The 10 Most Valuable Jay Cutler Cards
The most valuable Jay Cutler card is the 2012 Panini Prizm Jay Cutler Finite #35 at $12,107.00 as of October 20, 2026.
By Ripbin Research · Updated 2026-10-20 · prices from live market data
See all Jay Cutler cards & valuesShop Jay Cutler cards on eBay
Affiliate — we may earn a commissionThe 10 most valuable Jay Cutler cards in the Ripbin catalog (2006–2015) carry a combined raw market value of $13,809.01, topped by a $12,107.00 card.
#42012 Panini Prizm Jay Cutler Gold Prizm #35
$332.01PSA 10 ~$2,000.00
#62007 Bowman Chrome Jay Cutler Orange Refractor #BC170
$100.00PSA 10 ~$49.95
Just missed the cut
- #11 2014 Panini National Treasures Jay Cutler Century Black #6$66.54
- #12 2012 Panini Absolute Jay Cutler Spectrum Platinum Autograph #51$65.23
- #13 2017 Panini Contenders Optic Jay Cutler Gold #83$58.99
- #14 2014 Topps Chrome Mini Jay Cutler Gold Refractor #58$53.43
- #15 2006 Topps Heritage Chrome Jay Cutler Black Refractor #THC64$51.99
- #16 2012 Panini Absolute Jay Cutler Spectrum Gold Autograph #51$50.00
- #17 2016 Panini Donruss Optic Gridiron Kings Jay Cutler Green #35$42.50
- #18 2015 Panini Flawless Jay Cutler #9$40.00
- #19 2015 Panini National Treasures Jay Cutler Jersey Number Red #2$40.00
- #20 2017 Panini National Treasures Jay Cutler Emerald #50$39.99
Sets in this guide
More Football guides
Most Valuable Josh Allen CardsMost Valuable Patrick Mahomes Ii CardsMost Valuable Tom Brady CardsMost Valuable Bradley Chubb CardsMost Valuable Tez Johnson CardsMost Valuable Vernon Davis CardsMost Valuable Terrance Ferguson CardsMost Valuable Alshon Jeffery CardsMost Valuable Dalton Schultz CardsMost Valuable Trey Hendrickson Cards