The 10 Most Valuable Jay Hilgenberg Cards
The most valuable Jay Hilgenberg card is the 2025 Topps Signature Class Preeminent Ink Jay Hilgenberg Orange #PI-JHI at $35.00 as of October 20, 2026.
By Ripbin Research · Updated 2026-10-20 · prices from live market data
See all Jay Hilgenberg cards & valuesShop Jay Hilgenberg cards on eBay
Affiliate — we may earn a commissionThe 10 most valuable Jay Hilgenberg cards in the Ripbin catalog (1985–2025) carry a combined raw market value of $117.77, topped by a $35.00 card.
#101986 McDonald's Bears Jay Hilgenberg Green #63
$3.95PSA 10 ~$99.99
Just missed the cut
- #11 1990 Panini Sticker Jay Hilgenberg #191$3.25
- #12 1990 Panini Sticker Jay Hilgenberg #225$3.25
- #13 1988 Panini Sticker Jay Hilgenberg #254$2.65
- #14 1992 Pro Set Jay Hilgenberg #122$2.11
- #15 1992 Fleer Jay Hilgenberg #41$2.08
- #16 1993 Panini Score Jay Hilgenberg #245$2.05
- #17 1986 Topps Jay Hilgenberg #17$2.00
- #18 1992 Pacific Jay Hilgenberg #31$1.89
- #19 1993 Action Packed All Madden Jay Hilgenberg #15$1.89
- #20 1992 Pro Set Jay Hilgenberg #465$1.51
Sets in this guide
More Football guides
Most Valuable Patrick Mahomes Ii CardsMost Valuable Josh Allen CardsMost Valuable Tom Brady CardsMost Valuable Larry Rountree Iii CardsMost Valuable Carson Steele CardsMost Valuable Greg Newsome Ii CardsMost Valuable Eric Allen CardsMost Valuable Kendall Wright CardsMost Valuable Tony Banks CardsMost Valuable Tyleik Williams Cards