Ripbin
Scan

JJ McCarthy card values & price guide

JJ McCarthy has 300 cards tracked; the most valuable is the 2023 Bowman Chrome University 1955 JJ McCarthy Superfractor #55BF-19 at $2,999.00 as of October 23, 2026.

300 cards · 34 sets · 2021–2025

Share

Prices last updated Oct 2026

Cards tracked
300
Highest value
$2,999.00
Value range
$1–$2,999
Median value
$28
PSA 10 avg
$203
With recorded sales
178

Most valuable JJ McCarthy cards

2023 Bowman Chrome University 1955 JJ McCarthy Superfractor #55BF-19 card
2023 Bowman Chrome University 1955
$2,999.00
2023 Bowman Chrome University The Big Kahuna JJ McCarthy Superfractor #TBK-3 card
2023 Bowman Chrome University The Big Kahuna
$1,850.00
2024 Panini Luminance Year One Signatures RPS JJ McCarthy Purple #YOS-JMY card
2024 Panini Luminance Year One Signatures RPS
$1,000.00
2021 Bowman University Chrome Autographs JJ McCarthy Red Refractor #BCPA-JM card
2021 Bowman University Chrome Autographs
$667.69
2024 Panini Donruss Rated Rookies Retro JJ McCarthy Blue Ice #10 card
2024 Panini Donruss Rated Rookies Retro
$514.89
2021 Bowman University Chrome Autographs JJ McCarthy Gold Lava Refractor #BCPA-JM card
2021 Bowman University Chrome Autographs
$334.32
2023 Bowman Chrome University Future of Autographs JJ McCarthy Orange #FOFA-JMC card
2023 Bowman Chrome University Future of Autographs
$299.99
2022 Bowman's Best University Fight Song JJ McCarthy Autograph #FS-16 card
2022 Bowman's Best University Fight Song
$266.74

Top 10 by value

#CardValueShop
12023 Bowman Chrome University 1955 · Superfractor#55BF-19$2,999.00eBay ↗
22023 Bowman Chrome University The Big Kahuna · Superfractor#TBK-3$1,850.00eBay ↗
32024 Panini Luminance Year One Signatures RPS · Purple#YOS-JMY$1,000.00eBay ↗
42021 Bowman University Chrome Autographs · Red Refractor#BCPA-JM$667.69eBay ↗
52024 Panini Donruss Rated Rookies Retro · Blue Ice#10$514.89eBay ↗
62021 Bowman University Chrome Autographs · Gold Lava Refractor#BCPA-JM$334.32eBay ↗
72023 Bowman Chrome University Future of Autographs · Orange#FOFA-JMC$299.99eBay ↗
82022 Bowman Chrome University · Autograph Orange#48$284.02eBay ↗
92022 Bowman's Best University Fight Song · Autograph#FS-16$266.74eBay ↗
102023 Bowman's Best University Autographs · Orange#BOA-JJM$265.00eBay ↗

Earliest cards (2021)

The earliest JJ McCarthy cards in our catalog, ranked by value.

CardYearValue
2021 Bowman University Chrome Autographs · Red Refractor#BCPA-JM2021$667.69
2021 Bowman University Chrome Autographs · Gold Lava Refractor#BCPA-JM2021$334.32
2021 Bowman University Chrome Autographs · Orange Shimmer Refractor#BCPA-JM2021$250.50
2021 Bowman University Chrome Autographs · Green Refractor#BCPA-JM2021$235.00
2021 Bowman University · Red#392021$228.77
2021 Bowman University Chrome Autographs · Gold Refractor#BCPA-JM2021$206.63
2021 Bowman University Chrome Autographs · Orange Refractor#BCPA-JM2021$197.99
2021 Bowman University · Green#792021$136.50

