Matthew Schaefer Rookie Cards: Values & Price Guide
By Ripbin Research · Updated 2026-06-17 · prices from live market data
The most valuable Matthew Schaefer rookie card is the 2026 2025 Upper Deck Series 2 Population Count Matthew Schaefer #PC-37, worth about $2,539.80. The top 10 are worth roughly $5,616.63 combined.
Rookie cards are where collections start and where the biggest premiums live. This guide ranks Matthew Schaefer's earliest-year cards by value, beginning with the 2026 issues — every price pulled from current market data.
Prices below are for raw copies (top of the list: ~$2,539.80); click through any card for its full PSA/BGS/CGC/SGC grade ladder.
#12026 2025 Upper Deck Series 2 Population Count Matthew Schaefer #PC-37
$2,539.80PSA 10 ~$11,781.91At $2,539.80 ungraded, this is the card collectors hunt first. Graded gem-mint copies jump to roughly $11,781.91 — a 4.6× premium that rewards pristine examples. The 10 parallel is the version driving this price.
#22026 2025 Upper Deck Allure Matthew Schaefer #AR-MS
$750.00PSA 10 ~$3,412.40Valued around $750.00 ungraded. In PSA 10 it's a different card — around $3,412.40. The Extended Rookie Blue Line Autograph parallel is the version driving this price.
#32026 2025 Upper Deck Allure Matthew Schaefer #AR-MS
$591.49PSA 10 ~$2,694.17Valued around $591.49 ungraded. In PSA 10 it's a different card — around $2,694.17. The Extended Rookie Red Rainbow Autograph parallel is the version driving this price.
#42026 2025 Upper Deck Allure Matthew Schaefer #AR-MS
$416.11PSA 10 ~$1,907.27Valued around $416.11 ungraded. In PSA 10 it's a different card — around $1,907.27. The Blue Line Extended Rookie parallel is the version driving this price.
#52026 2025 O-Pee-Chee 3-D Marquee Rookie Matthew Schaefer #3D-MS
$347.93PSA 10 ~$1,608.76Raw copies trade near $347.93. A PSA 10 changes the math entirely: about $1,608.76.
#62026 2025 O-Pee-Chee Matthew Schaefer #592
$235.38PSA 10 ~$1,163.04Expect to pay about $235.38 for an ungraded example. Graded gem-mint copies jump to roughly $1,163.04 — a 4.9× premium that rewards pristine examples. This is the Rainbow Foil Black — scarcer than the base and priced accordingly.
#72026 2025 O-Pee-Chee Matthew Schaefer #592
$220.99PSA 10 ~$1,116.99Expect to pay about $220.99 for an ungraded example. Graded gem-mint copies jump to roughly $1,116.99 — a 5.1× premium that rewards pristine examples. This is the Retro Black Border — scarcer than the base and priced accordingly.
#82025 Upper Deck Black Diamond Rookie Team Logo Jumbo Puzzle Patch Matthew Schaefer #RTL-MS
$216.39PSA 10 ~$975.57Raw copies trade near $216.39. In PSA 10 it's a different card — around $975.57.
- 🃏
#92025 Upper Deck Black Diamond Auto Rookie Team Logo Jumbo Patch Full Logo 1 Matthew Schaefer #RTL-MS
$208.70PSA 10 ~$956.34Currently around $208.70 in raw condition. In PSA 10 it's a different card — around $956.34.
#102026 2025 SP Authentic Matthew Schaefer #111
$89.84PSA 10 ~$444.79Raw copies trade near $89.84. In PSA 10 it's a different card — around $444.79. This is the Patterned Foilboard Gold Authentics — scarcer than the base and priced accordingly.
Market snapshot
The top 10 Matthew Schaefer cards are worth a combined $5,616.63 in raw condition, and where graded data exists, PSA 10 copies average about 4.7× the raw price — condition is doing real work in this market. 9 of the top 10 clear the $100.00 mark. Values move with the market — each card page above tracks current prices and live listings.
Just missed the cut
- #11 2026 2025 O-Pee-Chee Matthew Schaefer #592$84.99
- #12 2026 Upper Deck National Hockey Card Day UD Victory Black Rookie Matthew Schaefer #V-9$49.99
- #13 2026 2025 SP Game Used Authentic Rookies Matthew Schaefer #AR-MS$43.20
- #14 2026 2025 O-Pee-Chee Matthew Schaefer #592$41.50
- #15 2026 2025 O-Pee-Chee Matthew Schaefer #592$28.72
- #16 2026 2025 O-Pee-Chee Premier Matthew Schaefer #P-92$27.34
- #17 2025 Upper Deck MVP Matthew Schaefer #275$25.00
- #18 2026 2025 SP Game Used Authentic Rookies Matthew Schaefer #AR-MS$24.24
- #19 2026 2025 Upper Deck Allure Matthew Schaefer #AR-MS$24.00
- #20 2026 2025 Upper Deck Series 2 Dazzlers Matthew Schaefer #DZ-57$22.72
Frequently asked questions
- What is the most valuable Matthew Schaefer rookie card?
- The 2026 2025 Upper Deck Series 2 Population Count Matthew Schaefer #PC-37 tops the list at around $2,539.80 ungraded — graded copies sell for more.
- Are Matthew Schaefer cards worth money?
- Yes — the top 10 Matthew Schaefer cards alone are worth about $5,616.63 combined in raw condition, and gem-mint graded copies average roughly 4.7× the raw price.
- Where can I sell Matthew Schaefer cards?
- eBay is the most liquid market — each card above links to live listings. You can also scan your cards with Ripbin to track values and receive bids from collectors.