The 10 Most Valuable 2004 Topps Total Football Cards
The most valuable 2004 Topps Total Football card is the 2004 Topps Total Sean Taylor Silver #363 at $18.58 as of October 20, 2026.
By Ripbin Research · Updated 2026-10-20 · prices from live market data
Shop 2004 Topps Total Football cards on eBay
Affiliate — we may earn a commissionThe 10 most valuable 2004 Topps Total Football cards in the Ripbin catalog carry a combined raw market value of $120.77, topped by a $18.58 card.
#12004 Topps Total Sean Taylor Silver #363
$18.58PSA 10 ~$149.48#22004 Topps Total Eli Manning First Edition #350
$15.99PSA 10 ~$96.00#32004 Topps Total Ben Roethlisberger Silver #375
$14.60PSA 10 ~$143.50#42004 Topps Total Tom Brady First Edition #200
$11.32PSA 10 ~$68.00#102004 Topps Total Larry Fitzgerald Silver #400
$8.87PSA 10 ~$105.64
Just missed the cut
- #11 2004 Topps Total Ben Roethlisberger #375$7.38
- #12 2004 Topps Total Ben Roethlisberger First Edition #375$7.07
- #13 2004 Topps Total Sean Taylor #363$7.03
- #14 2004 Topps Total John Lynch, Nick Ferguson, Kelly Herndon Silver #313$6.58
- #15 2004 Topps Total Troy Polamalu, Mike Logan #244$6.51
- #16 2004 Topps Total Sean Taylor First Edition #363$6.32
- #17 2004 Topps Total Shelton Quarles, Ellis Wyms, Ryan Nece Silver #304$6.29
- #18 2004 Topps Total Al Harris, Mark Roman, Mike McKenzie Silver #315$6.12
- #19 2004 Topps Total Kevin Faulk #97$5.99
- #20 2004 Topps Total Brian Dawkins, Michael Lewis Silver #274$5.69
Players in this guide
Sean Taylor cardsEli Manning cardsBen Roethlisberger cardsTom Brady cardsWill Witherspoon, Dan Morgan, Mark Fields cardsTroy Polamalu, Mike Logan cardsDrew Brees cardsRoy Williams cardsLarry Fitzgerald cardsJohn Lynch, Nick Ferguson, Kelly Herndon cardsShelton Quarles, Ellis Wyms, Ryan Nece cardsAl Harris, Mark Roman, Mike McKenzie cards
More Football guides
Most Valuable Brett Favre CardsMost Valuable Tom Brady CardsMost Valuable Peyton Manning CardsMost Valuable Erik Ezukanma CardsMost Valuable Marquez Stevenson CardsMost Valuable Danny Gray CardsMost Valuable Hunter Long CardsMost Valuable Demeco Ryans CardsMost Valuable Hayden Hurst CardsMost Valuable Shonn Greene Cards