked
300
Highest value
$7,800.00
Value range
$42–$7,800
Median value
$216
PSA 10 avg
$1,842
With recorded sales
265

Most valuable Matthew Schaefer cards

Top 7, ranked by market value

Updated Sep 2026 · Ripbin price data · ranked by PSA 10 median, then raw, weighted by listings seen

The most valuable Matthew Schaefer card by PSA 10 median is the 2026 Upper Deck Series 2 #451 Clear Cut, about $7,209 in PSA 10 and $2,200 raw as of Sep 2026. The entry point to the list is the 2026 Upper Deck Series 2 #451 Deluxe at about $930 raw.

  1. #1
    2026 Upper Deck Series 2 #451 Clear Cut
    PSA 10
    $7,209
    Raw
    $2,200
    PSA 9
    —
    BGS 9.5
    —
    based on 2 listings
    History builds monthly · first point Sep $2,200
    Shop on eBay →
  2. #2
    2026 Upper Deck Series 2 #451 Deluxe
    PSA 10
    —
    Raw
    $930
    PSA 9
    —
    BGS 9.5
    —
    based on 3 listings
    History builds monthly · first point Sep $930
    Shop on eBay →
  3. #3
    2026 Upper Deck Extended Series UD Canvas #C-365 Black White
    PSA 10
    —
    Raw
    $1,325
    PSA 9
    —
    BGS 9.5
    —
    based on 2 listings
    History builds monthly · first point Sep $1,325
    Shop on eBay →
  4. #4
    2026 Upper Deck Series 2 #499 High Gloss
    PSA 10
    —
    Raw
    $2,500
    PSA 9
    —
    BGS 9.5
    —
    based on 1 listing
    History builds monthly · first point Sep $2,500
    Shop on eBay →
  5. #5
    PSA 10
    —
    Raw
    $1,800
    PSA 9
    —
    BGS 9.5
    —
    based on 1 listing
    History builds monthly · first point Sep $1,800
    Shop on eBay →
  6. #6
    2026 SP Authentic #168
    PSA 10
    —
    Raw
    $1,374
    PSA 9
    —
    BGS 9.5
    —
    no live listings
    History builds monthly · first point Sep $1,374
    Shop on eBay →
  7. #7
    2026 SP Game Used Draft Day Marks #DDM-MS
    PSA 10
    —
    Raw
    $1,184
    PSA 9
    —
    BGS 9.5
    —
    no live listings
    History builds monthly · first point Sep $1,184
    Shop on eBay →

How this list was built. Ripbin tracks every Matthew Schaefer card in our catalog and this list is the 7 key cards ranked by our market data: the PSA 10 median asking price on eBay first, then raw, weighted by the number of listings seen. Raw, PSA 10, PSA 9 and BGS 9.5 figures are medians of current eBay asking prices for that exact card and parallel, refreshed daily; the charts are our monthly medians. Prices move — treat them as a guide, and check the exact card number and serial number before you pay a premium.

Earliest cards (2023)

The earliest Matthew Schaefer cards in our catalog, ranked by value.

By price

Price movers

Biggest 90-day price changes among tracked cards.

