The 10 Most Valuable Buffalo Bills Cards
The most valuable Buffalo Bills card is the 1961 Topps Stickers Buffalo Bills #I at $200.00 as of October 20, 2026.
By Ripbin Research · Updated 2026-10-20 · prices from live market data
See all Buffalo Bills cards & valuesShop Buffalo Bills cards on eBay
Affiliate — we may earn a commissionThe 10 most valuable Buffalo Bills cards in the Ripbin catalog (1960–2004) carry a combined raw market value of $355.77, topped by a $200.00 card.
#101979 Fleer Team Action Sticker Buffalo Bills Logo
$3.71PSA 10 ~$34.50
Just missed the cut
- #11 2015 Topps Buffalo Bills Pink #247$3.42
- #12 1989 Panini Sticker Buffalo Bills Logo Foil #224$3.25
- #13 2020 Panini NFL Stickers Buffalo Bills #37$2.86
- #14 1974 Topps Team Checklists Buffalo Bills$2.82
- #15 1979 Fleer Team Action Sticker Buffalo Bills Helmet$2.78
- #16 1978 Fleer Team Action Buffalo Bills Daylight Breakers #5$2.50
- #17 1980 Fleer Team Action Buffalo Bills You Block for Me, I'll... #5$1.99
- #18 1980 Fleer Team Action Buffalo Bills Stand 'EM Up and... #6$1.89
- #19 1976 Topps Buffalo Bills #453$1.80
- #20 1982 Fleer Team Action Buffalo Bills Point of Attack #5$1.75
Sets in this guide
More Football guides
Most Valuable Brett Favre CardsMost Valuable Tom Brady CardsMost Valuable Peyton Manning CardsMost Valuable Bernie Kosar CardsMost Valuable Eric Decker CardsMost Valuable Adam Vinatieri CardsMost Valuable Patrick Peterson CardsMost Valuable Rob Moore CardsMost Valuable Fran Tarkenton CardsMost Valuable Eddie Kennison Cards