Ripbin
Scan

Ad disclosure: As an eBay Partner Network affiliate, Ripbin earns from qualifying purchases. Learn more

🔥 Hot buys on eBay

See all →

As an eBay Partner Network affiliate, Ripbin earns from qualifying purchases.

Indianapolis Colts card values & price guide

Indianapolis Colts has 94 cards tracked; the most valuable is the 2022 Score Squad Indianapolis Colts End Zone #S6 at $35.00 as of November 15, 2026.

94 cards · 33 sets · 1984–2026

Share

Live eBay listings

As an eBay Partner Network affiliate, Ripbin earns from qualifying purchases.

Prices last updated Nov 2026

Cards tracked
94
Highest value
$35.00
Value range
$0–$35
Median value
$2
PSA 10 avg
$22
With recorded sales
44

Most valuable Indianapolis Colts cards

Top 10 by value

By price

All prices

CardYearValue
2022 Score Squad Indianapolis Colts End Zone #S6 card2022 Score Squad · End Zone#S62022$35.00
2022 Score Squad Indianapolis Colts First Down #S6 card2022 Score Squad · First Down#S62022$25.13
2012 Topps · Black#3282012$23.99
2013 Topps · Orange#4292013$23.24
2022 Score Squad Indianapolis Colts Artist's Proof #S6 card2022 Score Squad · Artist's Proof#S62022$12.49
2012 Topps · Orange#3282012$11.95
2006 Etopps Indianapolis Colts Team Card #1 card2006 Etopps · Team Card#12006$9.99
2004 Etopps Indianapolis Colts #26 card2004 Etopps#262004$9.99
2003 Fleer Platinum · Finish#1922003$9.99
2022 Score Squad Indianapolis Colts Red Zone #S6 card2022 Score Squad · Red Zone#S62022$5.00
2022 Score Huddle Up Indianapolis Colts Artist's Proof #HU-IND card2022 Score Huddle Up · Artist's Proof#HU-IND2022$4.99
2022 Score Huddle Up Indianapolis Colts Red Zone #HU-IND card2022 Score Huddle Up · Red Zone#HU-IND2022$4.25
2013 Topps · Black#4292013$4.24
2022 Score Squad Indianapolis Colts Gold Zone #S6 card2022 Score Squad · Gold Zone#S62022$3.99
2022 Score Huddle Up Indianapolis Colts Showcase #HU-IND card2022 Score Huddle Up · Showcase#HU-IND2022$3.88
Show all 60 cards in this table
2010 Topps Indianapolis Colts Gold #79 card2010 Topps · Gold#792010$3.75
2014 Topps · Gold#1932014$3.59
2014 Topps · Orange#1932014$3.42
2012 Topps · Pink#3282012$3.25
2011 Topps · Gold#3682011$3.16
2014 Topps · Black#1932014$3.12
2022 Score Squad Indianapolis Colts Showcase #S6 card2022 Score Squad · Showcase#S62022$2.99
2020 Panini NFL Stickers#1812020$2.86
2013 Topps · Camo#4292013$2.85
1989 Panini Sticker · Logo Foil#2861989$2.65
2022 Score Huddle Up Indianapolis Colts Gold Zone #HU-IND card2022 Score Huddle Up · Gold Zone#HU-IND2022$2.62
2010 Topps Indianapolis Colts #79 card2010 Topps#792010$2.59
2012 Topps · Camo#3282012$2.20
2015 Topps#2542015$1.79
1989 Franchise Game Indianapolis Colts card1989 Franchise Game1989$1.75
2013 Topps · Gold#4292013$1.51
2012 Topps · Gold#3282012$1.49
2022 Score Huddle Up Indianapolis Colts Green #HU-IND card2022 Score Huddle Up · Green#HU-IND2022$1.49
2015 Panini Score Team Leaders Indianapolis Colts #17 card2015 Panini Score Team Leaders#172015$1.49
2011 Topps#3682011$1.48
2022 Score Squad Indianapolis Colts #S6 card2022 Score Squad#S62022$1.42
2017 Score Huddle Up Indianapolis Colts #2 card2017 Score Huddle Up#22017$1.35
1995 Pacific Prisms Indianapolis Colts #13 card1995 Pacific Prisms#131995$1.31
2014 Topps · Pink#1932014$1.29
2012 Topps#3282012$1.25
2014 Topps#1932014$1.20
2013 Topps · Pink#4292013$1.06
1992 Pro Set#6851992$1.05
2013 Topps#4292013$1.00
1989 Panini Score Trivia Quiz indianapolis Colts #22 card1989 Panini Score Trivia Quiz#221989$0.99
2014 Topps · Camo#1932014$0.99
1999 Upper Deck Victory Indianapolis Colts Checklist #106 card1999 Upper Deck Victory · Checklist#1061999$0.99
2003 Fleer Platinum#1922003$0.90
2022 Score Huddle Up Indianapolis Colts #HU-IND card2022 Score Huddle Up#HU-IND2022$0.90
2001 Fleer Tradition Glossy#3512001$0.25
2014 Panini Score Brothers in Arms Indianapolis Colts #BA-14 card2014 Panini Score Brothers in Arms#BA-142014$0.25
2000 Fleer Tradition · Glossy#3782000$0.25
2000 Fleer Tradition#3782000$0.25
2022 Score Huddle Up · Red#HU-IND2022$0.25
1995 Pacific Prism Team Helmets Indianapolis Colts #13 card1995 Pacific Prism Team Helmets#131995$0.25
2022 Score Huddle Up Indianapolis Colts Purple #HU-IND card2022 Score Huddle Up · Purple#HU-IND2022$0.25
2022 Score Huddle Up · Gold#HU-IND2022$0.25
2001 Fleer Tradition Glossy#3712001$0.25
1984 Fleer Team Action Indianapolis Colts Cutting Off All the Angles #4 card1984 Fleer Team Action · Cutting Off All the Angles#41984$0.01
2026 Topps Heritage · Blue Refractor Chrome#3642026—

Showing the top 60 of 94 cards. View all Indianapolis Colts card prices (94 cards) →

By year

YearCardsTop cardValue
202622——
2022182022 Score Squad #S6$35.00
202012020 Panini NFL Stickers #181$2.86
20181——
201712017 Score Huddle Up #2$1.35
201522015 Topps #254$1.79
201482014 Topps #193$3.59
201362013 Topps #429$23.24
201262012 Topps #328$23.99
201122011 Topps #368$3.16
201022010 Topps #79$3.75
200612006 Etopps #1$9.99
200412004 Etopps #26$9.99
200322003 Fleer Platinum #192$9.99
200122001 Fleer Tradition Glossy #351$0.25
200022000 Fleer Tradition #378$0.25
199911999 Upper Deck Victory #106$0.99
19983——
199521995 Pacific Prisms #13$1.31
19941——
19931——
199211992 Pro Set #685$1.05
198941989 Panini Sticker #286$2.65
19882——
198421984 Fleer Team Action #4$0.01

Popular sets

Related articles

More Football players

Frequently asked questions

How much more is a PSA 10 Indianapolis Colts card worth?
Across Indianapolis Colts cards we track with both raw and PSA 10 prices, a PSA 10 sells for roughly 14.9× the ungraded price, averaging about $22. Grading pristine copies can pay off — check each card's grade ladder first.