By price

Affordable under $2576 cards
$25–$10039 cards
Grails ($500+)5 cards

All prices

CardYearValue
2023 Bowman Chrome University 1955 JJ McCarthy Superfractor #55BF-19 card2023 Bowman Chrome University 1955 · Superfractor#55BF-192023$2,999.00
2023 Bowman Chrome University The Big Kahuna JJ McCarthy Superfractor #TBK-3 card2023 Bowman Chrome University The Big Kahuna · Superfractor#TBK-32023$1,850.00
2024 Panini Luminance Year One Signatures RPS JJ McCarthy Purple #YOS-JMY card2024 Panini Luminance Year One Signatures RPS · Purple#YOS-JMY2024$1,000.00
2021 Bowman University Chrome Autographs JJ McCarthy Red Refractor #BCPA-JM card2021 Bowman University Chrome Autographs · Red Refractor#BCPA-JM2021$667.69
2024 Panini Donruss Rated Rookies Retro JJ McCarthy Blue Ice #10 card2024 Panini Donruss Rated Rookies Retro · Blue Ice#102024$514.89
2021 Bowman University Chrome Autographs JJ McCarthy Gold Lava Refractor #BCPA-JM card2021 Bowman University Chrome Autographs · Gold Lava Refractor#BCPA-JM2021$334.32
2023 Bowman Chrome University Future of Autographs JJ McCarthy Orange #FOFA-JMC card2023 Bowman Chrome University Future of Autographs · Orange#FOFA-JMC2023$299.99
2022 Bowman Chrome University · Autograph Orange#482022$284.02
2022 Bowman's Best University Fight Song JJ McCarthy Autograph #FS-16 card2022 Bowman's Best University Fight Song · Autograph#FS-162022$266.74
2023 Bowman's Best University Autographs JJ McCarthy Orange #BOA-JJM card2023 Bowman's Best University Autographs · Orange#BOA-JJM2023$265.00
2021 Bowman University Chrome Autographs JJ McCarthy Orange Shimmer Refractor #BCPA-JM card2021 Bowman University Chrome Autographs · Orange Shimmer Refractor#BCPA-JM2021$250.50
2022 Bowman Chrome University · Autograph Gold#482022$250.00
2023 Bowman Chrome University 1955 Autographs JJ McCarthy Gold #55B-JM card2023 Bowman Chrome University 1955 Autographs · Gold#55B-JM2023$245.63
2021 Bowman University Chrome Autographs JJ McCarthy Green Refractor #BCPA-JM card2021 Bowman University Chrome Autographs · Green Refractor#BCPA-JM2021$235.00
2022 Bowman Chrome University · Autograph Gold Lava#482022$231.25
Show all 60 cards in this table
2021 Bowman University · Red#392021$228.77
2022 Bowman Chrome University · Red Shimmer#482022$210.61
2023 Bowman Chrome University Sapphire Selections Autographs JJ McCarthy #SG-JJ card2023 Bowman Chrome University Sapphire Selections Autographs#SG-JJ2023$208.53
2021 Bowman University Chrome Autographs JJ McCarthy Gold Refractor #BCPA-JM card2021 Bowman University Chrome Autographs · Gold Refractor#BCPA-JM2021$206.63
2023 Bowman Chrome University Sapphire Selections Autographs JJ McCarthy Orange #SG-JJ card2023 Bowman Chrome University Sapphire Selections Autographs · Orange#SG-JJ2023$206.58
2023 Bowman Chrome University Future of Autographs JJ McCarthy #FOFA-JMC card2023 Bowman Chrome University Future of Autographs#FOFA-JMC2023$200.00
2023 Bowman Chrome University Sapphire Selections JJ McCarthy Purple #SS-8 card2023 Bowman Chrome University Sapphire Selections · Purple#SS-82023$199.00
2021 Bowman University Chrome Autographs · Orange Refractor#BCPA-JM2021$197.99
2023 Bowman Chrome University 1955 Autographs JJ McCarthy #55B-JM card2023 Bowman Chrome University 1955 Autographs#55B-JM2023$179.99
2023 Bowman Chrome University The Big Kahuna JJ McCarthy Autograph #TBK-3 card2023 Bowman Chrome University The Big Kahuna · Autograph#TBK-32023$179.01
2022 Bowman Chrome University JJ McCarthy Autograph Orange Shimmer #48 card2022 Bowman Chrome University · Autograph Orange Shimmer#482022$177.46
2023 Bowman's Best University Autographs JJ McCarthy Gold Geometric #BOA-JJM card2023 Bowman's Best University Autographs · Gold Geometric#BOA-JJM2023$167.50
2022 Bowman Chrome University · Autograph Yellow#482022$161.32
2022 Bowman's Best University · Red Lava#482022$155.50
2023 Bowman Chrome University The Big Kahuna JJ McCarthy Orange #TBK-3 card2023 Bowman Chrome University The Big Kahuna · Orange#TBK-32023$155.00
2023 Bowman's Best University Autographs · Gold#BOA-JJM2023$150.00
2023 Bowman's Best University · White Geometric#62023$149.99
2021 Bowman University · Green#792021$136.50
2021 Bowman University · Orange Shimmer#392021$135.66
2023 Bowman's Best University Autographs JJ McCarthy Orange Geometric #BOA-JJM card2023 Bowman's Best University Autographs · Orange Geometric#BOA-JJM2023$122.56
2021 Bowman University Chrome Autographs JJ McCarthy Yellow Refractor #BCPA-JM card2021 Bowman University Chrome Autographs · Yellow Refractor#BCPA-JM2021$120.00
2023 Bowman's Best University Prospect Jumbo Relic Autographs JJ McCarthy #JRA-JM card2023 Bowman's Best University Prospect Jumbo Relic Autographs#JRA-JM2023$119.94
2022 Bowman's Best University Fight Song JJ McCarthy Orange #FS-16 card2022 Bowman's Best University Fight Song · Orange#FS-162022$118.68
2024 Panini Luminance Year One Signatures RPS JJ McCarthy Green #YOS-JMY card2024 Panini Luminance Year One Signatures RPS · Green#YOS-JMY2024$112.05
2023 Bowman Chrome University Sapphire Prospect Autographs#PA-JJM2023$109.50
2022 Bowman Chrome University · Autograph Lava#482022$109.29
2023 Bowman's Best University Masterpieces Autographs JJ McCarthy #BMA-JM card2023 Bowman's Best University Masterpieces Autographs#BMA-JM2023$102.46
2023 Bowman's Best University · Red Geometric#62023$100.00
2021 Bowman University Chrome Autographs JJ McCarthy Lava Refractor #BCPA-JM card2021 Bowman University Chrome Autographs · Lava Refractor#BCPA-JM2021$99.13
2022 Bowman Chrome University · Autograph Green#482022$99.00
2022 Bowman Chrome University · Autograph Refractor#482022$98.08
2021 Bowman University · Gold#392021$95.00
2021 Bowman University · Red Shimmer#792021$94.91
2021 Bowman University · Gold Shimmer#392021$86.50
2023 Bowman's Best University Autographs#BOA-JJM2023$79.99
2023 Bowman Chrome University 1955 JJ McCarthy Orange #55BF-19 card2023 Bowman Chrome University 1955 · Orange#55BF-192023$75.00
2023 Bowman Chrome University Sapphire Selections JJ McCarthy Orange #SS-8 card2023 Bowman Chrome University Sapphire Selections · Orange#SS-82023$72.00
2023 Bowman's Best University · Orange Geometric#62023$59.13
2021 Bowman University Chrome Autographs JJ McCarthy #BCPA-JM card2021 Bowman University Chrome Autographs#BCPA-JM2021$54.75
2022 Bowman's Best University · Orange#482022$54.00
2022 Bowman Chrome University · Gold#482022$53.47
2021 Bowman University · Gold Shimmer#792021$52.89
2023 Bowman's Best University Gunslingers and Bandits Die Cuts JJ McCarthy Gold #GSB-5 card2023 Bowman's Best University Gunslingers and Bandits Die Cuts · Gold#GSB-52023$52.79
2022 Bowman Chrome University · Autograph#482022$51.00
2024 Panini Luminance Year One Signatures RPS JJ McCarthy Red #YOS-JMY card2024 Panini Luminance Year One Signatures RPS · Red#YOS-JMY2024$50.93

