The 10 Most Valuable Jim McMahon Cards
The most valuable Jim McMahon card is the 2023 Panini One Once Upon a Time Signatures Jim McMahon Gold Once Upon a Time Signature #331 at $115.00 as of October 14, 2026.
By Ripbin Research · Updated 2026-10-14 · prices from live market data
Shop Jim McMahon cards on eBay
Affiliate — we may earn a commissionThe 10 most valuable Jim McMahon cards in the Ripbin catalog (2023) carry a combined raw market value of $623.75, topped by a $115.00 card.
Just missed the cut
- #11 2023 Panini Select Base Set Jim McMahon Zebra Prizm #318$33.75
- #12 2023 Panini Select Base Set Jim McMahon Gold Prizm #318$30.50
- #13 2025 Panini Silhouette Framed Signatures Jim McMahon #3$30.00
- #14 2023 Topps Composite Resurgence Signatures Set Jim McMahon #RA-JM$23.72
- #15 2024 Panini National Treasures NFL Game Gear Jim McMahon #10$22.34
- #16 2023 Panini Select Base Set Jim McMahon Cosmic #318$20.50
- #17 2023 Panini Select Base Set Jim McMahon Dragon Scale Prizm #318$17.43
- #18 2025 Panini Immaculate Championship Memorabilia Jim McMahon #37$13.50
- #19 2024 Panini Immaculate Collection Championship Memorabilia Jim McMahon #36$13.49
- #20 2023 Panini Select Base Set Jim McMahon Tie-Dye Prizm #318$12.00
More Football guides
Most Valuable Patrick Mahomes Ii CardsMost Valuable Josh Allen CardsMost Valuable Justin Herbert CardsMost Valuable Joe Burrow CardsMost Valuable Justin Jefferson CardsMost Valuable Lamar Jackson CardsMost Valuable Jalen Hurts CardsMost Valuable Trevor Lawrence CardsMost Valuable Aaron Rodgers CardsMost Valuable Tom Brady Cards