Chad Pennington card values & price guide

Chad Pennington has 300 cards tracked; the most valuable is the 2000 Leaf Rookies & Stars Chad Pennington Longevity #139 at $196.95 as of October 25, 2026.

300 cards · 167 sets · 2000–2009

2004 Fleer Platinum Chad Pennington Red Autograph #19 card — Card: 2004 Fleer Platinum #19

Chad Pennington career

Quarterback

Chad Pennington is a quarterback, born June 26, 1976.

Born: June 26, 1976

Teams

Miami Dolphins, New York Jets

Facts from Wikidata

Prices last updated Oct 2026

Cards tracked

300

Highest value

$196.95

Value range

$2–$197

Median value

PSA 10 avg

$82

With recorded sales

228

Most valuable Chad Pennington cards

2000 Playoff Contenders

$24.99

$2003 Bowman Chrome Chad Pennington Gold Refractor #110 card$

2003 Bowman Chrome

$20.00

2003 Leaf Limited Threads

$20.00

2006 SP Authentic

$19.99

2000 Playoff Contenders

$18.99

$2004 Bowman Chrome Chad Pennington Gold Refractor #35 card$

2004 Bowman Chrome

$18.08

Top 10 by value

#	Card	Value	Shop
1	2000 Leaf Rookies & Stars · Longevity#139	$196.95	eBay ↗
2	2000 Ultra · Platinum Medallion#226P	$136.19	eBay ↗
3	2000 Bowman Chrome · Gold#173	$90.00	eBay ↗
4	2000 Skybox · Star Rubies Extreme#205SRE	$62.84	eBay ↗
5	2004 Fleer Platinum · Red Autograph#19	$59.95	eBay ↗
6	2000 Upper Deck Ultimate Victory · Parallel 100#96	$53.99	eBay ↗
7	2000 Bowman Chrome#173	$52.72	eBay ↗
8	2004 Fleer Authentix · Balcony Blue#70	$46.24	eBay ↗
9	2006 Leaf Certified Materials · Mirror Emerald Autograph#100	$42.96	eBay ↗
10	2000 Fleer E X · Essential Cred. Future#124	$40.00	eBay ↗

Earliest cards (2000)

The earliest Chad Pennington cards in our catalog, ranked by value.

Card	Year	Value
2000 Leaf Rookies & Stars · Longevity#139	2000	$196.95
2000 Ultra · Platinum Medallion#226P	2000	$136.19
2000 Bowman Chrome · Gold#173	2000	$90.00
2000 Skybox · Star Rubies Extreme#205SRE	2000	$62.84
2000 Upper Deck Ultimate Victory · Parallel 100#96	2000	$53.99
2000 Bowman Chrome#173	2000	$52.72
2000 Fleer E X · Essential Cred. Future#124	2000	$40.00
2000 Press Pass · Reflector#R5	2000	$29.99

By price

Affordable under $25285 cards

$25–$10013 cards

All prices

Card	Year	Value
2000 Leaf Rookies & Stars · Longevity#139	2000	$196.95
2000 Ultra · Platinum Medallion#226P	2000	$136.19
2000 Bowman Chrome · Gold#173	2000	$90.00
2000 Skybox · Star Rubies Extreme#205SRE	2000	$62.84
2004 Fleer Platinum · Red Autograph#19	2004	$59.95
2000 Upper Deck Ultimate Victory · Parallel 100#96	2000	$53.99
2000 Bowman Chrome#173	2000	$52.72
2004 Fleer Authentix · Balcony Blue#70	2004	$46.24
2006 Leaf Certified Materials · Mirror Emerald Autograph#100	2006	$42.96
2000 Fleer E X · Essential Cred. Future#124	2000	$40.00
2009 Topps Magic · Autograph#127	2009	$30.00
2000 Press Pass · Reflector#R5	2000	$29.99
2005 Leaf Rookies & Stars Longevity · Materials Black#65	2005	$29.29
2000 Pacific Crown Royale · Limited Series#133	2000	$29.23
2003 Panini Score · Final Score#98	2003	$25.00

