Josh Phelps card values & price guide

Josh Phelps has 91 cards tracked; the most valuable is the 2002 Justifiable Josh Phelps Gold #31 at $14.34 as of October 22, 2026.

91 cards · 49 sets · 2000–2007

Josh Phelps career

First baseman

Josh Phelps is a first baseman, born May 12, 1978.

Born: May 12, 1978

Teams

Cleveland Guardians, Memphis Redbirds, New York Yankees, Pittsburgh Pirates, St. Louis Cardinals, Toledo Mud Hens, Toronto Blue Jays

Facts from Wikidata

Prices last updated Oct 2026

Cards tracked

Highest value

$14.34

Value range

$0–$14

Median value

PSA 10 avg

$35

With recorded sales

Most valuable Josh Phelps cards

Top 10 by value

#	Card	Value	Shop
1	2002 Justifiable · Gold#31	$14.34	eBay ↗
2	2003 Flair#19	$6.46	eBay ↗
3	2002 Donruss Classics · Timeless Tributes#123	$4.20	eBay ↗
4	2002 Justifiable · Silver#31	$3.41	eBay ↗
5	2003 Leaf#120	$2.35	eBay ↗
6	2002 Donruss Elite#178	$1.79	eBay ↗
7	2007 Topps#515	$1.74	eBay ↗
8	2003 Donruss Elite Back to the Future Threads#BF-10	$1.66	eBay ↗
9	2003 Fleer Double Header#79	$1.55	eBay ↗
10	2007 Topps · Red Back#515	$1.49	eBay ↗

By price

Affordable under $2536 cards

All prices

Card	Year	Value
2002 Justifiable · Gold#31	2002	$14.34
2003 Flair#19	2003	$6.46
2002 Donruss Classics · Timeless Tributes#123	2002	$4.20
2002 Justifiable · Silver#31	2002	$3.41
2003 Leaf#120	2003	$2.35
2002 Donruss Elite#178	2002	$1.79
2007 Topps#515	2007	$1.74
2003 Donruss Elite Back to the Future Threads#BF-10	2003	$1.66
2003 Fleer Double Header#79	2003	$1.55
2007 Topps · Red Back#515	2007	$1.49
2007 Upper Deck#848	2007	$0.99
2007 Topps · Gold#515	2007	$0.99
2005 Donruss#368	2005	$0.99
2002 Bowman Chrome#341	2002	$0.89
2001 Upper Deck#7	2001	$0.78

Show all 60 cards in this table

2003 Upper Deck Victory#98	2003	$0.50
2003 Fleer Tradition#468	2003	$0.25
2003 Bowman#78	2003	$0.25
2003 Upper Deck#291	2003	$0.25
2002 Upper Deck Base Set#560	2002	$0.25
2002 Upper Deck Ovation#148	2002	$0.25
2003 Upper Deck MVP#213	2003	$0.25
2003 Upper Deck Patch Collection#117	2003	$0.25
2001 Donruss Rookies#R69	2001	$0.25
2004 Fleer Tradition#347	2004	$0.25
2004 Donruss Studio#198	2004	$0.25
2004 Donruss Throwback Threads#197	2004	$0.25
2005 Upper Deck#411	2005	$0.25
2002 Justifiable#31	2002	$0.25
2002 Fleer Tradition Update#U103	2002	$0.25
2003 Fleer Patchworks#86	2003	$0.25
2002 Bowman#409	2002	$0.25
2004 Upper Deck#48	2004	$0.25
2003 Donruss Team Heroes#534	2003	$0.25
2003 Donruss#225	2003	$0.01
2003 Upper Deck Vintage#26	2003	$0.01
2007 Topps · Platinum#515	2007	—
2007 Topps · Printing Plate#515	2007	—
2002 Justifiable · Black#31	2002	—
2005 Flair Cuts and Glory · Jersey#CGR-JP	2005	—
2003 Bowman Chrome#78	2003	—
2003 Bowman Chrome · Gold Refractor#78	2003	—
2003 Bowman Chrome · Refractor#78	2003	—
2003 Bowman Chrome · Xfractor#78	2003	—
2003 Donruss · Career Stat Line#225	2003	—
2003 Donruss · Season Stat Line#225	2003	—
2004 Donruss Classics#78	2004	—
2002 Fleer#386	2002	—
2002 Fleer · Gold Back#386	2002	—
2003 Fleer Patchworks · Star Ruby#86	2003	—
2005 Flair Cuts and Glory · Logo#CGR-JP	2005	—
2007 Upper Deck · Predictor Silver#848	2007	—
2007 Upper Deck · Printing Plate#848	2007	—
2001 Upper Deck · Exclusives Gold#7	2001	—
2001 Upper Deck · Exclusives#7	2001	—
2004 Upper Deck · High Gloss#48	2004	—
2004 Donruss Studio Players Collection Jersey#PC-45	2004	—
2004 Donruss Studio Players Collection Jersey · Platinum#PC-45	2004	—
2005 Topps Total Base Set#537	2005	—
2001 Pacific · Extreme LTD#500	2000	—

Showing the top 60 of 91 cards. View all Josh Phelps card prices (91 cards) →

By year

Year	Cards	Top card	Value
2007	11	2007 Topps #515	$1.74
2005	12	2005 Donruss #368	$0.99
2004	20	2004 Fleer Tradition #347	$0.25
2003	21	2003 Flair #19	$6.46
2002	18	2002 Justifiable #31	$14.34
2001	4	2001 Upper Deck #7	$0.78
2000	5	—	—

Live eBay listings

Affiliate — we may earn a commission

Most Valuable Josh Phelps Cards Most Valuable Shohei Ohtani Cards Most Valuable Aaron Judge Cards Most Valuable Mike Trout Cards Most Valuable Scott Kingery Cards Most Valuable Benito Santiago Cards Most Valuable Luke Williams Cards

More Baseball players

Shohei Ohtani cards Aaron Judge cards Mike Trout cards Scott Kingery cards Benito Santiago cards Luke Williams cards Travis Fryman cards Connor Phillips cards Shannon Stewart cards Griffin Conine cards Max Schuemann cards Logan Allen cards

Frequently asked questions

How much more is a PSA 10 Josh Phelps card worth?: Across Josh Phelps cards we track with both raw and PSA 10 prices, a PSA 10 sells for roughly 32.4× the ungraded price, averaging about $35. Grading pristine copies can pay off — check each card's grade ladder first.