Showing the top 60 of 300 cards. View all JJ McCarthy card prices (300 cards) →

By year

YearCardsTop cardValue
202532025 Panini Instant #194$9.96
20241262024 Panini Luminance Year One Signatures RPS #YOS-JMY$1,000.00
2023802023 Bowman Chrome University 1955 #55BF-19$2,999.00
2022522022 Bowman Chrome University #48$284.02
2021392021 Bowman University Chrome Autographs #BCPA-JM$667.69

Popular sets

2024 Wild Card 7 Card Studs AutoClubsChalkShatter120 cards2022 Bowman Chrome University32 cards$2842021 Bowman University30 cards$2292023 Bowman Chrome University20 cards2022 Bowman's Best University15 cards$1562023 Bowman's Best University13 cards$1502021 Bowman University Chrome Autographs9 cards$6682022 Bowman University Inception6 cards$13

Live eBay listings

Affiliate — we may earn a commission

Related articles

Most Valuable JJ McCarthy CardsMost Valuable Patrick Mahomes Ii CardsMost Valuable Josh Allen CardsMost Valuable Tom Brady CardsMost Valuable Isaiah Davis CardsMost Valuable Jordyn Tyson CardsMost Valuable Micah Hyde Cards

More Football players

Patrick Mahomes Ii cardsJosh Allen cardsTom Brady cardsIsaiah Davis cardsJordyn Tyson cardsMicah Hyde cardsJoe Tryon Shoyinka cardsJustin Blackmon cardsMatt Milano cardsWillie Mcginest cardsJessie Armstead cardsEric Gray cards

Frequently asked questions

How much more is a PSA 10 JJ McCarthy card worth?
Across JJ McCarthy cards we track with both raw and PSA 10 prices, a PSA 10 sells for roughly 5.0× the ungraded price, averaging about $203. Grading pristine copies can pay off — check each card's grade ladder first.