The 10 Most Valuable Jay Payton Cards
The most valuable Jay Payton card is the 2005 Topps Base Set Jay Payton Black #616 at $19.99 as of October 22, 2026.
By Ripbin Research · Updated 2026-10-22 · prices from live market data
See all Jay Payton cards & valuesShop Jay Payton cards on eBay
Affiliate — we may earn a commissionThe 10 most valuable Jay Payton cards in the Ripbin catalog (1996–2007) carry a combined raw market value of $60.38, topped by a $19.99 card.
Just missed the cut
- #11 2007 Upper Deck Jay Payton Predictor Silver #568$3.41
- #12 2003 Donruss Diamond Kings Jay Payton Framed Silver Foil #98$2.99
- #13 2005 Donruss Team Heroes Jay Payton #263$2.70
- #14 2003 Topps Heritage Jay Payton #397$2.69
- #15 2003 Donruss Diamond Kings Jay Payton Framed Bronze Foil #98$2.49
- #16 2004 Fleer Authentix Jay Payton #43$2.49
- #17 2008 Topps Jay Payton #438$2.37
- #18 1994 Signature Rookies Draft Picks Jay Payton$2.33
- #19 2006 Fleer Jay Payton Silver #36$2.25
- #20 2001 Finest Autographs Jay Payton #JP$2.07
Sets in this guide
More Baseball guides
Most Valuable Shohei Ohtani CardsMost Valuable Aaron Judge CardsMost Valuable Mike Trout CardsMost Valuable Seaver King CardsMost Valuable Angel Martinez CardsMost Valuable Trevor Hoffman CardsMost Valuable Harmon Killebrew CardsMost Valuable Nolan Jones CardsMost Valuable Kyle Hendricks CardsMost Valuable Al Kaline Cards