The 10 Most Valuable New York City FC Cards
The most valuable New York City FC card is the 2024 Topps Now MLS New York City FC Gold #155 at $53.00 as of October 23, 2026.
By Ripbin Research · Updated 2026-10-23 · prices from live market data
See all New York City FC cards & valuesShop New York City FC cards on eBay
Affiliate — we may earn a commissionThe 10 most valuable New York City FC cards in the Ripbin catalog (2017–2025) carry a combined raw market value of $170.54, topped by a $53.00 card.
Just missed the cut
- #11 2018 Topps MLS New York City FC Blue #190$5.99
- #12 2024 Topps Now MLS New York City FC #139$5.50
- #13 2021 Topps MLS New York City FC Blue #143$4.95
- #14 2025 Topps MLS 30th Anniversary Decades of Honor New York City FC #DOH-26$4.49
- #15 2016 Topps MLS New York City FC Blue #190$4.00
- #16 2021 Topps MLS New York City FC Icy Blue Foil #143$3.64
- #17 2024 Topps Now MLS New York City FC Orange #139$3.25
- #18 2024 Topps Now MLS New York City FC Orange #155$3.25
- #19 2020 Topps MLS New York City FC Blue #140$3.23
- #20 2019 Topps MLS New York City FC Blue #189$2.58
Sets in this guide
More Soccer guides
Most Valuable Erling Haaland CardsMost Valuable Lionel Messi CardsMost Valuable Kevin De Bruyne CardsMost Valuable Wojciech Szczesny CardsMost Valuable Kevin Trapp CardsMost Valuable Julio Enciso CardsMost Valuable Liam Delap CardsMost Valuable Joe Scally CardsMost Valuable Rayan Cherki CardsMost Valuable Rose Lavelle Cards