Ripbin
Scan

Casey Mittelstadt card values & price guide

Casey Mittelstadt has 125 cards tracked; the most valuable is the 2018 SP Authentic Casey Mittelstadt Autograph Black Gold Ink #148 at $57.24 as of September 25, 2026.

125 cards · 125 sets · 2018–2018

Share

Shop Casey Mittelstadt cards on eBay

Affiliate — we may earn a commission

Ripbin tracks 20 priced Casey Mittelstadt cards worth $0–$57 — the top 10 account for 84% of tracked value; PSA 10 copies trade ~12.8× raw.

Prices last updated Sep 2026

Cards tracked
125
Highest value
$57.24
Value range
$0–$57
Median value
$4
PSA 10 avg
$43
With recorded sales
1

Casey Mittelstadt has 125 hockey cards in the Ripbin catalog across 125 sets, valued $0.25–$57.24, topped by the 2018 SP Authentic Casey Mittelstadt Autograph Black Gold Ink #148 at about $57.24 ungraded.

Most valuable Casey Mittelstadt cards

2023-24 Upper Deck Premier Acetate Star Autograph Patch Casey Mittelstadt #AV-MI card
2023-24 Upper Deck Premier Acetate Star Autograph Patch
$11.75
2024-25 Upper Deck Premier Acetate Auto Patch Casey Mittelstadt #AV-MI card
2024-25 Upper Deck Premier Acetate Auto Patch
$9.99
2021-22 SP Authentic Limited Autograph Material Casey Mittelstadt #LAM-MI card
2021-22 SP Authentic Limited Autograph Material
$9.01
2023-24 Upper Deck Ultimate Collection Ultimate Access Autograph Patch Casey Mittelstadt #UA-CM card
2023-24 Upper Deck Ultimate Collection Ultimate Access Autograph Patch
$8.88
2024-25 Upper Deck Black Diamond Sparkling Scripts Casey Mittelstadt #SS-CM card
2024-25 Upper Deck Black Diamond Sparkling Scripts
$5.05
2021-22 Upper Deck Credentials Main Stage Signatures Casey Mittelstadt #BTS-CM card
2021-22 Upper Deck Credentials Main Stage Signatures
$4.52
2021-22 SP Authentic Chirography Casey Mittelstadt #C-CM card
2021-22 SP Authentic Chirography
$4.44
2021-22 Upper Deck Ovation Praised Penmanship Casey Mittelstadt #PP-CM card
2021-22 Upper Deck Ovation Praised Penmanship
$3.84

Top 10 most valuable Casey Mittelstadt cards

#CardValue
12018 SP Authentic · Autograph Black Gold Ink#148$57.24
22023-24 Upper Deck Premier Acetate Star Autograph Patch#AV-MI$11.75
32024-25 Upper Deck Premier Acetate Auto Patch#AV-MI$9.99
42021-22 SP Authentic Limited Autograph Material#LAM-MI$9.01
52023-24 Upper Deck Ultimate Collection Ultimate Access Autograph Patch#UA-CM$8.88
62024-25 Upper Deck Black Diamond Sparkling Scripts#SS-CM$5.05
72021-22 Upper Deck Credentials Main Stage Signatures#BTS-CM$4.52
82021-22 SP Authentic Chirography#C-CM$4.44
92021-22 Upper Deck Ovation Praised Penmanship#PP-CM$3.84
102021-22 SP Authentic Sign of the Times#SOTT-CM$3.59

Casey Mittelstadt's earliest cards (2018)

The earliest Casey Mittelstadt cards in our catalog — their rookie-year issues — ranked by value.

CardYearValue
2018 SP Authentic · Autograph Black Gold Ink#1482018$57.24
2018 Upper Deck#4532018$2.49
2018 Upper Deck MVP NHL Player Credentials Entry Level Access#NHL-MI2018$0.25

