The 6 Most Valuable Bill Mathis Cards

The most valuable Bill Mathis card is the 1962 Fleer Bill Mathis #62 at $8.97 as of October 20, 2026.

By Ripbin Research · Updated 2026-10-20 · prices from live market data

See all Bill Mathis cards & values

Shop Bill Mathis cards on eBay

Affiliate — we may earn a commission

The 6 most valuable Bill Mathis cards in the Ripbin catalog (1960–1967) carry a combined raw market value of $29.99, topped by a $8.97 card.

#11962 Fleer Bill Mathis #62
$8.97PSA 10 ~$1,090.46
Full price guide →See eBay listings ↗
#21963 Fleer Bill Mathis #12
$6.31PSA 10 ~$1,099.24
Full price guide →See eBay listings ↗
#31964 Topps Bill Mathis #120
$4.65PSA 10 ~$777.16
Full price guide →See eBay listings ↗
#41967 Topps Bill Mathis #96
$4.44PSA 10 ~$688.93
Full price guide →See eBay listings ↗
#51966 Topps Bill Mathis #94
$3.97PSA 10 ~$596.07
Full price guide →See eBay listings ↗
#61960 Fleer Bill Mathis #99
$1.65PSA 10 ~$340.80
Full price guide →See eBay listings ↗

Sets in this guide

1962 Fleer 1963 Fleer 1964 Topps 1967 Topps 1966 Topps 1960 Fleer

More Football guides

Most Valuable Brett Favre Cards Most Valuable Tom Brady Cards Most Valuable Peyton Manning Cards Most Valuable Lance Briggs Cards Most Valuable Jaheim Bell Cards Most Valuable Case Keenum Cards Most Valuable Desmond Howard Cards Most Valuable Nik Bonitto Cards Most Valuable Xavier Mckinney Cards Most Valuable Sam Leavitt Cards

All Bill Mathis cards & values →Card investing reports →

Bill Mathis Football cards most valuable cards card values price guide

More Bill Mathis cards on eBay

Affiliate — we may earn a commission