All prices

CardYearValue
2025 Upper Deck Extended Series Acetate Young Guns Matthew Schaefer Outburst Red #451 card2025 Upper Deck Extended Series Acetate Young Guns · Outburst Red#4512026$7,800.00
2025-26 O-Pee-Chee Platinum Rookie Autographs Matthew Schaefer Emerald Surge #R-MS card2025-26 O-Pee-Chee Platinum Rookie Autographs · Emerald Surge#R-MS2026$7,374.00
2025 SP Authentic Matthew Schaefer Limited Auto Material Vertical Patch #168 card2025 SP Authentic · Limited Auto Material Vertical Patch#1682026$6,455.63
2025-26 O-Pee-Chee Platinum Rookie Autographs Matthew Schaefer Orange Checkers #R-MS card2025-26 O-Pee-Chee Platinum Rookie Autographs · Orange Checkers#R-MS2026$5,900.00
2025-26 Upper Deck Star Rookies Base Star Rookies Autographs Matthew Schaefer Blue Autograph #5 card2025-26 Upper Deck Star Rookies Base Star Rookies Autographs · Blue Autograph#52026$4,523.80
2025 SP Authentic Matthew Schaefer Inscribed Autograph #168 card2025 SP Authentic · Inscribed Autograph#1682026$3,298.36
2025 Upper Deck Premier Acetate Rookie Patch Auto Matthew Schaefer #AR-MS card2025 Upper Deck Premier Acetate Rookie Patch Auto#AR-MS2026$3,190.48
2025-26 O-Pee-Chee Platinum Rookie Autographs · Red Prism#R-MS2026$3,150.00
2025 Upper Deck Premier Acetate Rookie Patch Auto Matthew Schaefer Gold #AR-MS card2025 Upper Deck Premier Acetate Rookie Patch Auto · Gold#AR-MS2026$2,953.04
2025 Upper Deck Extended Series Acetate Young Guns Matthew Schaefer #451 card2025 Upper Deck Extended Series Acetate Young Guns#4512026$2,572.35
2025 Upper Deck Series 2 Population Count · 10#PC-372026$2,539.80
2025 Upper Deck Extended Series UD Debut Game Jersey Autograph#DGJA-MS2026$2,350.00
2025-26 Upper Deck UD Debut Game Jersey Auto Matthew Schaefer #DGJA-MS card2025-26 Upper Deck UD Debut Game Jersey Auto#DGJA-MS—$2,350.00
2025-26 Upper Deck Black Diamond Base Diamond Relic Rookies · Pure Black Triple#BDR-MS2025$2,051.52
2025-26 Upper Deck Black Diamond Rookie Gems Signatures · Green#RGS-MS2025$1,975.00
Show all 60 cards in this table
2025 Upper Deck Ice Signature Swatches Jersey Matthew Schaefer Patch #SS-MS card2025 Upper Deck Ice Signature Swatches Jersey · Patch#SS-MS2026$1,800.00
2025-26 Upper Deck Black Diamond Rookie Gems Signatures Matthew Schaefer Red #RGS-MS card2025-26 Upper Deck Black Diamond Rookie Gems Signatures · Red#RGS-MS2025$1,699.48
2025 Parkhurst Matthew Schaefer Auto Patch #211 card2025 Parkhurst · Auto Patch#2112026$1,600.00
2025-26 O-Pee-Chee Platinum Base Set Matthew Schaefer Orange Checkers #268 card2025-26 O-Pee-Chee Platinum Base Set · Orange Checkers#2682026$1,585.82
2025 Upper Deck Ice Signature Swatches Jersey Matthew Schaefer #SS-MS card2025 Upper Deck Ice Signature Swatches Jersey#SS-MS2026$1,525.01
2025-26 O-Pee-Chee Platinum Rookie Autographs Matthew Schaefer Blue Fragments #R-MS card2025-26 O-Pee-Chee Platinum Rookie Autographs · Blue Fragments#R-MS2026$1,510.64
2025-26 O-Pee-Chee Platinum Rookie Autographs Matthew Schaefer Violet Pixels #R-MS card2025-26 O-Pee-Chee Platinum Rookie Autographs · Violet Pixels#R-MS2026$1,510.00
2025-26 O-Pee-Chee Platinum Rookie Autographs Matthew Schaefer Cosmic #R-MS card2025-26 O-Pee-Chee Platinum Rookie Autographs · Cosmic#R-MS2026$1,455.79
2025 SP Authentic Matthew Schaefer #168 card2025 SP Authentic#1682026$1,362.20
2025-26 Upper Deck Star Rookies Base Star Rookies Autographs Matthew Schaefer Green #5 card2025-26 Upper Deck Star Rookies Base Star Rookies Autographs · Green#52026$1,329.31
2025-26 SP Game Used Draft Day Marks Matthew Schaefer #DDM-MS card2025-26 SP Game Used Draft Day Marks#DDM-MS—$1,284.16
2025 Upper Deck Extended Series Acetate Young Guns Matthew Schaefer Exclusives #451 card2025 Upper Deck Extended Series Acetate Young Guns · Exclusives#4512026$1,264.18
2025 Upper Deck Clear Cut Stars in the Making Autograph Matthew Schaefer Red #SMA-MS card2025 Upper Deck Clear Cut Stars in the Making Autograph · Red#SMA-MS2026$1,237.99