Casey Mittelstadt cards by price

Affordable under $2519 cards
$25–$1001 cards

Casey Mittelstadt card prices

CardYearValue
2018 SP Authentic · Autograph Black Gold Ink#1482018$57.24
2023-24 Upper Deck Premier Acetate Star Autograph Patch Casey Mittelstadt #AV-MI card2023-24 Upper Deck Premier Acetate Star Autograph Patch#AV-MI—$11.75
2024-25 Upper Deck Premier Acetate Auto Patch Casey Mittelstadt #AV-MI card2024-25 Upper Deck Premier Acetate Auto Patch#AV-MI—$9.99
2021-22 SP Authentic Limited Autograph Material Casey Mittelstadt #LAM-MI card2021-22 SP Authentic Limited Autograph Material#LAM-MI—$9.01
2023-24 Upper Deck Ultimate Collection Ultimate Access Autograph Patch Casey Mittelstadt #UA-CM card2023-24 Upper Deck Ultimate Collection Ultimate Access Autograph Patch#UA-CM—$8.88
2024-25 Upper Deck Black Diamond Sparkling Scripts Casey Mittelstadt #SS-CM card2024-25 Upper Deck Black Diamond Sparkling Scripts#SS-CM—$5.05
2021-22 Upper Deck Credentials Main Stage Signatures Casey Mittelstadt #BTS-CM card2021-22 Upper Deck Credentials Main Stage Signatures#BTS-CM—$4.52
2021-22 SP Authentic Chirography Casey Mittelstadt #C-CM card2021-22 SP Authentic Chirography#C-CM—$4.44
2021-22 Upper Deck Ovation Praised Penmanship Casey Mittelstadt #PP-CM card2021-22 Upper Deck Ovation Praised Penmanship#PP-CM—$3.84
2021-22 SP Authentic Sign of the Times Casey Mittelstadt #SOTT-CM card2021-22 SP Authentic Sign of the Times#SOTT-CM—$3.59
2023-24 Upper Deck Clear Cut Champs Autos Casey Mittelstadt #C-MI card2023-24 Upper Deck Clear Cut Champs Autos#C-MI—$3.51
2023-24 Upper Deck Ultimate Collection Ultimate Emblems Autograph Casey Mittelstadt #UE-MI card2023-24 Upper Deck Ultimate Collection Ultimate Emblems Autograph#UE-MI—$3.33
2023-24 Upper Deck Premier On the Forefront Autograph Casey Mittelstadt #OFA-CM card2023-24 Upper Deck Premier On the Forefront Autograph#OFA-CM—$3.11
2022-23 SPx Superscripts Casey Mittelstadt #SS-CM card2022-23 SPx Superscripts#SS-CM—$2.53
2018 Upper Deck Casey Mittelstadt #453 card2018 Upper Deck#4532018$2.49
2023-24 SP Authentic Pageantry Auto Casey Mittelstadt #P-23 card2023-24 SP Authentic Pageantry Auto#P-23—$2.32
2023-24 SP Authentic Curated Signatures Casey Mittelstadt #SPC-CM card2023-24 SP Authentic Curated Signatures#SPC-CM—$2.18
2025-26 O-Pee-Chee Platinum Retro Red Auto Casey Mittelstadt #R-57 card2025-26 O-Pee-Chee Platinum Retro Red Auto#R-57—$1.55
2021-22 Upper Deck UD Game Jersey Casey Mittelstadt #GJ-CM card2021-22 Upper Deck UD Game Jersey#GJ-CM—$0.99
2018 Upper Deck MVP NHL Player Credentials Entry Level Access Casey Mittelstadt #NHL-MI card2018 Upper Deck MVP NHL Player Credentials Entry Level Access#NHL-MI2018$0.25
2024-25 Upper Deck UD Canvas Casey Mittelstadt #C188 card2024-25 Upper Deck UD Canvas#C188——
2024-25 O-Pee-Chee Platinum Base Set Casey Mittelstadt #136 card2024-25 O-Pee-Chee Platinum Base Set#136——
2023-24 Upper Deck Clear Cut 2021 Update - Base Set Casey Mittelstadt #CC-CM card2023-24 Upper Deck Clear Cut 2021 Update - Base Set#CC-CM——
2019-20 Upper Deck The Cup 2018-19 Update - Limited Logos Casey Mittelstadt #LL-CM card2019-20 Upper Deck The Cup 2018-19 Update - Limited Logos#LL-CM——
2019-20 Upper Deck Ice 2018-19 Ice Update - Ice Premieres Autographs Casey Mittelstadt #IPA-CM card2019-20 Upper Deck Ice 2018-19 Ice Update - Ice Premieres Autographs#IPA-CM——
2021-22 Upper Deck Premier Premier Signature Seats Casey Mittelstadt #PSS-CM card2021-22 Upper Deck Premier Premier Signature Seats#PSS-CM——
2022-23 O-Pee-Chee Retro Casey Mittelstadt #274 card2022-23 O-Pee-Chee Retro#274——
2019-20 Upper Deck Rookie Retrospective Jersey Casey Mittelstadt #RR-CM card2019-20 Upper Deck Rookie Retrospective Jersey#RR-CM——
2023-24 Parkhurst Base Set Casey Mittelstadt #39 card2023-24 Parkhurst Base Set#39——
2023-24 Upper Deck The Cup Base Set Casey Mittelstadt #56 card2023-24 Upper Deck The Cup Base Set#56——
2023-24 SP Authentic Pageantry Casey Mittelstadt #P-23 card2023-24 SP Authentic Pageantry#P-23——
2019-20 Upper Deck The Cup 2018-19 Update - Signature Materials Casey Mittelstadt #SP-MI card2019-20 Upper Deck The Cup 2018-19 Update - Signature Materials#SP-MI——
2023-24 Upper Deck Ultimate Collection Ultimate Signatures Casey Mittelstadt #US-CM card2023-24 Upper Deck Ultimate Collection Ultimate Signatures#US-CM——
2021-22 SPx Base Set Casey Mittelstadt #32 card2021-22 SPx Base Set#32——
