The 10 Most Valuable 1995 Finest Mystery Basketball Cards
The most valuable 1995 Finest Mystery Basketball card is the 1995 Finest Mystery Michael Jordan Orange Bordered Refractor #M1 at $1,799.99 as of October 19, 2026.
By Ripbin Research · Updated 2026-10-19 · prices from live market data
Shop 1995 Finest Mystery Basketball cards on eBay
Affiliate — we may earn a commissionThe 10 most valuable 1995 Finest Mystery Basketball cards in the Ripbin catalog carry a combined raw market value of $3,999.64, topped by a $1,799.99 card.
#11995 Finest Mystery Michael Jordan Orange Bordered Refractor #M1
$1,799.99PSA 10 ~$6,589.00
#21995 Finest Mystery Michael Jordan Borderless Refractor #M1
$1,134.69PSA 10 ~$5,017.50#31995 Finest Mystery Michael Jordan Borderless #M1
$231.50PSA 10 ~$818.02
#41995 Finest Mystery Shaquille O'Neal Borderless Refractor #M22
$217.50PSA 10 ~$6,766.03
#51995 Finest Mystery Michael Jordan Unpeeled #M1
$201.55PSA 10 ~$6,314.68
#71995 Finest Mystery Michael Jordan Orange Bordered #M1
$99.95PSA 10 ~$624.50
Just missed the cut
- #11 1995 Finest Mystery Shawn Kemp Borderless Refractor #M4$41.22
- #12 1995 Finest Mystery Scottie Pippen Borderless Refractor #M15$41.00
- #13 1995 Finest Mystery Shawn Kemp Orange Border Refractor Test Issue #M4$40.00
- #14 1995 Finest Mystery Shaquille O'Neal Orange Border Refractor Test Issue #M22$37.23
- #15 1995 Finest Mystery Reggie Miller Borderless Refractor #M14$36.49
- #16 1995 Finest Mystery Grant Hill Borderless Refractor #M2$36.00
- #17 1995 Finest Mystery Charles Barkley Borderless Refractor #M6$30.99
- #18 1995 Finest Mystery Scottie Pippen Orange Border Refractor Test Issue #M15$25.00
- #19 1995 Finest Mystery Shaquille O'Neal Borderless #M22$20.50
- #20 1995 Finest Mystery Hakeem Olajuwon Orange Border Refractor Test Issue #M21$20.10
Players in this guide
More Basketball guides
Most Valuable Lebron James CardsMost Valuable Stephen Curry CardsMost Valuable Giannis Antetokounmpo CardsMost Valuable Markelle Fultz CardsMost Valuable Dyson Daniels CardsMost Valuable Anfernee Hardaway CardsMost Valuable Victor Oladipo CardsMost Valuable Cam Reddish CardsMost Valuable Eric Gordon CardsMost Valuable Luguentz Dort Cards