Baylor Scheierman card values & price guide

Baylor Scheierman has 131 cards tracked; the most valuable is the 2024 Panini Prizm Baylor Scheierman Black Shimmer FOTL #236 at $4,999.95 as of August 27, 2026.

131 cards · 124 sets · 2025–2025

Shop Baylor Scheierman cards on eBay

Affiliate — we may earn a commission

Ripbin tracks 32 priced Baylor Scheierman cards worth $2–$5,000 — the top 10 account for 96% of tracked value; PSA 10 copies trade ~7.3× raw.

Prices last updated Aug 2026

Cards tracked

131

Highest value

$4,999.95

Value range

$2–$5,000

Median value

$16

PSA 10 avg

$94

With recorded sales

Baylor Scheierman has 131 basketball cards in the Ripbin catalog across 124 sets, valued $1.69–$4,999.95, topped by the 2024 Panini Prizm Baylor Scheierman Black Shimmer FOTL #236 at about $4,999.95 ungraded.

Most valuable Baylor Scheierman cards

2024-25 Panini Court Kings Fresh Paint Autographs

$40.00

2024-25 Topps Inception Rookie Jumbo Relic Autographs

$36.50

2024-25 Topps Inception Rookie Jumbo Relics

$36.50

2024-25 Donruss Next Day Autographs

$36.23

2024-25 Panini Origins Rookie Jersey Auto Set

$35.00

2024-25 Panini Select Rookie Jersey Autographs

$32.99

2024-25 Panini Immaculate Collection Massive Memorabilia Set

$25.00

2024-25 Hoops Rookie Ink

$25.00

Top 10 most valuable Baylor Scheierman cards

#	Card	Value
1	2024 Panini Prizm · Black Shimmer FOTL#236	$4,999.95
2	2024-25 Panini Court Kings Fresh Paint Autographs#FP-BAY	$40.00
3	2024-25 Topps Inception Rookie Jumbo Relic Autographs#RJR-BS	$36.50
4	2024-25 Topps Inception Rookie Jumbo Relics#RJR-BS	$36.50
5	2024-25 Donruss Next Day Autographs#NDA-BSB	$36.23
6	2024-25 Panini Origins Rookie Jersey Auto Set#RJA-BCR	$35.00
7	2024-25 Panini Select Rookie Jersey Autographs#RJA-BAY	$32.99
8	2024-25 Panini Immaculate Collection Massive Memorabilia Set#18	$25.00
9	2024-25 Hoops Rookie Ink#RI-BAY	$25.00
10	2024-25 Finest Masters Autographs#MA-BS	$21.66

Baylor Scheierman's earliest cards (2025)

The earliest Baylor Scheierman cards in our catalog — their rookie-year issues — ranked by value.

Card	Year	Value
2024 Panini Prizm · Black Shimmer FOTL#236	2025	$4,999.95
2024 Panini Donruss · Rated Rookie Signature#270	2025	$13.55
2024 Panini Donruss Optic · Signature#310	2025	$10.93

Baylor Scheierman cards by price

Affordable under $2523 cards

$25–$1008 cards

Grails ($500+)1 cards

2024 Panini Prizm #236$4,999.95

Recent Baylor Scheierman price movers

Biggest 90-day price changes among tracked cards.

Card	90-day	Value
2024-25 Panini Obsidian Rookie Eruption Autographs #REA-BAY	+725%	$139.99
2024-25 Topps Inception Rookie Jumbo Relic Autographs #RJR-BS	-45%	$20.00
2024-25 Panini Select Rookie Jersey Autographs #RJA-BAY	-35%	$21.53
2024-25 Panini Obsidian Eclipse Materials #EM-BSB	-15%	$17.00
2024-25 Panini Court Kings Fresh Paint Autographs #FP-BAY	-12%	$35.00