2021-22 Upper Deck Ovation UD Glass Magnifying Marks Red Casey Mittelstadt #MM-MI card2021-22 Upper Deck Ovation UD Glass Magnifying Marks Red#MM-MI——
2022-23 Upper Deck The Cup 2022-23 Upper Deck Update Casey Mittelstadt #20 card2022-23 Upper Deck The Cup 2022-23 Upper Deck Update#20——
2019-20 Upper Deck Ice 2018-19 Ice Update - Superb Script Portraits Casey Mittelstadt #SSP-CM card2019-20 Upper Deck Ice 2018-19 Ice Update - Superb Script Portraits#SSP-CM——
2019-20 Upper Deck The Cup 2018-19 Exquisite Collection Update - Endorsements Relics Casey Mittelstadt #ER-MI card2019-20 Upper Deck The Cup 2018-19 Exquisite Collection Update - Endorsements Relics#ER-MI——
2019-20 Upper Deck Ice 2018-19 Ice Update - Ice Premieres Autograph Patch Casey Mittelstadt #IP-CM card2019-20 Upper Deck Ice 2018-19 Ice Update - Ice Premieres Autograph Patch#IP-CM——
2022-23 Upper Deck Premier 2021 Update - Platinum Autograph Casey Mittelstadt #80 card2022-23 Upper Deck Premier 2021 Update - Platinum Autograph#80——
2019-20 Upper Deck The Cup 2018-19 Splendor Update - Base Casey Mittelstadt #S-MI card2019-20 Upper Deck The Cup 2018-19 Splendor Update - Base#S-MI——
2022-23 Upper Deck The Cup 2021-22 Exquisite Collection Update - 2003-04 Limited Logos Casey Mittelstadt #LLT-CM card2022-23 Upper Deck The Cup 2021-22 Exquisite Collection Update - 2003-04 Limited Logos#LLT-CM——
2022-23 Upper Deck The Cup 2021-22 The Cup Update - The NHL Collection Casey Mittelstadt #NHL-CM card2022-23 Upper Deck The Cup 2021-22 The Cup Update - The NHL Collection#NHL-CM——
2022-23 Upper Deck Ice 2021-22 Ice Update - White Snowflake Autograph Parallel Casey Mittelstadt #38 card2022-23 Upper Deck Ice 2021-22 Ice Update - White Snowflake Autograph Parallel#38——
2022-23 Upper Deck Premier 2021 Update - Premier Signature Seats Gold Section Casey Mittelstadt #PSS-CM card2022-23 Upper Deck Premier 2021 Update - Premier Signature Seats Gold Section#PSS-CM——
2022-23 Upper Deck The Cup 2021-22 The Cup Update - Top Tens Casey Mittelstadt #2017-8 card2022-23 Upper Deck The Cup 2021-22 The Cup Update - Top Tens#2017-8——
2019-20 Upper Deck Allure Quartz Autos Casey Mittelstadt #AQ-MI card2019-20 Upper Deck Allure Quartz Autos#AQ-MI——
2019-20 Upper Deck The Cup 2018-19 Update - UD Printing Plate Autograph Booklets Young Guns Casey Mittelstadt #453 card2019-20 Upper Deck The Cup 2018-19 Update - UD Printing Plate Autograph Booklets Young Guns#453——
2021-22 Upper Deck Ultimate Collection Ultimate Premium Material Parallel Casey Mittelstadt #UMS-CM card2021-22 Upper Deck Ultimate Collection Ultimate Premium Material Parallel#UMS-CM——
2022-23 SP Game Used 2022 NHL Heritage Classic Net Cord Relics Casey Mittelstadt #HCN-CM card2022-23 SP Game Used 2022 NHL Heritage Classic Net Cord Relics#HCN-CM——
2019-20 O-Pee-Chee Platinum 2018-19 Update Retro Rainbow Red Autos Casey Mittelstadt #R-95 card2019-20 O-Pee-Chee Platinum 2018-19 Update Retro Rainbow Red Autos#R-95——
2019-20 Upper Deck Ice 2018-19 Ice Update - Rookie Rinkside Signings Casey Mittelstadt #RRS-CM card2019-20 Upper Deck Ice 2018-19 Ice Update - Rookie Rinkside Signings#RRS-CM——
2019-20 Upper Deck The Cup 2018-19 Update - Autograph Rookie Plates Exquisite Collection Casey Mittelstadt #EC-CM card2019-20 Upper Deck The Cup 2018-19 Update - Autograph Rookie Plates Exquisite Collection#EC-CM——
2019-20 Upper Deck The Cup 2018-19 Exquisite Collection Update - Rookie Autograph Patch Casey Mittelstadt #EC-CM card2019-20 Upper Deck The Cup 2018-19 Exquisite Collection Update - Rookie Autograph Patch#EC-CM——
2019-20 Upper Deck Ice 2018-19 Ice Update - Exquisite Collection Platinum Rookie Signatures Casey Mittelstadt #R5 card2019-20 Upper Deck Ice 2018-19 Ice Update - Exquisite Collection Platinum Rookie Signatures#R5——
2019-20 Upper Deck Ice 2018-19 Ice Update - Superb Script Casey Mittelstadt #SS-CM card2019-20 Upper Deck Ice 2018-19 Ice Update - Superb Script#SS-CM——
2021-22 SP Authentic 2001-02 Retro - Sign of the Times Casey Mittelstadt #SOTT1-CM card2021-22 SP Authentic 2001-02 Retro - Sign of the Times#SOTT1-CM——
2021-22 O-Pee-Chee Retro Casey Mittelstadt #465 card2021-22 O-Pee-Chee Retro#465——
2025-26 O-Pee-Chee Base Retro Casey Mittelstadt #276 card2025-26 O-Pee-Chee Base Retro#276——
2021-22 Upper Deck Base Set Casey Mittelstadt #272 card2021-22 Upper Deck Base Set#272——

