Billy Butler card values & price guide

Billy Butler has 300 cards tracked; the most valuable is the 2012 Panini Prizm Billy Butler Gold #78 at $250.00 as of October 22, 2026.

300 cards · 91 sets · 2004–2024

Prices last updated Oct 2026

Cards tracked

300

Highest value

$250.00

Value range

$0–$250

Median value

PSA 10 avg

$32

With recorded sales

Most valuable Billy Butler cards

Top 10 by value

#	Card	Value	Shop
1	2012 Panini Prizm · Gold#78	$250.00	eBay ↗
2	2007 SP Authentic · Letter Patch Autograph#137	$22.49	eBay ↗
3	2007 Bowman Sterling · Black Refractor#BS-BB	$21.24	eBay ↗
4	2005 Bowman Chrome · Autograph Blue Refractor#353	$20.25	eBay ↗
5	2005 Bowman Sterling · Black Refractor#BSBBU	$19.99	eBay ↗
6	2005 Bowman Chrome · Refractor#353	$19.95	eBay ↗
7	2005 Bowman Chrome · Autograph Refractor#353	$12.74	eBay ↗
8	2015 Topps · Black#618	$9.74	eBay ↗
9	2008 Bowman · Blue#86	$9.60	eBay ↗
10	2005 Bowman Chrome · Autograph#353	$8.25	eBay ↗

Earliest cards (2005)

The earliest Billy Butler cards in our catalog, ranked by value.

Card	Year	Value
2005 Bowman Chrome · Autograph Blue Refractor#353	2005	$20.25
2005 Bowman Sterling · Black Refractor#BSBBU	2005	$19.99
2005 Bowman Chrome · Refractor#353	2005	$19.95
2005 Bowman Chrome · Autograph Refractor#353	2005	$12.74
2005 Bowman Chrome · Autograph#353	2005	$8.25
2005 Bowman's Best · Autograph Blue#103	2005	$6.67
2005 Bowman Chrome · Autograph Xfractor#353	2005	$6.50
2005 Bowman's Best · Autograph Red#103	2005	$5.93

By price

Affordable under $2574 cards

All prices

Card	Year	Value
2012 Panini Prizm · Gold#78	2012	$250.00
2007 SP Authentic · Letter Patch Autograph#137	2007	$22.49
2007 Bowman Sterling · Black Refractor#BS-BB	2007	$21.24
2005 Bowman Chrome · Autograph Blue Refractor#353	2005	$20.25
2005 Bowman Sterling · Black Refractor#BSBBU	2005	$19.99
2005 Bowman Chrome · Refractor#353	2005	$19.95
2005 Bowman Chrome · Autograph Refractor#353	2005	$12.74
2015 Topps · Black#618	2015	$9.74
2008 Bowman · Blue#86	2008	$9.60
2005 Bowman Chrome · Autograph#353	2005	$8.25
2007 Upper Deck Future Stars · Autograph#177	2007	$7.00
2005 Bowman's Best · Autograph Blue#103	2005	$6.67
2005 Bowman Chrome · Autograph Xfractor#353	2005	$6.50
2005 Bowman's Best · Autograph Red#103	2005	$5.93
2005 Bowman's Best · Autograph#103	2005	$5.53

Show all 60 cards in this table

2013 Bowman Chrome · Black Refractor#21	2013	$5.12
2016 Bowman · Orange#63	2016	$4.25
2010 Bowman Chrome#69	2010	$4.10
2016 Bowman · Gold#63	2016	$3.99
2007 Bowman Chrome Draft Picks · Refractor#BDP30	2007	$3.99
2005 Bowman's Best · Autograph Green#103	2005	$3.20
2016 Bowman · Green#63	2016	$3.01
2013 Panini Pinnacle Clear Vision · Triple#CV26	2013	$3.00
2013 Topps · Silver Slate Blue Sparkle#499	2013	$2.99
2014 Donruss#61	2014	$2.99
2011 Bowman#113	2011	$2.60
2007 SP Rookie Edition · 1995 Design Autograph#182	2007	$2.55
2012 Panini Prizm · Green Prizm#78	2012	$2.54
2005 Bowman Chrome#353	2005	$2.50
2010 Bowman Platinum#59	2010	$2.34
2015 Topps · Gold#618	2015	$2.25
2005 Bowman Sterling#BSBBU	2005	$2.13
2007 Topps · Swinging#636	2007	$2.09
2013 Topps · Red#499	2013	$2.08
2008 Bowman Chrome#82	2008	$2.03
2013 Topps · Emerald#499	2013	$2.00
2013 Panini Pinnacle#57	2013	$1.99
2013 Topps · Gold#499	2013	$1.99
2009 Upper Deck Base Set#172	2009	$1.97
2013 Bowman#90	2013	$1.97
2015 Bowman Chrome · Refractor#93	2015	$1.89
2005 Bowman#277	2005	$1.76
2013 Bowman · State & Hometown#90	2013	$1.75
2007 Fleer#415	2007	$1.72
2009 Upper Deck First Edition#132	2009	$1.62
2014 Bowman Chrome · Purple Refractor#139	2014	$1.60
2013 Topps#499	2013	$1.40
2013 Panini Pinnacle Clear Vision · Single#CV26	2013	$1.39
2007 Upper Deck Masterpieces#83	2007	$1.38
2015 Topps#618	2015	$1.25
2016 Bowman · Blue#63	2016	$1.19
2016 Bowman#63	2016	$1.08
2005 Bowman Heritage · Mini#226	2005	$1.04
2013 Bowman · Gold#90	2013	$1.03
2013 Bowman Platinum#72	2013	$1.00
2007 Bowman Sterling#BS-BB	2007	$0.99
2012 Bowman#51	2012	$0.99
2007 Bowman Chrome Draft Picks · Xfractor#BDP30	2007	$0.99
2011 Bowman Platinum#80	2011	$0.85
2005 Bowman Heritage#226	2005	$0.70

Showing the top 60 of 300 cards. View all Billy Butler card prices (300 cards) →

By year

Year	Cards	Top card	Value
2024	12	—	—
2017	3	—	—
2016	17	2016 Bowman #63	$4.25
2015	37	2015 Topps #618	$9.74
2014	18	2014 Donruss #61	$2.99
2013	62	2013 Bowman Chrome #21	$5.12
2012	10	2012 Panini Prizm #78	$250.00
2011	18	2011 Bowman #113	$2.60
2010	8	2010 Bowman Chrome #69	$4.10
2009	5	2009 Upper Deck Base Set #172	$1.97
2008	18	2008 Bowman #86	$9.60
2007	45	2007 SP Authentic #137	$22.49
2006	2	—	—
2005	38	2005 Bowman Chrome #353	$20.25
2004	7	—	—

Live eBay listings

Affiliate — we may earn a commission

Most Valuable Billy Butler Cards Most Valuable Shohei Ohtani Cards Most Valuable Aaron Judge Cards Most Valuable Mike Trout Cards Most Valuable Mitch Keller Cards Most Valuable Justin Steele Cards Most Valuable Seth Hernandez Cards

More Baseball players

Shohei Ohtani cards Aaron Judge cards Mike Trout cards Mitch Keller cards Justin Steele cards Seth Hernandez cards Jhoan Duran cards Catfish Hunter cards Jose Miranda cards Jackie Bradley Jr cards Javy Lopez cards Ruben Sierra cards

Frequently asked questions

How much more is a PSA 10 Billy Butler card worth?: Across Billy Butler cards we track with both raw and PSA 10 prices, a PSA 10 sells for roughly 7.8× the ungraded price, averaging about $32. Grading pristine copies can pay off — check each card's grade ladder first.