Ripbin
Scan

Ad disclosure: As an eBay Partner Network affiliate, Ripbin earns from qualifying purchases. Learn more

🔥 Hot buys on eBay

See all →

As an eBay Partner Network affiliate, Ripbin earns from qualifying purchases.

Carmella card values & price guide

Carmella has 300 cards tracked; the most valuable is the 2024 Panini Prizm WWE Superstar Autograph Carmella White Sparkle #12 at $799.99 as of November 15, 2026.

300 cards · 98 sets · 2016–2025

Share

Live eBay listings

As an eBay Partner Network affiliate, Ripbin earns from qualifying purchases.
Carmella

Carmella career

Carmella was born October 23, 1987.

Born
October 23, 1987
Height
165 cm
5 ft 5 in
Weight
50 kg
110 lb
College
University of Massachusetts Dartmouth
Nationality
United States

Facts from Wikidata

Prices last updated Nov 2026

Cards tracked
300
Highest value
$799.99
Value range
$10–$800
Median value
$25
PSA 10 avg
$115
With recorded sales
288

Most valuable Carmella cards

Top 10 by value

Earliest cards (2016)

The earliest Carmella cards in our catalog, ranked by value.

By price

All prices

CardYearValue
2024 Panini Prizm WWE Superstar Autograph Carmella White Sparkle #12 card2024 Panini Prizm WWE Superstar Autograph · White Sparkle#122024$799.99
2023 Panini Chronicles WWE Carmella Platinum #111 card2023 Panini Chronicles WWE · Platinum#1112024$179.99
2022 Panini NXT WWE Alumni Signatures Carmella Gold #AS-CML card2022 Panini NXT WWE Alumni Signatures · Gold#AS-CML2022$175.00
2022 Panini Select WWE Carmella Elephant Prizm #294 card2022 Panini Select WWE · Elephant Prizm#2942022$149.99
2024 Panini Select WWE Carmella Gold Prizm #105 card2024 Panini Select WWE · Gold Prizm#1052024$149.97
2022 Panini Impeccable WWE Illustrious Ink Autographs Carmella Holo Gold #IL-CML card2022 Panini Impeccable WWE Illustrious Ink Autographs · Holo Gold#IL-CML2022$133.00
2023 Panini Prizm WWE Carmella Under Card Gold #88 card2023 Panini Prizm WWE · Under Card Gold#882023$125.00
2023 Panini Prizm WWE Carmella Gold #88 card2023 Panini Prizm WWE · Gold#882023$119.99
2022 Panini Revolution WWE Autographs Carmella Lava #AG-CML card2022 Panini Revolution WWE Autographs · Lava#AG-CML2022$110.22
2022 Panini Select WWE Carmella Gold Prizm #294 card2022 Panini Select WWE · Gold Prizm#2942022$107.75
2023 Panini Select WWE Carmella Zebra #18 card2023 Panini Select WWE · Zebra#182023$107.61
2023 Panini Prizm WWE Superstar Autographs Carmella Gold #SA-CML card2023 Panini Prizm WWE Superstar Autographs · Gold#SA-CML2023$105.50
2022 Panini Select WWE Carmella Zebra Prizm #294 card2022 Panini Select WWE · Zebra Prizm#2942022$102.50
2023 Panini Impeccable WWE Silver WWE Logo Carmella #BAR-CML card2023 Panini Impeccable WWE Silver WWE Logo#BAR-CML2023$100.00
2024 Panini PhotoGenic WWE · Swirl FOTL#1662024$100.00
Show all 60 cards in this table
2023 Panini Select WWE Carmella Mojo #18 card2023 Panini Select WWE · Mojo#182023$99.99
2022 Panini Select WWE Carmella Tie Dye Prizm #189 card2022 Panini Select WWE · Tie Dye Prizm#1892022$99.00
2022 Panini Select WWE Carmella Gold Wave #294 card2022 Panini Select WWE · Gold Wave#2942022$92.72
2025 Topps Chrome WWE Carmella Red Geometric Refractor #145 card2025 Topps Chrome WWE · Red Geometric Refractor#1452025$91.25
2022 Panini Select WWE Carmella Lucky Envelopes Prizm #294 card2022 Panini Select WWE · Lucky Envelopes Prizm#2942022$89.00
2022 Panini Impeccable WWE Silver Logo Carmella #15 card2022 Panini Impeccable WWE Silver Logo#152022$83.00
2024 Panini Prizm WWE Carmella Gold #200 card2024 Panini Prizm WWE · Gold#2002024$82.57
2023 Panini Select WWE Carmella Zebra #287 card2023 Panini Select WWE · Zebra#2872023$81.00
2023 Panini Chronicles WWE Phoenix Autograph Carmella Gold #23 card2023 Panini Chronicles WWE Phoenix Autograph · Gold#232024$79.99
2023 Panini Select WWE Carmella Lucky Envelopes #18 card2023 Panini Select WWE · Lucky Envelopes#182023$79.64