Showing the top 60 of 125 cards. View all Casey Mittelstadt card prices (125 cards) →

Most popular sets featuring Casey Mittelstadt

2018 SP Authentic1 card$572023-24 Upper Deck Premier Acetate Star Autograph Patch1 card$122024-25 Upper Deck Premier Acetate Auto Patch1 card$102021-22 SP Authentic Limited Autograph Material1 card$92023-24 Upper Deck Ultimate Collection Ultimate Access Autograph Patch1 card$92024-25 Upper Deck Black Diamond Sparkling Scripts1 card$52021-22 Upper Deck Credentials Main Stage Signatures1 card$52021-22 SP Authentic Chirography1 card$4

Related articles

Most Valuable Casey Mittelstadt CardsMost Valuable Connor Mcdavid CardsMost Valuable Cale Makar CardsMost Valuable Auston Matthews CardsMost Valuable Alex Ovechkin CardsMost Valuable Sidney Crosby CardsMost Valuable Connor Bedard Cards

More Hockey players

Connor Mcdavid cardsCale Makar cardsAuston Matthews cardsAlex Ovechkin cardsSidney Crosby cardsConnor Bedard cardsNathan Mackinnon cardsLeon Draisaitl cardsKirill Kaprizov cardsWayne Gretzky cardsMacklin Celebrini cardsMatt Boldy cards

Frequently asked questions

How much more is a PSA 10 Casey Mittelstadt card worth?
Across Casey Mittelstadt cards we track with both raw and PSA 10 prices, a PSA 10 sells for roughly 12.8× the ungraded price, averaging about $43. Grading pristine copies can pay off — check each card's grade ladder first.

Casey Mittelstadt cards live on eBay

Affiliate — we may earn a commission