The 10 Most Valuable Tyrann Mathieu Cards
The most valuable Tyrann Mathieu card is the 2025 Panini Prizm Base Set Tyrann Mathieu Black Finite #196 at $2,282.00 as of October 21, 2026.
By Ripbin Research · Updated 2026-10-21 · prices from live market data
See all Tyrann Mathieu cards & valuesShop Tyrann Mathieu cards on eBay
Affiliate — we may earn a commissionThe 10 most valuable Tyrann Mathieu cards in the Ripbin catalog (2013–2026) carry a combined raw market value of $6,439.68, topped by a $2,282.00 card.
#62013 Panini Spectra Tyrann Mathieu Spectra Gold #250
$349.99PSA 10 ~$175.00
Just missed the cut
- #11 2013 Panini Select Tyrann Mathieu Gold Prizm #246$255.00
- #12 2013 Topps Chrome Tyrann Mathieu Red Refractor #4$209.82
- #13 2021 Panini Select Base Set Tyrann Mathieu Disco #218$165.40
- #14 2024 Panini Phoenix Base Set Tyrann Mathieu Black Pandora #143$150.00
- #15 2013 Panini Contenders Tyrann Mathieu Running Autograph Cracked Ice Ticket #189$145.00
- #16 2013 Panini Prizm Tyrann Mathieu Light Blue Die Cut Prizm #296$135.00
- #17 2013 Panini Spectra Tyrann Mathieu Autograph Spectra Gold #196$129.99
- #18 2023 Panini Prizm Base Set Tyrann Mathieu Green Shimmer #218$125.00
- #19 2024 Panini Mosaic Base Set Tyrann Mathieu Green Fluorescent #161$89.99
- #20 2025 Panini Prizm Base Set Tyrann Mathieu Gold #196$85.00
Sets in this guide
More Football guides
Most Valuable Patrick Mahomes Ii CardsMost Valuable Josh Allen CardsMost Valuable Tom Brady CardsMost Valuable Mason Taylor CardsMost Valuable David Njoku CardsMost Valuable Terrace Marshall Jr CardsMost Valuable Kordell Stewart CardsMost Valuable Evan Engram CardsMost Valuable Tiki Barber CardsMost Valuable Jerome Ford Cards