Show all 60 cards in this table

2000 Playoff Contenders · Autograph#112	2000	$24.99
2004 Leaf Certified Materials · Materials Mirror Gold#82	2004	$23.54
2003 Spx · Spectrum#80	2003	$22.39
2000 SP Authentic Sign of the Times#CP	2000	$21.04
2003 SP Authentic Sign of the Times#CP	2003	$20.90
$2003 Bowman Chrome Chad Pennington Gold Refractor #110 card$ 2003 Bowman Chrome · Gold Refractor#110	2003	$20.00
2003 Leaf Limited Threads · At the Half#LT-12	2003	$20.00
2000 Fleer Autographics · Silver	2000	$20.00
2006 SP Authentic · Gold#61	2006	$19.99
2000 Playoff Contenders · Championship Ticket Autograph#112	2000	$18.99
2000 Pacific Aurora · Autograph#99	2000	$18.97
$2004 Bowman Chrome Chad Pennington Gold Refractor #35 card$ 2004 Bowman Chrome · Gold Refractor#35	2004	$18.08
2004 Leaf Certified Materials · Mirror Red Autograph#82	2004	$18.00
2006 Spx · Spectrum#61	2006	$17.79
2000 Leaf Limited#384	2000	$17.79
2000 Upper Deck Black Diamond · Rookie Jersey Gold#156	2000	$17.50
$2007 Bowman Chrome Chad Pennington Orange Refractor #BC119 card$ 2007 Bowman Chrome · Orange Refractor#BC119	2007	$15.51
2004 Upper Deck Finite Signatures · Radiance#FS-CP	2004	$15.50
2000 Fleer Autographics · Gold	2000	$15.00
2005 Leaf Certified Materials · Mirror Blue Autograph#81	2005	$14.99
2003 Topps Chrome · Gold Xfractor#161	2003	$14.78
2004 Leaf Certified Materials · Mirror Blue#82	2004	$14.34
2004 SP Authentic · Gold#60	2004	$14.04
2000 Spx · Signed Jersey#136	2000	$13.99
2005 Topps · Gold#91	2005	$13.84
2007 Playoffs NFL · Material Black Prime#67	2007	$13.30
2004 Leaf Certified Materials · Mirror Gold Autograph#82	2004	$12.50
2003 SP Authentic · Gold#10	2003	$12.04
2004 Fleer Authentix · Club Box Gold#70	2004	$12.03
2003 SP Authentic Threads · Gold#JC-CP	2003	$12.03
2000 Fleer Autographics	2000	$12.00
2004 Leaf Certified Materials · Materials Mirror Blue#82	2004	$11.98
2005 Panini Donruss Elite · Aspirations#64	2005	$11.74
$2004 Topps Chrome Chad Pennington Black Refractor #13 card$ 2004 Topps Chrome · Black Refractor#13	2004	$11.74
2004 Upper Deck Sweet Spot · Gold#67	2004	$10.89
2003 Fleer Authentix · Standing Room Only#62	2003	$10.80
2003 Spx · Spectrum#98	2003	$10.80
$2009 Bowman Chrome Chad Pennington Gold Refractor #16 card$ 2009 Bowman Chrome · Gold Refractor#16	2009	$10.55
2000 Press Pass Autograph · Gold Standout Signature	2000	$10.50
2008 Topps Chrome · Red Refractor#TC4	2008	$10.50
2005 Upper Deck Reflections · Gold#65	2005	$10.32
2004 Leaf Certified Materials · Mirror Gold#82	2004	$10.00
2006 Panini Donruss Elite · Status Gold#68	2006	$10.00
2005 Panini Donruss Zenith Z-Team · Gold#ZT-19	2005	$10.00
2003 SP Signature Signature Edition · Red#CP	2003	$9.99

Showing the top 60 of 300 cards. View all Chad Pennington card prices (300 cards) →

By year

Year	Cards	Top card	Value
2009	6	2009 Topps Magic #127	$30.00
2008	5	2008 Topps Chrome #TC4	$10.50
2007	41	2007 Bowman Chrome #BC119	$15.51
2006	29	2006 Leaf Certified Materials #100	$42.96
2005	37	2005 Leaf Rookies & Stars Longevity #65	$29.29
2004	51	2004 Fleer Platinum #19	$59.95
2003	37	2003 Panini Score #98	$25.00
2002	13	2002 SP Authentic #32	$7.44
2001	16	2001 Pacific Impressions #95	$7.20
2000	65	2000 Leaf Rookies & Stars #139	$196.95

Live eBay listings

Affiliate — we may earn a commission

Most Valuable Chad Pennington Cards Most Valuable Patrick Mahomes Ii Cards Most Valuable Josh Allen Cards Most Valuable Tom Brady Cards Most Valuable Carl Pickens Cards Most Valuable Fletcher Cox Cards Most Valuable Devin Leary Cards

More Football players

Patrick Mahomes Ii cards Josh Allen cards Tom Brady cards Carl Pickens cards Fletcher Cox cards Devin Leary cards Dexter Lawrence cards Devin Duvernay cards Jacoby Brissett cards Danny Gray cards Colin Kaepernick cards Brian Westbrook cards

Frequently asked questions

How much more is a PSA 10 Chad Pennington card worth?: Across Chad Pennington cards we track with both raw and PSA 10 prices, a PSA 10 sells for roughly 9.6× the ungraded price, averaging about $82. Grading pristine copies can pay off — check each card's grade ladder first.