Carl Pavano card values & price guide

Carl Pavano has 180 cards tracked; the most valuable is the 2005 Donruss Classics Carl Pavano Timeless Tributes Gold #195 at $5.00 as of October 22, 2026.

180 cards · 91 sets · 1996–2025

Carl Pavano career

Pitcher

Carl Pavano is a pitcher, born January 8, 1976.

Born: January 8, 1976

Teams

Cleveland Guardians, Gulf Coast League Yankees, Minnesota Twins, Montreal Expos, New York Yankees, Trenton Thunder

Facts from Wikidata

Prices last updated Oct 2026

Cards tracked

180

Highest value

$5.00

Value range

$0–$5

Median value

PSA 10 avg

$43

With recorded sales

Most valuable Carl Pavano cards

Top 10 by value

#	Card	Value	Shop
1	2005 Donruss Classics · Timeless Tributes Gold#195	$5.00	eBay ↗
2	1998 Bowman Chrome International · Refractor#437	$4.84	eBay ↗
3	2005 Donruss Studio · Proof Silver#189	$4.00	eBay ↗
4	2001 Fleer Platinum · Platinum Edition#211	$2.99	eBay ↗
5	1997 Bowman Chrome · Refractor#159	$2.84	eBay ↗
6	1997 Bowman Chrome International · Refractor#159	$2.80	eBay ↗
7	1998 Team Best Autograph	$2.74	eBay ↗
8	2007 Upper Deck · Predictor Silver#838	$2.44	eBay ↗
9	2005 Leaf Limited · Gold#51	$2.27	eBay ↗
10	1997 Bowman Chrome#159	$2.25	eBay ↗

By price

Affordable under $2560 cards

All prices

Card	Year	Value
2005 Donruss Classics · Timeless Tributes Gold#195	2005	$5.00
1998 Bowman Chrome International · Refractor#437	1998	$4.84
2005 Donruss Studio · Proof Silver#189	2005	$4.00
2001 Fleer Platinum · Platinum Edition#211	2001	$2.99
1997 Bowman Chrome · Refractor#159	1997	$2.84
1997 Bowman Chrome International · Refractor#159	1997	$2.80
1998 Team Best Autograph	1998	$2.74
2007 Upper Deck · Predictor Silver#838	2007	$2.44
2005 Leaf Limited · Gold#51	2005	$2.27
1997 Bowman Chrome#159	1997	$2.25
1998 Donruss Signature Millennium Marks	1998	$2.25
2005 Donruss Classics · Timeless Tributes Silver#195	2005	$2.06
2005 Finest · Green Xfractor#12	2005	$2.01
1998 Upper Deck Base Set#541	1998	$1.99
1996 Bowman#259	1996	$1.88

Show all 60 cards in this table

2005 Fleer Authentix#43	2005	$1.85
1997 Bowman's Best · Refractor#120	1997	$1.79
2001 Upper Deck#200	2001	$1.75
2005 Leaf#77	2005	$1.69
2007 Upper Deck#838	2007	$1.66
2004 Upper Deck#350	2004	$1.59
1997 Bowman's Best · Atomic Refractor#120	1997	$1.50
1998 Leaf Rookies & Stars Freshman Orientation#8	1998	$1.49
1997 Bowman#161	1997	$1.49
2005 Finest · Blue Xfractor#12	2005	$1.49
2007 Topps#352	2007	$1.49
1998 Donruss#345	1998	$1.45
2005 Upper Deck ESPN#32	2005	$1.42
1998 Bowman's Best#111	1998	$1.25
1998 Bowman Chrome#437	1998	$1.20
2005 Fleer Tradition#201	2005	$1.12
2000 Fleer Tradition#290	2000	$1.11
2005 Leaf Limited#51	2005	$1.05
1998 Pinnacle Plus#34	1998	$0.99
1998 Stadium Club#354	1998	$0.99
1998 Donruss Signature#101	1998	$0.99
1998 Donruss · Gold Press Proof#345	1998	$0.75
1998 Donruss Preferred#162	1998	$0.65
1998 Pinnacle Performers#134	1998	$0.25
1998 Bowman#437	1998	$0.25
2001 Fleer Platinum#211	2001	$0.25
2005 Leaf Limited · Bronze#51	2005	$0.25
2005 Donruss Studio#189	2005	$0.25
1999 Pacific Aurora#114	1999	$0.25
1998 Score Rookie Traded#238	1998	$0.25
2001 Fleer Triple Crown#198	2001	$0.25
2005 Donruss Classics#195	2005	$0.25
2000 Fleer Focus#216	2000	$0.25
1999 Pacific#268	1999	$0.25
1999 Upper Deck Black Diamond · Triple#108	1999	$0.25
1999 Upper Deck Black Diamond · Double#108	1999	$0.25
2005 Donruss Team Heroes#373	2005	$0.25
2001 Fleer Focus#149	2001	$0.25
2001 Upper Deck MVP#234	2001	$0.25
2001 Upper Deck Victory#389	2001	$0.25
2001 Upper Deck Vintage#251	2001	$0.25
1999 Upper Deck Black Diamond#108	1999	$0.20
1998 Score Rookie Traded#RT238	1998	$0.10
1998 Collector's Choice#415	1998	$0.01
2001 Fleer Tradition#233	2001	$0.01

Showing the top 60 of 180 cards. View all Carl Pavano card prices (180 cards) →

By year

Year	Cards	Top card	Value
2025	2	—	—
2012	4	—	—
2011	10	—	—
2010	11	—	—
2009	14	—	—
2008	6	—	—
2007	10	2007 Upper Deck #838	$2.44
2006	5	—	—
2005	32	2005 Donruss Classics #195	$5.00
2004	5	2004 Upper Deck #350	$1.59
2003	4	—	—
2002	8	—	—
2001	16	2001 Fleer Platinum #211	$2.99
2000	4	2000 Fleer Tradition #290	$1.11
1999	11	1999 Pacific Aurora #114	$0.25
1998	29	1998 Bowman Chrome International #437	$4.84
1997	8	1997 Bowman Chrome #159	$2.84
1996	1	1996 Bowman #259	$1.88

Live eBay listings

Affiliate — we may earn a commission

Most Valuable Carl Pavano Cards Most Valuable Shohei Ohtani Cards Most Valuable Aaron Judge Cards Most Valuable Mike Trout Cards Most Valuable Javy Lopez Cards Most Valuable Tanner Bibee Cards Most Valuable Carson Whisenhunt Cards

More Baseball players

Shohei Ohtani cards Aaron Judge cards Mike Trout cards Javy Lopez cards Tanner Bibee cards Carson Whisenhunt cards Phil Niekro cards Seth Hernandez cards Owen White cards Jordan Groshans cards Masahiro Tanaka cards Jhoan Duran cards

Frequently asked questions

How much more is a PSA 10 Carl Pavano card worth?: Across Carl Pavano cards we track with both raw and PSA 10 prices, a PSA 10 sells for roughly 103.1× the ungraded price, averaging about $43. Grading pristine copies can pay off — check each card's grade ladder first.