Baylor Scheierman card prices

Card	Year	Value
2024 Panini Prizm · Black Shimmer FOTL#236	2025	$4,999.95
2024-25 Panini Court Kings Fresh Paint Autographs#FP-BAY	—	$40.00
2024-25 Topps Inception Rookie Jumbo Relic Autographs#RJR-BS	—	$36.50
2024-25 Topps Inception Rookie Jumbo Relics#RJR-BS	—	$36.50
2024-25 Donruss Next Day Autographs#NDA-BSB	—	$36.23
2024-25 Panini Origins Rookie Jersey Auto Set#RJA-BCR	—	$35.00
2024-25 Panini Select Rookie Jersey Autographs#RJA-BAY	—	$32.99
2024-25 Panini Immaculate Collection Massive Memorabilia Set#18	—	$25.00
2024-25 Hoops Rookie Ink#RI-BAY	—	$25.00
2024-25 Finest Masters Autographs#MA-BS	—	$21.66
2024-25 Topps Chrome Next Stop Signatures#NSS-BS	—	$20.00
2024-25 Panini Obsidian Eclipse Materials#EM-BSB	—	$19.99
2024-25 Panini Mosaic Rookie Autographs Mosaic#RAM-BAY	—	$19.50
2025-26 Topps Topps Notch Signatures#TNS-BSC	—	$18.00
2024-25 Panini Obsidian Rookie Eruption Autographs#REA-BAY	—	$16.97
2024-25 Hoops Hot Signatures Rookies#HSR-BAY	—	$16.65
2024-25 Panini Court Kings Impressionist Ink Autographs#II-BAY	—	$16.17
2024-25 Panini Noir Rookie Jumbo Material Set#14	—	$15.00
2024 Panini Donruss · Rated Rookie Signature#270	2025	$13.55
2024-25 Panini Immaculate Collection Rookie Autographs International Set#36	—	$13.00
2024 Panini Donruss Optic · Signature#310	2025	$10.93
2024-25 Finest Arrivals#A-21	—	$10.25
2025-26 Topps Signature Class Manuscripts#MS-BS	—	$8.50
2024-25 Panini Court Kings Works in Progress#26	—	$7.50
2024-25 Hoops Great SIGnificance#GS-BSC	—	$7.28
2024-25 Panini Prizm Rookie Penmanship#RPE-BAY	—	$6.35
2024-25 Topps Chrome Topps Certified Autograph Issue Rookies#TCRA-BS	—	$6.00
2024-25 Panini Immaculate Collection Draft Combine Memorabilia Set#31	—	$5.50
2024-25 Panini Court Kings Rookie Swatches#RJS-BSC	—	$5.21
2024-25 Topps Chrome Destiny#D-22	—	$3.77
2024-25 Panini Noir New Wave Jerseys Set#14	—	$2.25
2024-25 Panini Origins Originals Set#20	—	$1.69
2024-25 Donruss Base Set#224	—	—
2024-25 Haunted Hoops Base Haunted Hoops#249	—	—
2024-25 Topps Chrome Advisory#A-22	—	—
2024-25 Panini Select Jumbo Rookie Signature Swatches#JRS-BAY	—	—
2024-25 Panini Select Jumbo Rookie Swatches#JRS-BAY	—	—
2024-25 Panini Totally Certified Freshman Fabric Signatures#19	—	—
2024-25 Panini Revolution Rookie Autographs#RA-BAY	—	—
2024-25 Panini Totally Certified Rookie Yearbook Autographs#RYA-BAY	—	—
2024-25 Panini Totally Certified Rookie Roll Call Autographs#14	—	—
2024-25 Panini National Treasures Rookie Materials Autographs Triple#RMT-BAY	—	—
2024-25 Panini Prizm Black Private Signings#PS-BAY	—	—
2024-25 Hoops Rise 'n Shine Memorabilia#RSM-BSC	—	—
2024-25 Panini Noir Casting Call Memorabilia Set#29	—	—
2024-25 Panini Noir Opening Night Memorabilia International Set#29	—	—
2024-25 Finest Electrifying Signatures Geometric#ES-BS	—	—
2024-25 Panini Silhouette Silhouette Autographs#SIL-BAY	—	—
2024-25 Panini Obsidian Base Set#154	—	—
2024-25 Panini Photogenic Base Set#200	—	—
2024-25 Panini Immaculate Collection Sneak Peek - Heel Logo Set#29	—	—
2024-25 Panini Obsidian Base Set#206	—	—
2025-26 Topps Holiday Base Set#H5	—	—
2025-26 Topps 1980-81 Topps Basketball#80BK-49	—	—
2025-26 Topps Holiday Autographs#H5	—	—
2024-25 Panini Totally Certified Base Set#172	—	—
2024-25 Panini One and One Base Set#132	—	—
2024-25 Panini Revolution Base Set#120	—	—
2024-25 Panini Immaculate Collection Base Set#115	—	—
2024-25 Panini Immaculate Collection Rookie Championship Tags Autographs Set#14	—	—

Showing the top 60 of 131 cards. View all Baylor Scheierman card prices (131 cards) →

Most popular sets featuring Baylor Scheierman

2024-25 Panini Court Kings Base Set5 cards 2024-25 Donruss Base Set2 cards 2024-25 Panini Obsidian Base Set2 cards 2024-25 Panini National Treasures Base Set2 cards 2024 Panini Prizm1 card$5,000 2024-25 Panini Court Kings Fresh Paint Autographs1 card$40 2024-25 Topps Inception Rookie Jumbo Relic Autographs1 card$37 2024-25 Topps Inception Rookie Jumbo Relics1 card$37

Most Valuable Baylor Scheierman Cards Most Valuable Lebron James Cards Most Valuable Victor Wembanyama Cards Most Valuable Ja Morant Cards Most Valuable Luka Doncic Cards Most Valuable Stephen Curry Cards Most Valuable Jayson Tatum Cards

More Basketball players

Lebron James cards Victor Wembanyama cards Ja Morant cards Luka Doncic cards Stephen Curry cards Jayson Tatum cards Anthony Edwards cards Giannis Antetokounmpo cards Kevin Durant cards Trae Young cards Nikola Jokic cards Paolo Banchero cards

Frequently asked questions

How much more is a PSA 10 Baylor Scheierman card worth?: Across Baylor Scheierman cards we track with both raw and PSA 10 prices, a PSA 10 sells for roughly 7.3× the ungraded price, averaging about $94. Grading pristine copies can pay off — check each card's grade ladder first.