The 10 Most Valuable Sandy McCarthy Cards
The most valuable Sandy McCarthy card is the 2020-21 SP Signature Edition Legends UD Canvas Legends Sandy McCarthy Autograph #C-99 at $5.93 as of October 22, 2026.
By Ripbin Research · Updated 2026-10-22 · prices from live market data
See all Sandy McCarthy cards & valuesShop Sandy McCarthy cards on eBay
Affiliate — we may earn a commissionThe 10 most valuable Sandy McCarthy cards in the Ripbin catalog (1991–2020) carry a combined raw market value of $38.10, topped by a $5.93 card.
Just missed the cut
- #11 1996 Upper Deck Sandy McCarthy #23$1.45
- #12 1993 Parkhurst Sandy Mccarthy #30$1.33
- #13 1993 Parkhurst Sandy McCarthy Emerald Ice #30$1.16
- #14 1993 Upper Deck Sandy McCarthy #493$1.13
- #15 2000 Topps Heritage Sandy McCarthy #178$1.10
- #16 2020-21 SP Signature Edition Legends UD Canvas Legends Sandy McCarthy #C-99$0.99
- #17 1999 Be a Player Millennium Sandy McCarthy Autograph Gold #184$0.99
- #18 1998 Be a Player Sandy McCarthy Autograph #282$0.99
- #19 1991 Upper Deck Sandy McCarthy #77$0.73
- #20 1996 Collector's Choice Sandy McCarthy #43$0.47
Sets in this guide
More Hockey guides
Most Valuable Connor Mcdavid CardsMost Valuable Sidney Crosby CardsMost Valuable Alex Ovechkin CardsMost Valuable Tanner Laczynski CardsMost Valuable Jaxson Stauber CardsMost Valuable Dino Ciccarelli CardsMost Valuable Cole Koepke CardsMost Valuable Gary Roberts CardsMost Valuable Seamus Casey CardsMost Valuable Jakub Lauko Cards