2022 Panini Select WWE Signatures Carmella Gold Wave Prizm #SG-CML card2022 Panini Select WWE Signatures · Gold Wave Prizm#SG-CML2022$78.15
2020 Topps WWE Undisputed Autographs Carmella Purple #A-CM card2020 Topps WWE Undisputed Autographs · Purple#A-CM2020$77.32
2023 Panini Select WWE Carmella Gold #18 card2023 Panini Select WWE · Gold#182023$76.72
2022 Panini Select WWE Carmella Tiger Prizm #294 card2022 Panini Select WWE · Tiger Prizm#2942022$76.00
2024 Panini Select WWE Carmella Tiger Prizm #105 card2024 Panini Select WWE · Tiger Prizm#1052024$75.00
2022 Panini Select WWE Carmella Gold Flash #294 card2022 Panini Select WWE · Gold Flash#2942022$75.00
2021 Topps Heritage WWE Autographs Carmella Red #A-CM card2021 Topps Heritage WWE Autographs · Red#A-CM2021$75.00
2021 Topps WWE Women's Division Autographs · Black#A-CM2021$74.95
2022 Panini Chronicles WWE National Treasures Memorabilia Autographs Carmella Gold #NT-CML card2022 Panini Chronicles WWE National Treasures Memorabilia Autographs · Gold#NT-CML2022$74.38
2022 Panini Select WWE Carmella Green Prizm #294 card2022 Panini Select WWE · Green Prizm#2942022$72.91
2025 Topps Chrome WWE Carmella Black Gold Refractor #145 card2025 Topps Chrome WWE · Black Gold Refractor#1452025$72.50
2024 Panini Prizm WWE Superstar Autograph Carmella Under Card Gold #12 card2024 Panini Prizm WWE Superstar Autograph · Under Card Gold#122024$71.50
2016 Topps WWE Undisputed Autographs Carmella Gold #UA-CA card2016 Topps WWE Undisputed Autographs · Gold#UA-CA2016$69.95
2020 Topps WWE Undisputed Dual Relics · Purple#DR-CM2020$66.78
2023 Panini Prizm WWE Carmella Gold Shimmer #88 card2023 Panini Prizm WWE · Gold Shimmer#882023$66.00
2024 Panini PhotoGenic WWE Carmella Gold #166 card2024 Panini PhotoGenic WWE · Gold#1662024$65.00
2024 Panini Prizm WWE Superstar Autograph Carmella Gold #12 card2024 Panini Prizm WWE Superstar Autograph · Gold#122024$60.74
2021 Topps WWE · Black#1422021$60.00
2017 Topps WWE Women's Division · Autograph#R-282017$60.00
2016 Topps WWE Divas Revolution Kiss · Autograph2016$60.00
2023 Donruss Elite WWE Elite Signature · Gold#372024$60.00
2023 Panini Select WWE Carmella Gold Wave #18 card2023 Panini Select WWE · Gold Wave#182023$58.05
2023 Panini Select WWE Carmella Tie-Dye #380 card2023 Panini Select WWE · Tie-Dye#3802023$57.00
2023 Panini Select WWE Carmella Gold Flash #18 card2023 Panini Select WWE · Gold Flash#182023$55.67
2021 Topps WWE Women's Division Autographs · Gold#A-CM2021$55.50
2022 Panini Revolution WWE · Galactic#402022$55.37
2022 Panini Select WWE Carmella Gold Flash #189 card2022 Panini Select WWE · Gold Flash#1892022$55.00
2023 Panini Chronicles WWE Carmella Gold #111 card2023 Panini Chronicles WWE · Gold#1112024$54.99
2024 Panini Select WWE Carmella Ice Gold Prizm #105 card2024 Panini Select WWE · Ice Gold Prizm#1052024$54.84
2024 Panini Three Count WWE Memorabilia Autograph · Red#MA-CML2024$54.00
2023 Panini Immaculate WWE Past and Present Signature Carmella #PP-CML card2023 Panini Immaculate WWE Past and Present Signature#PP-CML2023$52.77
2023 Panini Revolution WWE · Lava#312023$50.00
2023 Panini Immaculate WWE Remarkable Memorabilia Carmella #RM-CML card2023 Panini Immaculate WWE Remarkable Memorabilia#RM-CML2023$50.00
2021 Topps Slam Attax Chrome WWE · Black#212021$50.00
2022 Panini Select WWE Carmella Gold Wave #189 card2022 Panini Select WWE · Gold Wave#1892022$47.07

Showing the top 60 of 300 cards. View all Carmella card prices (300 cards) →

By year

Popular sets

Related articles

More Wrestling players

Frequently asked questions

How much more is a PSA 10 Carmella card worth?
Across Carmella cards we track with both raw and PSA 10 prices, a PSA 10 sells for roughly 4.0× the ungraded price, averaging about $115. Grading pristine copies can pay off — check each card's grade ladder first.