2025 Upper Deck Series 2 Fluorescence Matthew Schaefer Magenta #F-26 card2025 Upper Deck Series 2 Fluorescence · Magenta#F-262026$1,175.76
2025-26 Upper Deck Allure Base Extended Rookies · Purple Diamond Extended Rookie#AR-MS2026$1,171.09
2025 Upper Deck Splendor Black & White Borderless Auto#BWBL-MS2026$1,084.26
2025 Upper Deck Extended Series Acetate Young Guns Matthew Schaefer Clear Cut #451 card2025 Upper Deck Extended Series Acetate Young Guns · Clear Cut#4512026$1,041.30
2025-26 SP Base Set · Gold Signature#1112026$1,037.50
2025-26 O-Pee-Chee Platinum Base Set Matthew Schaefer Seismic Gold #268 card2025-26 O-Pee-Chee Platinum Base Set · Seismic Gold#2682026$1,035.00
2024 Upper Deck Team Canada Juniors · Outburst Gold#692024$1,009.99
2025 SP Authentic · Acetate#1682026$988.41
2025-26 O-Pee-Chee Platinum Rookie Autographs Matthew Schaefer Sunset #R-MS card2025-26 O-Pee-Chee Platinum Rookie Autographs · Sunset#R-MS2026$965.29
2025-26 Upper Deck Credentials Debut Ticket Access Autographs#DTA-MS—$883.77
2025 Upper Deck Ultimate Collection Introductions Auto · Gold#UI-MS2026$869.69
2025 Upper Deck Artifacts Autograph Rookie Redemption Matthew Schaefer #I card2025 Upper Deck Artifacts Autograph Rookie Redemption#I2026$846.86
2025 Upper Deck Extended Series Acetate Young Guns Matthew Schaefer Deluxe #451 card2025 Upper Deck Extended Series Acetate Young Guns · Deluxe#4512026$831.69
2025-26 Upper Deck Black Diamond Base Set · Autograph#BDB-MS2025$818.42
2025 Upper Deck Ultimate Collection Phenoms Autograph Matthew Schaefer Gold #UP-MS card2025 Upper Deck Ultimate Collection Phenoms Autograph · Gold#UP-MS2026$811.23
2025-26 SP Game Used Inked Rookie Sweaters · Patch#IRS-MS2026$787.99
2025 SP Authentic Matthew Schaefer Horizontal Autograph #168 card2025 SP Authentic · Horizontal Autograph#1682026$773.32
2025 Upper Deck Allure · Extended Rookie Blue Line Autograph#AR-MS2026$750.00
2025 Upper Deck Extended Series Acetate Young Guns Matthew Schaefer Outburst Silver #451 card2025 Upper Deck Extended Series Acetate Young Guns · Outburst Silver#4512026$722.60
2025-26 O-Pee-Chee Platinum Rookie Autographs Matthew Schaefer Rainbow #R-MS card2025-26 O-Pee-Chee Platinum Rookie Autographs · Rainbow#R-MS2026$700.15
2025-26 SkyBox Metal Universe Base Set · Blue#1132026$700.00
2024 Upper Deck Team Canada Juniors · Autograph Patch#852024$700.00
2026 Upper Deck NSCC Hot Prospect Autograph Matthew Schaefer Red #HPA-MS card2026 Upper Deck NSCC Hot Prospect Autograph · Red#HPA-MS2026$687.50
2025 Upper Deck Premier · Shoulder Number#1092026$685.00
2025 Upper Deck Ice Premieres Autograph Matthew Schaefer Gold #IPA-MS card2025 Upper Deck Ice Premieres Autograph · Gold#IPA-MS2026$685.00
2025 Upper Deck Series 2 Incarnations Matthew Schaefer #INC-5 card2025 Upper Deck Series 2 Incarnations#INC-52025$684.50
2025-26 SPx Blue Autograph Parallel - Rookies · Gold#F-MS2026$681.92
2025-26 Fleer Ultra Base Set · Red Rainbow Foil Auto#1642026$651.07
2025-26 Fleer Ultra Ultra Future Stars Matthew Schaefer Green #FST-8 card2025-26 Fleer Ultra Ultra Future Stars · Green#FST-82026$630.55
2025 Upper Deck Extended Series UD Debut Game Jersey#DGJ-MS2026$620.00
2025-26 Upper Deck UD Debut Game Jersey Matthew Schaefer #DGJ-MS card2025-26 Upper Deck UD Debut Game Jersey#DGJ-MS—$620.00
2025-26 SP Base Set · Signature#1112026$614.85

Showing the top 60 of 300 cards. View all Matthew Schaefer card prices (300 cards) →

By year

Popular sets

Related articles

More Hockey players

Frequently asked questions

How much more is a PSA 10 Matthew Schaefer card worth?
Across Matthew Schaefer cards we track with both raw and PSA 10 prices, a PSA 10 sells for roughly 4.6× the ungraded price, averaging about $1,842. Grading pristine copies can pay off — check each card's grade ladder first.